MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[Bonatogether]

This is basically my pool atm:
Bonatogether
Jamiet99uk
President Eden
rdrivera2005
sweetandcool

Where you think the mafia is?

Within that group. Sorry, to be clear I townread Damo, Bozo, Snowy, and you.

respectable

[Bonatogether]

I don't want to screw up like last time and say nothing for EoN, since I'm confident I won't be available.

Townie:

Damo (insightful when they post, clearly town)
Bona (self-explanatory)

Neutral-Positive:

Dousing (constantly tunneling, easy to manipulate, yet obviously sincere)
Jamiet (good vibes)
Bozo (insightful, but not enough posts to get a great read)

Neutral/Null:

Rdr

Negative:

President Eden (I just don't trust them, they seem to be pocketing)
Mafia:

Snowy (kind of seems like they got more active because of criticism of coasting, but I could be wrong here).
Chaqa (seems like it must be true)

why are you unvoting

[President Eden]

god we’re really gonna have to wait for him to do this aren’t we

[Bonatogether]

I'm not asking this to criticize you but to let you develop this a bit further.

How likely do you think it is that the mafia team is exactly snowy, Chaqa, and me?

President Eden, are you a teacher IRL? Just getting that vibe.

I wanted to be one once, if that counts! And I expect my midlife crisis pivot to be teaching law instead of practicing it

Since I'm not familiar with y'all, it's hard for me to be able to find much reason to believe or disbelieve the possibility of a particular team combo.

I also don't recall any of you bussing each other much. And honestly, even then it doesn't mean much. Dousing and I could be mafia and committed to hard bussing each other

But honestly, I'm most confident about Chaqa. Their voting pattern has been extremely suspicious.

Sure, you wouldn't know anything about our tendencies as players or as potential teammates. But based on what you've put together about the incentives mafia might have to do certain things - whatever you may have put together so far - does the behavior of snowy, Chaqa, and me toward each other reflect the possibility of us being teammates?

Regarding the underlined - I would say I've pushed Chaqa reasonably strongly, Chaqa has pushed back (though I think less strongly), and snowy has at least tried to keep me as a potential daykill. Do you agree with that assessment, and why or why not?

mafia theory posting is scummy

[Bonatogether]

god we’re really gonna have to wait for him to do this aren’t we

i am going to backread all 20 pages right now

[Bonatogether]

After this night its gonna be
5 town
3 mafia

A little scary because town loses if we vote wrong D3 yeah?

true

Not true. And stop giving away free info.

i don't follow

[Bonatogether]

You may have a point.

I've thought about this some more. If Eden is scum I very much doubt Chaqa or Jamie is.

Current thinking Eden plus 2 from {sweet, Bona, X} where X is one of {Dousing, bozo, rdr, snowy}

OR

3 from {sweet, Bona, Y} where Y is X plus Jamie and Chaqa.

I think tomorrow should be between Eden Bona and sweet assuming they all survive the night (I expect the NK to be me, rdr, bozo or possibly Dousing).

Damo, I think you are town and I need to understand your reasons to clear Chaqa and Snowy (at some extent). Right now I have both as scum.

Tomorrow it will be mylo and we need to consolidate somehow because there is little margin for town not voting together.

i think you're scum

[bozotheclown]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

Why do you think Bonatogether would fail to claim a RB as mafia?

[Bonatogether]

shit there's a tie

Now is this reaction actually "shit there's a tie"?

Or is it "shit, my team-mate Eden is in danger"?

How often do people make actual scumslips like that?

I just don't see any reason to believe the reaction is anything other than what it seems.

i can see why people think you're scum

[Bonatogether]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

you had me as one of your top town not 20 pages ago you smoothbrain

[President Eden]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

Why do you think Bonatogether would fail to claim a RB as mafia?

idk

I’d have claimed it as either alignment

he’s 100% lying barring some absurd misunderstanding though

[Bonatogether]

bozo vote

Bozo had voted. Why were you hectoring him to vote?

The total collapse of the Chaqa wagon is part of the puzzle in my view, and here you were, Bona, hustling Bozo to move off Chaqa.

i thought he hadn't voted

[President Eden]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

you had me as one of your top town not 20 pages ago you smoothbrain

lying about not being rb’d tends to change that

[Bonatogether]

or at least made a real vote

[Bonatogether]

##vote koala

you're next

Interesting remark since you sat squarely on Koala while President Eden was the main rival wagon at the end.

my plan was (and remains) koala d2, eden d3

[sweetandcool]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

you had me as one of your top town not 20 pages ago you smoothbrain

Never heard that insult before. How clever, smoothbrain, implying that they haven't developed very many neurons.

[Bonatogether]

I guess it was self-preservation?

I'm aware you were playing on Twitch or something for most of the few hours up to EoD.

Yea. I actually tried to catch up, and I'd said to myself that if I saw Koala switch to me that I'd switch to him, because I assumed it would start a cascade that would make it me vs him. Then as I opened the new message screen I realized it was x:59 so I just voted him and said fuck it I'll catch up later if I'm alive.

Honestly, this tracks. Koala was already the clear vote, and if Eden was mafia it doesn't make sense they would make that last second vote, since it accomplished nothing.

[Bonatogether]

spicy

##VOTE Bonatogether

Why do you think Bonatogether would fail to claim a RB as mafia?

idk

I’d have claimed it as either alignment

he’s 100% lying barring some absurd misunderstanding though

i don't know what you're talking about so i'll just get to it later

[Dousing]

ratio

yea whatever kid just confirm I rb’d you n1 already

i wasn't rbed at all this game

Oh my god folks! The plot has THICKENED!

[Bonatogether]

Yea. I actually tried to catch up, and I'd said to myself that if I saw Koala switch to me that I'd switch to him, because I assumed it would start a cascade that would make it me vs him. Then as I opened the new message screen I realized it was x:59 so I just voted him and said fuck it I'll catch up later if I'm alive.

Honestly, this tracks. Koala was already the clear vote, and if Eden was mafia it doesn't make sense they would make that last second vote, since it accomplished nothing.

this is a TERRIBLE reaction