M1024: Panhandlin' [GAME THREAD]

[Hamilton Brian]

Based on everyone's interaction with Kakarroto, I would say Bonatogether, damo, Fluminator, HB, Jamiet, KoalaAttack, and rdrivera seem more likely to be town (compared to not considering their interaction with Kakarroto). However, that only leaves ghug, worcej, and myself.

Could you give me more specific reasons behind why the interactions look good for these people?

This is a decent line of inquiry and I hope bozo comes around to respond.

Kak interacted, or mentioned, everyone. Like I said earlier, the quality of the interactions was labile.

I, for one, didn't feel like I had a decent interaction with them. So what does bozo "see" that suggests that group is town?

[Hamilton Brian]

Oh no, RIP GHUG

Meh! This whispers "feigned surprise" to me.

[Jamiet99uk]

Oh no, RIP GHUG

Meh! This whispers "feigned surprise" to me.

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

[Hamilton Brian]

Oh no, RIP GHUG

Meh! This whispers "feigned surprise" to me.

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

If you could ever fake the volatility as mafia, you'd be deadly. Of course, your good in either alignment.

Anyway...subtracting yourself, myself, koala, and damo, town would best benefit if ____________ were the Day 2 kill.

Fill in the blank.

[Jamiet99uk]

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

If you could ever fake the volatility as mafia, you'd be deadly. Of course, your good in either alignment.

Anyway...subtracting yourself, myself, koala, and damo, town would best benefit if ____________ were the Day 2 kill.

Fill in the blank.

Can you explain how you have filtered out certain players here?

[worcej]

Oh no, RIP GHUG

Meh! This whispers "feigned surprise" to me.

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

Jamie also RIPs - it’s NAI

Though I do question the authenticities of it based off the ghug jokes.

[KoalaAttack]

I am back for about ~15 min waiting for someone, then gone again rest of night.

Ghug has died. He was Giggles the Oodles of Slipping Giggling Googler, a vanilla townie.

Poop. RIP ghug – sorry we argued so much but I will re-evaluate your points now that I know they were sincere.

[KoalaAttack]

I think it unlikely that I get killed tonight. I also doubt koala gets axed. My two strongest town liens are.Koala and ghug.

Interesting… So – your strongest 2 Town-reads were ghug & myself, who were in the midst of arguing galore with each other.

You say you won’t get killed.
You say I won’t get killed.
You say … nothing about ghug getting killed?

How come?

[KoalaAttack]

if i die kill koalagray

If we win this game, I will promise to become GandalfKoala next game in your honor.

And if we lose, I’ll give you the option to play the next game as GhugKoala – not impersonating, rather trying to play your preferred way as much as possible – but only if you opt in.

[KoalaAttack]

<snip>
Bandersnatch:

(A) I love your Impersonations! If it worked once, keep doing it mate!
(B) I hate your Impersonations, but you do you. Don't fix it if it ain't broken.
(C) Please stop for the love of god. Play the game how ghug & Jamiet want you to play it.
<snip>

Final tally:

(A) 0
(B) 0
(C) 1 – Damo

The (C)s have it, I will be the real KoalaKoala for the duration D2.

If you wish to bring Impersonation back, vote for (A) or (B) and I’ll revisit at day end if I’m still alive.

[Fluminator]

I vote you impersonate Jamiet today

[KoalaAttack]

Anyway I'll be out for an event the rest of tonight, so no more talking from me.

If I die before I wake, "vote for ghug" would be my take.

Waiting for that other shoe to drop, you know.

You're still alive, so congratulations. I guess.

So...on D1, before you ended your voting day with a self-vote (which as town is a horrible, horriblr, awful goddamned play...stop doing that), you had a variety of votes.

You voted at varying times for Bona (not a bad choice, imo), jamie (again, not the worst choice), then TFB.

In your voting pattern ghug never showed up.

So what changed in your thought process so that towards the end of N1 you were content to have your dying wish to be "vote for ghug?"

You are congratulating someone who you just pointed out self-voted-and-AFK-ed-EOD for staying alive? Really?

