Ok…sweetandcool wrote: ↑Tue May 23, 2023 6:48 pmThe case for ghug being Town:
During N2, ghug asks Haze to please convince them that they are town, because they feel they must vote Haze D3 and they don't like it.
Haze replies by clearly communicating (only to ghug) that they RB ghug: Link . You can continue with peterbot to see that Haze makes other very obvious comments. At this point, we can safely conclude that ghug knows that Haze RB ghug on N1 and consequently that Haze is captain.
So how do we explain Spy X's visit to Haze on N2? The most likely explanation is that it was clear to Mafia that Haze was some sort of PR and they wanted to figure out what they were.
Is there any explanation that makes sense for X to visit Haze, if his teammate ghug knows Haze is captain? Not really. There are two possibilities and they both make no sense.
1. X didn't log in on time to change their order from pointlessly scanning Haze.
REBUTTAL: X was active on the thread plenty after Haze outted themself to ghug. ghug would have had X adjust their action to be more useful.
2. Mafia wanted to verify Haze's role.
REBUTTAL: But there is absolutely no way ghug DIDN'T know Haze's role. This is pointless.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONCLUSION: I can't believe I'm actually saying this, but the way N1 played out and ghug simultaneously being RB by Haze seems to have been a coincidence.
We absolutely need to find a new wagon. ##UNVOTE
(see ghug, this is why hammering is a stupid suggestion)
So why are you voting yourself?