MAFIA 78: Random Facts [GAME THREAD] - [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

Shouldn't bona have convinced himself he's caught someone by now?

WE GOT HIM BOYS

##Vote Bona

[BK3K]

since my FOS on BK he has been viewing the thread but not posting and is not trying to address the issue.

So theres that.

I have little ten minute breaks which are not enough to read and post.

What's your issue with me? I said "at the risk of being scumreqd" and something else?

Honestly you should vote for me not being able to contribute good analysis before you should vote for me being scum

I do think bunny is SUS. I just don't want to vote him D1. You're right, that's bad meta. But i also think i have a good reason to vote chaqa

So I'll try to read it all, no promises i come out with a bomb shell post. Take this as you may, i do not fear death

[President Eden]

Open question to all experienced players: Is it a good idea to follow the crowd in D1 or to blaze your own trail?

blazing your own trail is much preferred because it shows other people where you are + it comes from the only viewpoint you can 100% trust to be townie (your own)

that said, I'm not above breaking a "tie" or "close call" among multiple suspects by following somebody I townread who's been putting in good work. I don't think anyone else here is above it either

and ultimately, at EOD, you should consolidate onto one of the wagons that is plausibly going to go, so you may end up following anyway by virtue of that need

[damo666]

He spelled it wrong while claiming scum?

Yep

Even if you buy the Chipotle swearing, which I don't, since he's definitely going to use it to win a scum game at some point, I don't see why the counterfactual would hold any sway for you.

Benefit of doubt.

[brainbomb]

since my FOS on BK he has been viewing the thread but not posting and is not trying to address the issue.

So theres that.

I have little ten minute breaks which are not enough to read and post.

What's your issue with me? I said "at the risk of being scumreqd" and something else?

Honestly you should vote for me not being able to contribute good analysis before you should vote for me being scum

I do think bunny is SUS. I just don't want to vote him D1. You're right, that's bad meta. But i also think i have a good reason to vote chaqa

So I'll try to read it all, no promises i come out with a bomb shell post. Take this as you may, i do not fear death

being mafia is > greater concern than if you have poor analysis

[damo666]

Tbf I explained I thought BK was giving scummy vibes earlier, I think some of the inactives trying to coast are scum and I think Damo might be.

Does he seem bored? A little.

Does his math suck? A lot

You may be on to something

Precisely! And his alphabetical reads list!

Aplphabetical within category because I went down alpha list to categorise. What's so strange about that?

[damo666]

Precisely! And his alphabetical reads list!

wait, is this actually a thing?

I’m dead serious

You're bloody stupid.

[KoalaAttack]

Open question to all experienced players: Is it a good idea to follow the crowd in D1 or to blaze your own trail?

blazing your own trail is much preferred because it shows other people where you are + it comes from the only viewpoint you can 100% trust to be townie (your own)

that said, I'm not above breaking a "tie" or "close call" among multiple suspects by following somebody I townread who's been putting in good work. I don't think anyone else here is above it either

and ultimately, at EOD, you should consolidate onto one of the wagons that is plausibly going to go, so you may end up following anyway by virtue of that need

Thank you President Eden!



But also...

President Eden was not in the last game, but from all the conversation references I gather that they are a veteran on here... is that right, experienced folks?

this is actually my first game of mafia

Uhh – new suspect for the list?

I feel like there are too many inside jokes among the crowd here and I can't tell them apart from slips.

[BunnyGo]

Oh COME ON there are 3 new pages already while I was typing that (admittedly long) post?

What the heck people... I need to get back to work!

I dunno man…figure it out yourself

[damo666]

ghug isnt addressing that I keep listing him as scum now so maybe it has some validity. or maybe if he was scum he would be like brain, dont go back to doing all that again, I thought we retired that stuff ages ago

Or maybe you did it all between when I went to bed and when I caught up?

I'd be distributed if you went through today without scumreading everyone in the game at some point. If it evolves from consideration to death tunnel, we may have some words.

disappointed?

[President Eden]

President Eden was not in the last game, but from all the conversation references I gather that they are a veteran on here... is that right, experienced folks?

this is actually my first game of mafia

Uhh – new suspect for the list?

I feel like there are too many inside jokes among the crowd here and I can't tell them apart from slips.

You could say I've been here for a while.

[Fluminator]

I wasn’t drunk last game…see my posts above.

