MAFIA 78: Random Facts [GAME THREAD] - [HIDDEN]

[Bonatogether]

hardclaims that are lies = death

especially when soft cced like that

That is not urgent, and it does not even have to be D5, since we have one mis-kill left. It is probably better to wait until D6 even if she never come back to post, so have more town votes when trying to find the other mafia.

this is an incredibly smoothbrain take. take the shit in front of you and be done with it.

we don't need more town votes, we need more town info. leaving scum alive doesn't give us shit like that

[Bonatogether]

@koala, why am I more invigorated after Eden's death than Hug's?

Because I've been sus of Eden for the whole game. I felt vindicated after that. I never was particularly honed in on ghug before he flipped

relatable

[BK3K]

I've got to think, this is all nutty

Chaqa, neon, Fisch, tfb

I think both scum are in there. Guaranteed at least one is

Let me think more

Chaqa, neon, and tfb are on here because i have my own reasons to suspect them. Fisch because it was Rivera's dying wish. What's the case against Fisch?

[bozotheclown]

I've got to think, this is all nutty

Chaqa, neon, Fisch, tfb

I think both scum are in there. Guaranteed at least one is

Let me think more

Chaqa, neon, and tfb are on here because i have my own reasons to suspect them. Fisch because it was Rivera's dying wish. What's the case against Fisch?

Besides the lurking, rdrivera did not like lfischl showing up at EOD and trying to save PE. I agree it is suspicious, but it seems almost too obvious.

[bozotheclown]

hardclaims that are lies = death

especially when soft cced like that

That is not urgent, and it does not even have to be D5, since we have one mis-kill left. It is probably better to wait until D6 even if she never come back to post, so have more town votes when trying to find the other mafia.

this is an incredibly smoothbrain take. take the shit in front of you and be done with it.

we don't need more town votes, we need more town info. leaving scum alive doesn't give us shit like that

Hammering D5 give us less information going into D6, not more.

[Chaqa]

hardclaims that are lies = death

especially when soft cced like that

That is not urgent, and it does not even have to be D5, since we have one mis-kill left. It is probably better to wait until D6 even if she never come back to post, so have more town votes when trying to find the other mafia.

this is an incredibly smoothbrain take. take the shit in front of you and be done with it.

we don't need more town votes, we need more town info. leaving scum alive doesn't give us shit like that

Absolutely based and I agree

[Chaqa]

That is not urgent, and it does not even have to be D5, since we have one mis-kill left. It is probably better to wait until D6 even if she never come back to post, so have more town votes when trying to find the other mafia.

this is an incredibly smoothbrain take. take the shit in front of you and be done with it.

we don't need more town votes, we need more town info. leaving scum alive doesn't give us shit like that

Hammering D5 give us less information going into D6, not more.

Any theories made without Neon’s alignment are void because we wouldn’t even know if we’re still looking for one mafia or two.

It’s so wasteful to people’s time

[BK3K]

this is an incredibly smoothbrain take. take the shit in front of you and be done with it.

we don't need more town votes, we need more town info. leaving scum alive doesn't give us shit like that

Hammering D5 give us less information going into D6, not more.

Any theories made without Neon’s alignment are void because we wouldn’t even know if we’re still looking for one mafia or two.

It’s so wasteful to people’s time

The question is if cost benefit analysis.

If we flip neon and neon is town, does that give us enough info to win?
If she is scum, does that give us enough info to win?

Idk the answer to either of these.

I do know, that while there is a chance neon is town, get actual leave a really sour taste in my mouth. Basing off vibes, Neon is very fishy indeed. I'm keeping my vote there

[BK3K]

Hammering D5 give us less information going into D6, not more.

Any theories made without Neon’s alignment are void because we wouldn’t even know if we’re still looking for one mafia or two.

It’s so wasteful to people’s time

The question is if cost benefit analysis.

If we flip neon and neon is town, does that give us enough info to win?
If she is scum, does that give us enough info to win?

Idk the answer to either of these.

I do know, that while there is a chance neon is town, get actual leave a really sour taste in my mouth. Basing off vibes, Neon is very fishy indeed. I'm keeping my vote there

Get actual = her actions

[Bonatogether]

That is not urgent, and it does not even have to be D5, since we have one mis-kill left. It is probably better to wait until D6 even if she never come back to post, so have more town votes when trying to find the other mafia.

wdym

Assuming Neon is a mafia we have identified, we have 6 town players looking for the last mafia, where D6 we would only have 5 if we DKed Neon.

town VOTES don't matter shit, but town THOUGHT does

if votes mattered more than info then d1 would be an easy dub for town

[bozotheclown]

They would have had reason to suspect rdrivera was the real doctor.

Only if neon is mafia

Rivera being doc was not at all clear

People who claim they knew Rivera was doc: neon, bozo. Anyone else?