Part of the reason I did that is I still have zero clue on how I’m supposed to vote on D1 as a Townie. There is so little info, and so much randomness, especially with the shitposting, it feels like roulette... At least when I was Mafia last game I had some clear objectives (though I was pre-occupied voting for Bona to kill the Godfather and take over).

- Bona was a bad attempt at BrainKoala that was a half-joke early on

- Jamie I suspected for his reaction to Impersonation same as Kak, but this was long before Kak was shown to be Mafia, so I didn’t believe in my own theory as much yet

- TFB was again poor BrainKoala coupled with sheeping of others saying TFB seems off

None of these were good cases at the time.

Cliff-notes of Koala vs ghug argument galore from my POV
Koala: I suspect Jamiet for such-and-such
ghug: Koala is not solving
Koala: I also suspect ghug for such-and-such
ghug: Koala is not solving
Koala: yes I am, look I suspect you ghug
ghug: you are doing it wrong, bad case, I’m innocent
Koala: do you have a better theory case you can give in instead?
ghug: nope, it’s too early for me to share anything solid with you yet
Koala: OK then, if I die vote ghug
ghug: right back at ya

So this made my list of suspects at the time be: (1) ghug, (2) Jamiet

But now I am going to go back and re-read Townie ghug and see if that helps me re-evaluate Jamiet or introduce new suspects...

[Hamilton Brian]

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

If you could ever fake the volatility as mafia, you'd be deadly. Of course, your good in either alignment.

Anyway...subtracting yourself, myself, koala, and damo, town would best benefit if ____________ were the Day 2 kill.

Fill in the blank.

Can you explain how you have filtered out certain players here?

Townreading Koala; can't see the effort being put into the "schtick" AND trying to keep it all straight as mafia. Damo...just that gut when reading their stuff. Me...because naturally I don't suspect myself. You? I've been thinking you're mafia since D1 but there's nothing conclusive and I have to separate the feeling I have (animosity for your style) from facts on the ground.

Maybe throw Flum in there. I go back and forth with their D1 material.

[Hamilton Brian]

I think it unlikely that I get killed tonight. I also doubt koala gets axed. My two strongest town liens are.Koala and ghug.

Interesting… So – your strongest 2 Town-reads were ghug & myself, who were in the midst of arguing galore with each other.

You say you won’t get killed.
You say I won’t get killed.
You say … nothing about ghug getting killed?

How come?

I am not townread enough right now; mafia benefit from me being alive since I am a living, walking, breathing shroud of doubt. I townread you, and explained better in a post to jame, but how you're playing right now is not "town friendly," so you're good to keep around. Ghug was my strongest townread. In the pantheon of this "town," I would have expected ghug to take an axe, but it wouldn't be wise for me to write, "I think ghug dies this Night," would it be?

[Hamilton Brian]

And just because people are arguing within the game does not dictate their alignment.

I was absolutely apoplectic with ghug two games ago; we were still on the same side.

Arguing is good. Maintaining respect while doing so is also good.

[Hamilton Brian]

Meh! This whispers "feigned surprise" to me.

Well you can fuck off.

I'm sorry Ghug has died.

Jamie also RIPs - it’s NAI

Though I do question the authenticities of it based off the ghug jokes.

Right? Things have been contentious between jamie and bozo. Does jamie still offer a RIP with bozo dying? NAI.

[KoalaAttack]

Ok I am caught up and have to turn into a pumpkin again now. See you all tomorrow.

[Fluminator]

I'm leaning towards thinking we kill out of the people who haven't posted yet today.

[worcej]

If you could ever fake the volatility as mafia, you'd be deadly. Of course, your good in either alignment.

Anyway...subtracting yourself, myself, koala, and damo, town would best benefit if ____________ were the Day 2 kill.

Fill in the blank.

Can you explain how you have filtered out certain players here?

Townreading Koala; can't see the effort being put into the "schtick" AND trying to keep it all straight as mafia. Damo...just that gut when reading their stuff. Me...because naturally I don't suspect myself. You? I've been thinking you're mafia since D1 but there's nothing conclusive and I have to separate the feeling I have (animosity for your style) from facts on the ground.

Maybe throw Flum in there. I go back and forth with their D1 material.

The damo read seems weird here - can you explain more?

[Fluminator]

##Vote TheBozo