MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[brainbomb]

Y2k-tom-squiggs

Or

Snowy-vecna-?

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTE

I'm on my phone for a couple of hours, we'll give a Vote Count as soon as possible but I am confident the Peterbot count appears correct.

SNOWY is now the only player who has not met the post requirements. He will be replaced at EoD if he fails to participate by then.

[Durga]

I guess I'm about to waste my time rereading this game instead of criminal procedure

[xorxes]

Vecna, you're either very perceptive, or you knew something we didn't. What felt off about Moscow?

funnily enough i dont even remember anymore. Or maybe im just saying this to watch who'll jump on my case. Im guessing brainbomb picked up on the same things.

not sure how far ill get on the catchup here. might just sheep brain for today.

Yeah, the reread of Vecna is pretty sad. Not only has Vecna been lurking, but he's been too chill. His latest post especially was lacking in the normal Vecna confidence. Usually he plays more like ghug or BB with making things happen and not being afraid of offending anyone.

That is actually a good observation. Not enough to move my vote yet though.

[Squigs44]

Squiggs push on worcej is the kinda spurrious bad push scum would make. Reactionary based- flimsy but just conspirathetical enough to gain support

I still think Worcej is scummy based off of his reaction and subsequent answers to my questions. You obviously disagree. Do you not find it odd how he started to cast doubt on you and then flipped around. You breadcrumbed investigator before the flip and scum had no reason to fake that claim just to get killed that phase.

[Tom Bombadil]

Ive been scum with y2k before. He was paranoid, timid, unsure how to contribute.

This seems like very unafraid y2k. Either he suddenly got way better as scum, or he is town.

[brainbomb]

Scum would be hesitant to lynch vecna or snowy. They dont want inactive town (if thats the case), dying. They want feeble bad town dying that casts doubt on town in good spots

[worcej]

Squiggs push on worcej is the kinda spurrious bad push scum would make. Reactionary based- flimsy but just conspirathetical enough to gain support

I still think Worcej is scummy based off of his reaction and subsequent answers to my questions. You obviously disagree. Do you not find it odd how he started to cast doubt on you and then flipped around. You breadcrumbed investigator before the flip and scum had no reason to fake that claim just to get killed that phase.

To be clear, because I question everything, especially a brainbomb quote, that is scummy behavior?

[xorxes]

What seems fake about them? These look like real reads offering real thoughts without an agenda other than scumhunting.

Do you still think that after his admission that : "Honestly that reads list was put together in a a hurry, so I really only iso'd a couple of players I thought were scummy."

[Vecna]

whybis it a good observation xorxes? when ive stated im way behind on the thread and its a weekend?

in before the standard "vecna is defensive, lynch him!"

[xorxes]

Ive been scum with y2k before. He was paranoid, timid, unsure how to contribute.

This seems like very unafraid y2k. Either he suddenly got way better as scum, or he is town.

I'm getting town vibes from him now too.

[Squigs44]

Squiggs push on worcej is the kinda spurrious bad push scum would make. Reactionary based- flimsy but just conspirathetical enough to gain support

I still think Worcej is scummy based off of his reaction and subsequent answers to my questions. You obviously disagree. Do you not find it odd how he started to cast doubt on you and then flipped around. You breadcrumbed investigator before the flip and scum had no reason to fake that claim just to get killed that phase.

To be clear, because I question everything, especially a brainbomb quote, that is scummy behavior?

No, it's more the way you did it. You hedged you're question on him, and then flipped it around quite easily.

[brainbomb]

We need to fall back to who is using bad logic bad reasoning.

Start there

No reasoning
Bad reasoning
Flimsy reasoning

Or the person is just kinda dumb

[Vecna]

Scum would be hesitant to lynch vecna or snowy. They dont want inactive town (if thats the case), dying. They want feeble bad town dying that casts doubt on town in good spots

except ill probably get active at some point and completely destroy their ass. not a coincidence town starting winning games again recently.

dont pretend you didnt scan whatshisname because we both had the same gut feeling about the slot

[flash2015]

A general question about the site - how does it figure out who is online? I assume if it indicates you are online it means you have refreshed the page in the last X minutes? Does anyone know what X is?

[brainbomb]

Toms relied on just jokey vendetta push all game. Purposeless. Gives him a meatshield to avoid real hunting.

Not to say ND is doing jack shit- he isnt

[xorxes]

whybis it a good observation xorxes? when ive stated im way behind on the thread and its a weekend?

in before the standard "vecna is defensive, lynch him!"

Because after your performance N0 with the cannon argument I expected a more forceful participation from you than an "I will sheep brainbomb".

[Tom Bombadil]

When will someone realize its not a joke, nor for out of game reasons.

Ask 10 mafia players here, who is the worst scum under pressure and 9 of them would say ND.

Why there is such a reluctance to pressure him is baffling to me.

[worcej]

No, it's more the way you did it. You hedged you're question on him, and then flipped it around quite easily.

I flipped because of the realization that the kit was a one time use item, which wasn't inherently clear in the first post on the thread but was established in the sign-ups. That made his claim a lot more believable and the only logical conclusion was to shoot MF to confirm.

I'm starting to learn lol... I've realized that our GMs are not perfect and post a lot of rules in the sign-up thread and will not update their starting post with that information.

[ghug]

No reasoning - ghug, rdrivera, flash
Flimsy reasoning - xorxes, Tom
Bad reasoning - squiggles
Kinda dumb - brainbomb
damo666
DemonRHK
Durga
ND
snowy801
Vecna
worcej
y2kjbk