I did not say I knew rdrivera was the doctor, but I considered it a good possibility.

[Bonatogether]

I was concerned that was the reason rdrivera was suspecting Neon's claim.

While the obvious conclusion is that the mafia were willing to trade Neon for identifying the doctor, I think we should wait to see if Neon comes back before hammering.

Lmao maybe if RDR didn't make it so obvious that they were the real doctor...

I fake claimed to provide cover for the doctor because A. I'm a slot that is inherently going to get miskilled just because this site has a bias against subs

B. I believed (correctly mind you) that Brainbomb was not lying about being saved and that it would be an easy fake claim to make.

C. I could (hopefully) get mafia to miskill me and provide cover for the real doctor.

I'm town and killing me here is actually pretty bad because Eden was clearly fishing to find out if I was the real doc or not and if I'm wolf they don't need to fish like that. RDR played into the hands of the wolfs by continuing to say how I'm a wolf all phase.

I also think Bozo is a wolf but it's unlikely any one will listen to me so we can start here

##VOTE lfischl

##END

why would you ever fakeclaim PR as town subbing into an AWOL slot? that math just doesn't make sense to me

[Bonatogether]

hardclaims that are lies = death

especially when soft cced like that

Lmao this is really not a good way to play mafia

hardclaim means no take-backs and no bullshit

[Bonatogether]

I think we should at least wait to see if she comes back and posts. It is possible she was fake claiming as town to draw the RB/NK, realizing that she was likely to be a mis-kill eventually anyway.

Why did mafia not shoot her then?

Well possibly because the real doc was super obvious

if that was the case, why didn't he claim? why no c

[Bonatogether]

meant to say

why no claim or cc

[Bonatogether]

PE probably tried to start a wagon on rdrivera knowing he was likely the doctor to try to get him to claim, since rdrivera having to claim under pressure might help Neon win a CC battle.

I would have unclaimed the moment that anyone who was at real that of going over claimed doc lmao.

This sites incessant bias against subs doomed me the minute I became one. My previous slot did me no favors. I'm smart enough to realize I'm a miskill town can not afford and I will always be miskilled.

Or

I can claim the save on brainbomb because I believe it's real and I can provide cover to the real doc and hopefully people are smart enough to play along so mafia miskill me instead of town.

when in this game has anyone seriously proposed voting you because of the fact that you're a sub, or said they suspect you because you're a sub? this just isn't true

[Bonatogether]

Well possibly because the real doc was super obvious

If it was so obvious to you that rdrivera was the real doctor, why did you end D4 voting for him?

More cover lol he wasn't going over anyways and he wasn't going asking with the idea to cover himself. The only thing I had left was to vote and hope mafia didn't see what I did. But i think Eden figured it out pretty early on.

so if eden figured it out early on

presumably the entire scumteam knew? lmao

[Bonatogether]

##vote Neon
##end

There is no other choice today, but feel free to discuss other things.

I’ll be around more later. We’re about to eat then finish the one shot

Lmao it's like this site has never seen a town fake claim before

if you're town your claim was so utterly and incomprehensibly smoothbrain it's unjustifiable

[BK3K]

PE probably tried to start a wagon on rdrivera knowing he was likely the doctor to try to get him to claim, since rdrivera having to claim under pressure might help Neon win a CC battle.

I would have unclaimed the moment that anyone who was at real that of going over claimed doc lmao.

This sites incessant bias against subs doomed me the minute I became one. My previous slot did me no favors. I'm smart enough to realize I'm a miskill town can not afford and I will always be miskilled.

Or

I can claim the save on brainbomb because I believe it's real and I can provide cover to the real doc and hopefully people are smart enough to play along so mafia miskill me instead of town.

when in this game has anyone seriously proposed voting you because of the fact that you're a sub, or said they suspect you because you're a sub? this just isn't true

It struck me as odd that sub bias was all of the sudden an issue when Rivera flipped doc. I didn't say anything because it's my first game on the site, so idk the history or truth to that. But it certainly stood out to me

[Bonatogether]

I would have unclaimed the moment that anyone who was at real that of going over claimed doc lmao.

This sites incessant bias against subs doomed me the minute I became one. My previous slot did me no favors. I'm smart enough to realize I'm a miskill town can not afford and I will always be miskilled.

Or

I can claim the save on brainbomb because I believe it's real and I can provide cover to the real doc and hopefully people are smart enough to play along so mafia miskill me instead of town.

I can see making the claim as town for the reasons you gave. However, the fact that you were a likely DK target also makes is a good play as mafia to out the doctor or try to get a CC DKed first.

I would never trade my life to try to get a CC. Self meta is gross but I'll give you this. I value my life as mafia more than anyone else. I can talk my way out of a PoE.

i literally spent an entire game arguing with you because you claimed, as self-meta, that your towngame and scumgame were identical. mfw