MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[brainbomb]

Tom v ND is more a scum v scum type read. Where its preplanned bullshiylt fightinh so if either dies they can be distant

[ghug]

When will someone realize its not a joke, nor for out of game reasons.

Ask 10 mafia players here, who is the worst scum under pressure and 9 of them would say ND.

Why there is such a reluctance to pressure him is baffling to me.

Cool story. What else do you care about?

[Vecna]

We need to fall back to who is using bad logic bad reasoning.

Start there

No reasoning
Bad reasoning
Flimsy reasoning

Or the person is just kinda dumb

brain can i ask you a favour? can you keep my ass alive here and catch people in their crappy logic voting for me? im doing an ozark binge with the special other, and really dont feel like defending myself here.

gimme a target and ill vote it. You know i wouldbt do that as scum because id know it to be too dangerous for my teammates. also, id k iw better than tontry and buddy up to you here, because its too likely to get you paranoid.

[Vecna]

whybis it a good observation xorxes? when ive stated im way behind on the thread and its a weekend?

in before the standard "vecna is defensive, lynch him!"

Because after your performance N0 with the cannon argument I expected a more forceful participation from you than an "I will sheep brainbomb".

i have no reads and im behind. I dont wanna get lynched though since ill be too usefull for town with my item.

[y2kjbk]

What seems fake about them? These look like real reads offering real thoughts without an agenda other than scumhunting.

Do you still think that after his admission that : "Honestly that reads list was put together in a a hurry, so I really only iso'd a couple of players I thought were scummy."

I thought the reads were honest, I never said they were well thought out.

[Tom Bombadil]

When will someone realize its not a joke, nor for out of game reasons.

Ask 10 mafia players here, who is the worst scum under pressure and 9 of them would say ND.

Why there is such a reluctance to pressure him is baffling to me.

Cool story. What else do you care about?

I've stated what I care about, why I'm voting for RHK and my townreads so far.

[ghug]

When will someone realize its not a joke, nor for out of game reasons.

Ask 10 mafia players here, who is the worst scum under pressure and 9 of them would say ND.

Why there is such a reluctance to pressure him is baffling to me.

Cool story. What else do you care about?

I've stated what I care about, why I'm voting for RHK and my townreads so far.

Why is the majority of what you say still ND-related? You're not trying to lynch him, and you've blown your stated goal by stating it. What does it add to discussion?

[brainbomb]

The way Tom is articulating his push on ND is the kinda push you make when you dont ACTUALLY want that push to get lynched.

[brainbomb]

##Vote Tom

That vecna post just now was decent

[brainbomb]

RHK is towny.

[Tom Bombadil]

Cool story. What else do you care about?

I've stated what I care about, why I'm voting for RHK and my townreads so far.

Why is the majority of what you say still ND-related? You're not trying to lynch him, and you've blown your stated goal by stating it. What does it add to discussion?

Because it is why people are trying to lynch me - so I am defending why I voted for him and people seem to be having a hard time understanding.

[y2kjbk]

##VOTE Tom

[brainbomb]

I forgot rivera was even in this lol

[xorxes]

Tom v ND is more a scum v scum type read. Where its preplanned bullshiylt fightinh so if either dies they can be distant

That was Janiet/ND in the game that got aborted. I'm not seeing that with Tom/ND yet, but then ND hasn't given us much.

[rdrivera2005]

I am torn about Tom. His push on ND was so bad that I don't believe scum Tom would do this (Tom played one of the best scum games I remember).
Lynching Vecna now is just stupid.
Squigs reads seems so faked. And he didn't answer Xorxes, so my vote is staying.

[rdrivera2005]

I forgot rivera was even in this lol

I am here baby...

[DemonRHK]

By your own admission Tom, you wanted to start a wagon because ND *might* crack under pressure *if* he is scum. You’re trying to sell a compound assumption as fact for a lynch.

I don’t like Vecna being allowed off the hook for a half-assed handwave like that, but have to take it at face value for now.

##Vote Tom

[brainbomb]

Tom Bombadil (5) Squigs44 ND brainbomb y2kjbk DemonRHK
Squigs44 (4) worcej xorxes rdrivera2005 flash2015
ghug (2) damo666 Durga
DemonRHK (1) Tom Bombadil
snowy801 (1) ghug

[flash2015]

I am really not seeing the argument for Tom...but I haven't played with him before in another game so perhaps I am missing something here.

[brainbomb]

Sometimes when scum is losing they fear safe places to go and they bus hoping none of those happen