MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[snowy801]

unsure how your phone autocorrected damo to Eden but this looks right

Your conclusion from eod1 is that damo is scum?

Yeah. His name was floated around for coasting, then he became a real counterwagon to Fox who flipped town, then people found “reasons” to vote elsewhere when the dice were truly cast at EOD. Quintessential scum wagon d1

But if damo is scum wouldn't there only be 1 other scum around to do that?

Or do you still subscribe to recruited traitor worldview

[snowy801]

By the way, I've read the setup and I wanted to know if we know whether Mafia took any powers? Somehow I got the impression we knew they took nothing, but now it seems there is no way for us to know until concrete evidence turns up. Is that correct?

worcej knows but he won't tell us. sad!

He might at this rate of GM posts

[President Eden]

Your conclusion from eod1 is that damo is scum?

Yeah. His name was floated around for coasting, then he became a real counterwagon to Fox who flipped town, then people found “reasons” to vote elsewhere when the dice were truly cast at EOD. Quintessential scum wagon d1

But if damo is scum wouldn't there only be 1 other scum around to do that?

Or do you still subscribe to recruited traitor worldview

I do subscribe to recruited traitor view

Going from only 2 voices to 3 is a big deal, and you offset the town getting a PR by needing one fewer miskill

[Bonatogether]

Can we be productive?

How would we go about learning the power distribution? Do we wait until someone uses a power, a role player gets killed, or what?

And if we're going to start throwing accusations, can we give actual reasoning? Like right now some of you are going to President Eden, so maybe you could weigh in on what I said about them just a bit ago?

we learn through roles flipping and claiming as the game progresses

[Bonatogether]

unsure how your phone autocorrected damo to Eden but this looks right

Your conclusion from eod1 is that damo is scum?

Yeah. His name was floated around for coasting, then he became a real counterwagon to Fox who flipped town, then people found “reasons” to vote elsewhere when the dice were truly cast at EOD. Quintessential scum wagon d1

but DAMO didn't do shit

[President Eden]

Disregard my response as I forgot how the recruit traitor worked

[sweetandcool]

Who does everybody think the most likely Mafia kill will be tonight? And can we draw any conclusions based on choice?

[Bonatogether]

damo was a shitty wagon so idk why you're proud of this

Damo did nothing to make me think he was town.

I missed the 4 or so hours leading up to EoD as I made clear.

I asked for summaries of the top wagons and nobody responded. NOTE THAT NOBODY TRIED TO PERSUADE ME TO VOTE FOX.

I wanted to pick a major wagon and Damo felt the best due to his total lack of effort. Fox was a townlean for me.

you should have voted koala

oh well, into the scumbucket with you

[Bonatogether]

My top scumreads right now are Snowy and Damo, and anyone reading my posts should know why.

i read your posts but i didn't retain the information in them

[snowy801]

Who does everybody think the most likely Mafia kill will be tonight? And can we draw any conclusions based on choice?

Let's not talk about this

[President Eden]

Actually snowy, I realize it doesn’t matter whether they recruited traitor or not, the traitor knows the teammates (see role PM in OP). So as long as damo is a not-traitor mafia then there are 2 other teammates that could be involved, which I think is enough

So I conclude damo isn’t traitor but is a decent shot to flip mafia

[snowy801]

Actually snowy, I realize it doesn’t matter whether they recruited traitor or not, the traitor knows the teammates (see role PM in OP). So as long as damo is a not-traitor mafia then there are 2 other teammates that could be involved, which I think is enough

So I conclude damo isn’t traitor but is a decent shot to flip mafia

Perhaps

What was that thing you mentioned about not understanding how traitors work earlier

[damo666]

Who does everybody think the most likely Mafia kill will be tonight? And can we draw any conclusions based on choice?

Not useful to try guess before the event. Analysing why a particular player was NKd can be fruitful.

[Bonatogether]

Who does everybody think the most likely Mafia kill will be tonight? And can we draw any conclusions based on choice?

not something we need to discuss and also something we can't learn much from -> kills are made based on the players doing the killing and the player being killed and their relationship. you first have to guess a scumteam, then within that world, make a guess, in the process revealing information about your own worldview, and you don't get much info from it, so it's not really worth it

[Bonatogether]

i'm going to read the OP

[President Eden]

Actually snowy, I realize it doesn’t matter whether they recruited traitor or not, the traitor knows the teammates (see role PM in OP). So as long as damo is a not-traitor mafia then there are 2 other teammates that could be involved, which I think is enough

So I conclude damo isn’t traitor but is a decent shot to flip mafia

Perhaps

What was that thing you mentioned about not understanding how traitors work earlier

I got momentarily confused from misreading your post and thought that there would only be two mafia at all unless they selected to have a traitor in pregame

I blame a long work day, a restless teenage son and probably blame ghug a second time for good measure

[Bonatogether]

there was a prechat? that changes the game

[Bonatogether]

they can get daychat? there's no reason to not take that

[sweetandcool]

there was a prechat? that changes the game

I assume so since they got 24 hours to decide powers.

[Bonatogether]

there was a prechat? that changes the game

I assume so since they got 24 hours to decide powers.

it's in the setup