MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[damo666]

I'm the only person apart from scum who knows yesterday ended up as TvT. Gonna do some VCA and will post findings shortly.

[snowy801]

I'm the only person apart from scum who knows yesterday ended up as TvT. Gonna do some VCA and will post findings shortly.

pog damonalysis

[damo666]

Day 1 VCA

If there was any 'saving' it was of Koala or Bona (or both).

Observations on each player's votes:

Bona - poss bus of Koala but no sign of panic when K went to 3 votes 2 minutes out.

Bozo: very late switch to from Bona to Fox probably tie avoidance (there being the possibility of a switch from Fox to me).

Chaqa - slight possibilty of short bus on K but that seems a little pointless. Late switch almost certainly tie avoidance.

Dousing - voted K throughout.

ghug - nothing much, the late move from me to Chaqa probably a combo of tie avoidance and not wanting to vote Fox

Jamie - I think he simply townread Fox and incorrectly scumread me

Koala - bizarrely kept on sweet which was going nowhere. Smacks of not wanting to be on the TvT top wagons. Highly suspicious imo.

Eden - seems fixated on me. Could easily be scum driving a mk. Could he be that misguided as town?

rdr - consistently on Fox.

snowy - slight possibilty of bussing Bona and getting cold feet although I doubt it.

sweet - On Fox from hours out.

Conclusions: Koala is the most suspicious but anybody could be scum.

I think we should kill either Bona or Koala tomorrow unless the NK sheds light.

[Chaqa]

I want to vote for Bona or Fox. Voting the new player day 1 is too cliche

I'll vote Fox to save Bona.

What changed your position on Bonatogether?

One of his posts during the lead up to EoD.

[Chaqa]

I went back to find the post but I couldn't.

[President Eden]

By the way, I've read the setup and I wanted to know if we know whether Mafia took any powers? Somehow I got the impression we knew they took nothing, but now it seems there is no way for us to know until concrete evidence turns up. Is that correct?

Disregard my response as I forgot how the recruit traitor worked

there was a prechat? that changes the game

This was a quick succession of questionable town telling.

Bona’s is obviously fake but he seems town anyway, mine wasn’t really a towntell (but hey, whatever gets you to the right answer). S&C I could believe, though if I’m being honest I TR him independently and am not viewing this in a vacuum

[Jamiet99uk]

Koala - bizarrely kept on sweet which was going nowhere. Smacks of not wanting to be on the TvT top wagons. Highly suspicious imo.

Conclusions: Koala is the most suspicious but anybody could be scum.

I think we should kill either Bona or Koala tomorrow unless the NK sheds light.

This is interesting work and I would to see Koala's response.

[President Eden]

koala feels like he's hopping onto the foxcastle train on sweetncool in a way that i don't like

so how do you process the fox-s&c-koala trio?

because you hated my argument for fox being mafia and s&c being town, but this post + a couple others suggests you are suspicious of fox & koala, which supports that theory

i like fox but not entirely
i think sweetandcool's argument doesn't make sense and he's generally offbeat so i lean towards scumreading him especially as he's experienced
koalers felt like he's orienting towards these dorks in a specific way that's scum indicative to me

your argument read backwards to my understanding of the situation

@chaqa was it this one maybe? bc this spoke to me

[Chaqa]

so how do you process the fox-s&c-koala trio?

because you hated my argument for fox being mafia and s&c being town, but this post + a couple others suggests you are suspicious of fox & koala, which supports that theory

i like fox but not entirely
i think sweetandcool's argument doesn't make sense and he's generally offbeat so i lean towards scumreading him especially as he's experienced
koalers felt like he's orienting towards these dorks in a specific way that's scum indicative to me

your argument read backwards to my understanding of the situation

@chaqa was it this one maybe? bc this spoke to me

IDK maybe it was more general vibes. I was pretty high

[President Eden]

i like fox but not entirely
i think sweetandcool's argument doesn't make sense and he's generally offbeat so i lean towards scumreading him especially as he's experienced
koalers felt like he's orienting towards these dorks in a specific way that's scum indicative to me

your argument read backwards to my understanding of the situation

@chaqa was it this one maybe? bc this spoke to me

IDK maybe it was more general vibes. I was pretty high

That explains a lot

[Jamiet99uk]

@chaqa was it this one maybe? bc this spoke to me

IDK maybe it was more general vibes. I take a shitload of drugs.

That explains a lot.

La da da da la da da la la da da

Chaq was gonna find scum, until he got high
Gonna get some scumreads down, but then he got high
Mis-killed a foxy town, and I know why (why man?)
'Cause he got high
Because he got high
'Cause Chaqa got high

[Chaqa]

If we do have a vig, I think shooting tonight is the best play.

[President Eden]

If we do have a vig, I think shooting tonight is the best play.

We get it, you’re the vig

[Bonatogether]

it literally was not a drive by vote

i spent the entirety of the last hour saying i thought you were scum

Awesome! Can you please summarize your actual case? Because repeating a case-less vote is just machine gun drive by. What make sit not a drive by is a case that everyone can read and evaluate.

no, i already posted that

[Bonatogether]

Damo did nothing to make me think he was town.

I missed the 4 or so hours leading up to EoD as I made clear.

I asked for summaries of the top wagons and nobody responded. NOTE THAT NOBODY TRIED TO PERSUADE ME TO VOTE FOX.

I wanted to pick a major wagon and Damo felt the best due to his total lack of effort. Fox was a townlean for me.

you should have voted koala

oh well, into the scumbucket with you

There wasn't a viable Koala wagon.

I scumread Damo more, anyway.

it would have been if you had voted him

[Bonatogether]

By the way, I've read the setup and I wanted to know if we know whether Mafia took any powers? Somehow I got the impression we knew they took nothing, but now it seems there is no way for us to know until concrete evidence turns up. Is that correct?

Disregard my response as I forgot how the recruit traitor worked

there was a prechat? that changes the game

This was a quick succession of questionable town telling.

Bona’s is obviously fake but he seems town anyway, mine wasn’t really a towntell (but hey, whatever gets you to the right answer). S&C I could believe, though if I’m being honest I TR him independently and am not viewing this in a vacuum

you're a clown

[Bonatogether]

If we do have a vig, I think shooting tonight is the best play.

shooting early is always based

[Chaqa]

If we do have a vig, I think shooting tonight is the best play.

We get it, you’re the vig

I would have shot Jamie already

[ghug]

That was bad and you should all feel bad.

If you preferred to DK Bonatogether, why did you vote for rdrivera 14 minutes before EOD? Your voting pattern for Bonatogether looks a lot like M78.

I was mimicking my town behavior in M78, though I think drawing the comparison is fair.

I didn't feel that strongly about Bona. It's more specifically killing Fox that I dislike.

[ghug]

I dunno if a chaqa vanity wagon is any better tbh

I wanted an odd number of votes on the two wagons because latebreaking tiebreak votes seemed likely.

I don't see how 4-3 is better than 5-3 when there were players not voting for either Foxcastle or damo. KoalaAttack also had 3 votes, so you made it 4-3-3.

I think I brought the odds of a tie down with my vote.