MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[Jamiet99uk]

is this what it's like to be on the sidelines of epic wallpost arguments?

because i am so sorry fellas

Apology accepted. But yes you have done this in the past.

[Jamiet99uk]

We’re going hiking tomorrow, so I don’t know exactly what time I’ll be around. Hopefully a few hours before EOD but no guarantees.

You and Eden are going hiking?

[Jamiet99uk]

Is this what it is like to be on the sidelines of epic wallpost arguments?

because i am so sorry fellas

Wade on in, the waters warm. I'd love to hear your thoughts on President Eden, Koala and Snowy. Happy to hear about others too.

Asking President Eden if he scumreads or townreads himself?

Odd question to ask.

[Jamiet99uk]

Thank you. I get what you are saying and agree with your premise. I'm letting the experienced players settle their feelings about chaqa because it's a little out of my depth.

you should never have a filter in mafia because a primary goal is to towntell to others

Based.
Extremely based.

[Jamiet99uk]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

He's town.

[Jamiet99uk]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

Admired by the ladies, successful/sexy businessman. Squeaky keen. Did I miss any relevant details?

I like this sweet cool person.

[Jamiet99uk]

Also I just finished d1 and I say we kill eden

##vote Eden

This is the kind of action I can get behind.

##Vote President Eden

[Jamiet99uk]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

Seems hard to believe d1 Jamie is ever scum

When was the last time you ever saw him post more than Bona? And most of that came while the bot was down and most people were on cruise control

He’s been less memorable today for me but I don’t think that matters much. And it could be an indictment of my lack of focus lol.

During Friday I took a lovely friend out to lunch and then she wanted to take a nice long slow walk in Regent's Park because it was a sunny spring day, so we did that. Hence for several hours I had no attention for the game really. I posted a little from the train, but when my train finally got me back to Durham, there was no internet at home because of a British Telecom fault, and I just went to bed. I'm catching up now.

[Jamiet99uk]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

Seems hard to believe d1 Jamie is ever scum

When was the last time you ever saw him post more than Bona? And most of that came while the bot was down and most people were on cruise control

He’s been less memorable today for me but I don’t think that matters much. And it could be an indictment of my lack of focus lol.

I am fairly certain Jamie has posted a lot in games as mafia.

Bozo's pretty much right here. My post count is not alignment indicative.

[Jamiet99uk]

Conclusion: Koala hasn't been goofing off much this game. So that's already a striking difference between previous game's town Koala and this game's (Mafia) Koala.

This is an interesting point.

Koala invested a whole lot of the sign-up thread in saying how he was going to develop this "Gandalf" persona for this game. Then a little way into D1 he just sort of dropped it.

[Jamiet99uk]

I won't pretend that I like people agreeing with me. That's why I am currently very suspicious of President Eden. I think they egged me on when I was accusing Fox.

I'm surprised nobody has pointed out the following, because it's something I have been feeling self-conscious about and I think you are referencing, but my main suspects have also been the two who have attacked me; Fox and Koala (I attacked Fox first, yes).

My fuel against Fox was that they didn't seem to address my concern but rather tried to discredit me, something Mafia would do (turn accusations against the accuser).

My fuel against Koala is that they seem to be doing exactly that against Bonatogether (in addition to other Koala behaviours). Bonatogether made a well thought out post and Koala just hand waved it away. They have not substantially made any argument as to why they are not Mafia. The fact that they pushed against me is irrelevant, especially since I have agreed with the base of their argument that newness should not be a shield against suspicion.

I think it's unfair to say I've been pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill. Yes, I made a mention about damo but acknowledged it as a conspiracy theory and haven't really mentioned it since. I think it's good to at least point suspicious things out, as long as I acknowledge that it's a bit of a reach.

Same with President Eden. Yes, I'm currently voting for them. But again, I've mentioned something that seems out of place, but have acknowledged that it's not super substantial. I would like discussion on it, and then if the discussion is satisfactory I will probably change my vote.

SCUMSLIP!!!!

Where do you see a scumslip in any of what sweet'n'cool posted there, Damo?

[Jamiet99uk]

Wait, I see something.

I think it's unfair to say I've been pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill.

@Sweetandcool:

Who accused you of "pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill" ? Which player said this, and in which post(s)?

[damo666]

Wait, I see something.

I think it's unfair to say I've been pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill.

@Sweetandcool:

Who accused you of "pushing for a damo and/or President Eden misskill" ? Which player said this, and in which post(s)?

The word 'miskill' could be a scumslip.

[snowy801]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

Why did you solicit other people's responses to Koala's post, but not respond to i t yourself?

Because I know what I think, and there's nothing to respond to there anyway

[snowy801]

Ladies & Gentlemen, I present to you – The Case of Bona

For context, we are talking about this post of mine:

Speaking of reasons why I actually believe something, I direct people to review this comment

Which Snowy used as reason to hardlock me as Mafia.

And what is Bona's ultimate response to this entire discussion?

isn't the post by snowy clearly a reference to mafia the game?

this entire post falls under the same category as I documented of 'obfuscating through misrepresentation' as I understand it, just on a different (and easier) target

In other words, Bona is basically saying I am full of shit and Snowy is right.

OK... coolio... So, I'm full of shit and Snowy is right.

That means that my original post was indeed a Mafia claim, riiight?

Because I can only know that Bona is Mafia for sure if I'm Mafia myself, riiiight?

Yet it's the same Bona who is taking Snowy's side?

I am pretty sure there it at least one mafia caught here – and it ain't me.

Any of you logical types, please double-check my thinking above. Am I crazy?

Ok I was wrong.

It was not interesting.

Bona was commenting about a different post. Whether his comment was correct or not, it related to the one where Snowy called him a "mafia player" (i.e. someone who is playing the game of mafia, not someone who is of mafia alignment).

Now, I don't agree with Bona's take on that. I think Snowy was implying Bona to be scum. But this is irrelevant to the mistaken "logic" presented by Koala above.

Bona had it right. Implications of alignment would've seen me use the word scum instead

[snowy801]

I lied haven't slept again yet, trying to

How do people feel about JimothyT

He's town.

Source?

[snowy801]

damo you had a fairly inconclusive eod1 analysis posted last night

Given the NK and the game progression, have you formed any further conclusions on that matter as the major counterwagon?

[rdrivera2005]

I am having a hard time keeping up with this game. I just feel people are over focused on words and little details instead of trying to look at motivations and reasoning.

The best case is still Bozo's on Chaqa, which reaction to just duck and wait to see if it vanish doesn't make feel is a wrong one.

Snowy keeps probing everyone like sensing the waters to see where a wagon could develop, I just don't remember town Snowy playing this way. He asked me a ton of things after I called him on not doing this and when I answered (including some questions to him) he just ignored it.

[snowy801]

I am having a hard time keeping up with this game. I just feel people are over focused on words and little details instead of trying to look at motivations and reasoning.

The best case is still Bozo's on Chaqa, which reaction to just duck and wait to see if it vanish doesn't make feel is a wrong one.

Snowy keeps probing everyone like sensing the waters to see where a wagon could develop, I just don't remember town Snowy playing this way. He asked me a ton of things after I called him on not doing this and when I answered (including some questions to him) he just ignored it.

You can't recall me playing this way. You mean to tell me that you, rdrivera2000, can't recall me playing this way.

[Jamiet99uk]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

Why did you solicit other people's responses to Koala's post, but not respond to i t yourself?

Because I know what I think, and there's nothing to respond to there anyway

You are bad at telling the rest of us what you think.

In any case, if there is "nothing to respond to", what thoughts do you expect Rdr to have?