Xorxes have a valid point, I am just not sure if the mass claim is better done this EON or the next. For two reasons, first we need all people with unknown items to claim at EON and considering Vecna's and ND (and Worcej if you include him), it's unlikely to work.
Yes, we need to coordinate.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 1:27 pm
Xorxes have a valid point, I am just not sure if the mass claim is better done this EON or the next. For two reasons, first we need all people with unknown items to claim at EON and considering Vecna's and ND (and Worcej if you include him), it's unlikely to work.
Yes, but the claimant will (almost) be clear themself. The longer we wait, the less clearing the claim will be.Second point is nurse is only used when it did a save and if it's not used tonight and we mass claim, it's lost as scum can roleblocked it forever.
Have you considered this drawbacks?
worcej, is this actually why you switched? because of me town-reading ND?
I still think the (lack of) coordination is the biggest risk. Scum doesn't know what item the NK have, so I think it's worth to wait another day to give a possible nurse an extra chance.xorxes wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 1:40 pmYes, we need to coordinate.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 1:27 pm
Xorxes have a valid point, I am just not sure if the mass claim is better done this EON or the next. For two reasons, first we need all people with unknown items to claim at EON and considering Vecna's and ND (and Worcej if you include him), it's unlikely to work.
Yes, but the claimant will (almost) be clear themself. The longer we wait, the less clearing the claim will be.Second point is nurse is only used when it did a save and if it's not used tonight and we mass claim, it's lost as scum can roleblocked it forever.
Have you considered this drawbacks?
But yes, it probably does make sense to wait another day.
Indeedrdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 2:43 pmThis I agree, if Yav can be cleared scum will have a hard task ahead.
PST, I drink a lot, and work. I also have a tendency to lurk in my Mafia games, because I like to watch people fray out at each other instead of goading it. There are a lot of people who have played a lot and I am trying to learn their tendencies to get an idea of the type of player they are and it's much easier to do this without goading it.
I did not like either wagon. I think they were shit but I was not about to get people to move off either of them. My strongest scum read, knowing I'll still get flamed for it again, is Durga but no one cares still. The possible buddy I find her to possibly have is Vecna - I feel like he is being incredibly distant. He did say he would be not around much, but this is some high-level lurking. His posts yesterday boiled down to one that protects ND, then pushes a 4-man group only, which includes me. Recent posts have been almost wagon starters, with little details as to what is scummy about going on.
What I took from D1 Squiggs is he stfu because he knew he was outed and did not want to create/clear any more people by defending. As several have said, he went after me early and pushed for it and if he would've kept going it could've allowed more analysis on who to go for.
Opinion on ghug, rdrivera & ND ?worcej wrote: ↑Thu Sep 13, 2018 2:54 pmPST, I drink a lot, and work. I also have a tendency to lurk in my Mafia games, because I like to watch people fray out at each other instead of goading it. There are a lot of people who have played a lot and I am trying to learn their tendencies to get an idea of the type of player they are and it's much easier to do this without goading it.I did not like either wagon. I think they were shit but I was not about to get people to move off either of them. My strongest scum read, knowing I'll still get flamed for it again, is Durga but no one cares still. The possible buddy I find her to possibly have is Vecna - I feel like he is being incredibly distant. He did say he would be not around much, but this is some high-level lurking. His posts yesterday boiled down to one that protects ND, then pushes a 4-man group only, which includes me. Recent posts have been almost wagon starters, with little details as to what is scummy about going on.
A distant second is xorxes due to pushing for item identity instead of scum players. We have few items in play, assuming they still are, that will town-clear anyone.
My town clears are brain/damo/y2k based entirely off their claims and lack of CC's. I think flash acted as town with his shot, because it was quick once the MF read was public. I believe Demon is town and yavu is also, but neither has played very towny to make me go all-in with those ideas.
So, TL;DR: my 3 I'd like to see go are Durga/Vecna/xorxes, in that order of preference.What I took from D1 Squiggs is he stfu because he knew he was outed and did not want to create/clear any more people by defending. As several have said, he went after me early and pushed for it and if he would've kept going it could've allowed more analysis on who to go for.
MF was quick and a dirty kill, so not much to gain from his play.
At this point, I also believe the repair kit was out of play and we will gain nothing off of it. I am skeptical of the Electro-Shield, but maybe it is still out there. Doctor's kit is somewhat unknown too... I do believe y2k had one, under the correct assumption BB would know.
Users browsing this forum: Aristocrat, Bing [Bot], brainbomb
