MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[flash2015]

damo, why did you wait until N2 to send the birthday card?

I think I have missed something (busy day at work, fast read on the last 6 pages), but where did you see that Damo sent the birthday card?

DemonRHK scumread Damo, then said he received the birthday card, then he said damo was confirmed town...thus damo must have sent the birthday card.

[rdrivera2005]

I want to vote Ghug, but with the slime in play I am not sure it's a good idea to pile oh him early.

[flash2015]

damo, why did you wait until N2 to send the birthday card?

I think I have missed something (busy day at work, fast read on the last 6 pages), but where did you see that Damo sent the birthday card?

DemonRHK scumread Damo, then said he received the birthday card, then he said damo was confirmed town...thus damo must have sent the birthday card.

To DemonRHK

[ghug]

Y'all need to spend less time thinking about where items could be and more time thinking about the game.

Relevant item information:
Barring counterclaim, brain and y2k are conftown
Damo is town unless RHK is scum
Flash is very likely town
Durga is likely town

That's it

We just lynched scum, and another one flipped. That's where we're going to catch the next scum too. If you want to vote for me for that, go right ahead. If you want to vote for me for this Alex Jones item bullshit, feel free to go fuck yourself.

Excluding myself and those soft- or hard- cleared listed above, we have two scum in:
DemonRHK
ND
rdrivera2005
yavuzovic
Tom Bombadil
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

Xorxes has either improved drastically at feigning effort as scum (entirely possible, but less likely than the alternative), or is town. Worcej had an organic reaction to brain's claim and then went hard on Squigs all day, so I'm pretty comfortable clearing him too. My logic clearing Vecna for the Squigs reads stands. We should be lynching between the other five and me at least today and probably tomorrow as well. Add Vecna back in if you don't buy my logic, but it's great logic, so you should just listen it me.

I think Rivera is the likeliest scum of the group and RHK the least likely. I could be talked into lynching any of the other three if Rivera is no fly, but I'd rather just kill him.

[rdrivera2005]

Thanks Xorxes and Flash. This clears Damo and also give town points to RHK.

[y2kjbk]

I want to vote Ghug, but with the slime in play I am not sure it's a good idea to pile oh him early.

Scum having and activating slime would mean either scum are not slimed and change the lynch and out themselves effectively, or they slime themselves and town should want to maintain the lynch chosen by the slimed people.

I can't stay away from this game when I'm town lol. Lynch the hell out of me whenever I lurk, no matter what excuse I make.

[rdrivera2005]

Y'all need to spend less time thinking about where items could be and more time thinking about the game.

Relevant item information:
Barring counterclaim, brain and y2k are conftown
Damo is town unless RHK is scum
Flash is very likely town
Durga is likely town

That's it

We just lynched scum, and another one flipped. That's where we're going to catch the next scum too. If you want to vote for me for that, go right ahead. If you want to vote for me for this Alex Jones item bullshit, feel free to go fuck yourself.

Excluding myself and those soft- or hard- cleared listed above, we have two scum in:
DemonRHK
ND
rdrivera2005
yavuzovic
Tom Bombadil
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

Xorxes has either improved drastically at feigning effort as scum (entirely possible, but less likely than the alternative), or is town. Worcej had an organic reaction to brain's claim and then went hard on Squigs all day, so I'm pretty comfortable clearing him too. My logic clearing Vecna for the Squigs reads stands. We should be lynching between the other five and me at least today and probably tomorrow as well. Add Vecna back in if you don't buy my logic, but it's great logic, so you should just listen it me.

I think Rivera is the likeliest scum of the group and RHK the least likely. I could be talked into lynching any of the other three if Rivera is no fly, but I'd rather just kill him.

First decent post I see from you. And I agree with you that the lynch pool is basically this and that the theory where you fake claim to have been stolen is complete nonsense.

[xorxes]

Damo is town unless RHK is scum

No unless there from you.

If they are both scum, then faking a birthday card is the most stupid thing they could do unless they really had the card (stolen from bozo), but that can't have happened from your point of view, so for you damo is town no matter what.

[ghug]

Damo is town unless RHK is scum

No unless there from you.

If they are both scum, then faking a birthday card is the most stupid thing they could do unless they really had the card (stolen from bozo), but that can't have happened from your point of view, so for you damo is town no matter what.

The piece you're missing here is how low my opinion is of both of them.

[rdrivera2005]

Damo is town unless RHK is scum

No unless there from you.

If they are both scum, then faking a birthday card is the most stupid thing they could do unless they really had the card (stolen from bozo), but that can't have happened from your point of view, so for you damo is town no matter what.

The piece you're missing here is how low my opinion is of both of them.

This is not a matter of opinion. Xorxes have a valid point and your answer is bullshit.

[flash2015]

OK, I will join the wagon:

##VOTE ghug

[xorxes]

I want to vote Ghug, but with the slime in play I am not sure it's a good idea to pile oh him early.

Scum having and activating slime would mean either scum are not slimed and change the lynch and out themselves effectively, or they slime themselves and town should want to maintain the lynch chosen by the slimed people.

I can't stay away from this game when I'm town lol. Lynch the hell out of me whenever I lurk, no matter what excuse I make.

The slime activator is slimed as well, so at most one scum would be left out of the slime. I wouldn't worry about scum using the slime at this stage at all.

[y2kjbk]

I recommend thief come forward and confirm ghug's claim or not, if you're alive. Based on adjudication rules, bozo could have been the thief that targeted ghug. Squigs or MF as well. Doubtful it was Chaqa.

[rdrivera2005]

I recommend thief come forward and confirm ghug's claim or not, if you're alive. Based on adjudication rules, bozo could have been the thief that targeted ghug. Squigs or MF as well. Doubtful it was Chaqa.

Squigs can't, otherwise he would still be alive.

[y2kjbk]

Good point.

[y2kjbk]

Well, that assumes ghug is telling the truth about his replacement head.

[ghug]

No unless there from you.

If they are both scum, then faking a birthday card is the most stupid thing they could do unless they really had the card (stolen from bozo), but that can't have happened from your point of view, so for you damo is town no matter what.

The piece you're missing here is how low my opinion is of both of them.

This is not a matter of opinion. Xorxes have a valid point and your answer is bullshit.

His point is that they'd have to be pretty damn stupid to do it as scum, which is one of the reasons I'm advocating against lynching both of them. That list only gives certainties as certainties.

[brainbomb]

Guys uhhh worjec or whatever actually might be scum.

After I claimed scan on moscow
Squiggs voted worcej as soon as the cannon killed moscow

Reread Start Day 1

[ghug]

The theif should absolutely not claim right now. It gives mafia someone to target and doesn't tell us anything about my alignment.

The thief should claim if I'm lying, but I'm not, so that's a moot point.

[brainbomb]

Squoggs accused worcej of flaking on my claim