Wait wait wait, what? I take back all my questions to Bunny about grading my Suspect List and whether I should switch from Chaqa to Bona. Which Bunny didn't respond to anyway, which was mildly Suspicious BTW.


Koala's updated Suspect List:

(1) Chaqa ... I get the sense that this kind of joke is just something Chaqa would do, but I still have no stronger theory than the very suspicious timing of said joke after the Cop is dead.

(2) Bona ... still largely same as before (joke)-voting townie, but also looks like folks either think Bona is very town or very Mafia, so flipping them would unveil lots of useful info!

(3) Bunny ... faking drunkness last game! I know it was for a good cause since Bunny was a Townie, but it just completely resets my entire evaluation of Bunny so far. Suspicious. Not responding to my direct questions asking for Bunny's advice (which were admittedly intended to put his responses on display for all to see). Still suspicious. Also said that poop is delicious, which is a joke but that means they can say literally anything and not mean it.

(4) Bozo ... kills koalas (it's never going away!), didn't explain absence (though point re explaining would be Suspicious was valid, credit), still seems much more quiet than last game.

(bonus) TheFlyingBoat is the new popular vote, who has a lot of good arguments made against them (and some for them) but I just don't have enough of my own opinion formed, so it would be largely following the crowd. Koalas sleep all day, not follow crows all days, those are sheeps. Open question to all experienced players: Is it a good idea to follow the crowd in D1 or to blaze your own trail?


I wish I had a confirmed Townie I could ask for advice from. We do have one confirmed, but their judgement seems severely impaired based on the fact of them shooting out Cop. Ehh... I'll ask anyway, Fluminator what do you think about my suspect list?


PS: Darg why you have to ruin the Year of Bunny by sharing that TMI aspect?

Like you said, you might not want to trust my views because now that the shock of jamiet being the cop is over, I honestly don't regret it. I mention something suspicious, and his argument in response was that I was a terrible person outside the game and that my argument was invalid because nothing I say is serious (because he's upset I bring up controversial topics in a dead forum). He just kept going on about how I was a bad person and I would shoot him again because I didn't need that energy. For future reference Jamiet, if you have a problem with me, keep it in PMs or whatever political thread you're losing your mind over instead of bringing it into games.
Anywho.. you still asked so

Chaqa's gimmick is to never give a shit in these games. It's pretty NAI.

I don't know Bona as well as others, I think Chaqa claimed in past games he has a 100% accuracy read on Bona, so I might sheep his opinion on Bona.

I agree with your read on Bunny, but in my one game I rememer him as scum, I think I incorrectly townread him, which makes me think he's better at faking towniness than he's showing here which might just mean he's trying to look towny which ironically makes him more town.

Bozo not saying where he was in NAI and perfectly in character with him.

I would only follow the crowd on TFB if you find the arguments compelling.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Does he seem bored? A little.

Does his math suck? A lot

You may be on to something

Precisely! And his alphabetical reads list!

Aplphabetical within category because I went down alpha list to categorise. What's so strange about that?

You have tended to order lists by strength of read when town

[Fluminator]

oops should have proofread, have a work meeting to get to.
Bunny's paragraph should be
"I agree with your read on Bunny, but in my one game I rememer him as scum, I think I incorrectly townread him, which makes me think he's better at faking towniness than he's showing here which might just mean he's NOT trying to look towny which ironically makes him more town.

[damo666]

Check his D3 towncore list in M72 and then how he posts in other games when he is town. You don’t see that fake attempt to contribute there

Yeah it's great scum play to do a fake readlist day 1

[damo666]

Check his D3 towncore list in M72 and then how he posts in other games when he is town. You don’t see that fake attempt to contribute there

Yeah it's great scum play to do a fake readlist day 1

[TheFlyingBoat]

@TFB, what's your take on the people on your wagon so far. Any of them opportunistic scum?

I don’t think there is opportunistic scum on my wagon. If there is it would have to be RDR or bozo.

I’d probably goes bozo here as I’m not sure how he squares arguing that Eden was distancing voting me while then voting me instead of Eden as to me that implies that he thinks Eden is mafia and thinks either Eden is trying to weaken his attachment to a town wagon while still pushing the kill through or he thinks we’re both scum and he thinks that this is a bit of scum theater. Either way, in his worldview, surely he has to think that Eden is a better vote than me

at least you showed up with 3 hours left

Better late than never eh?

[TheFlyingBoat]

Check his D3 towncore list in M72 and then how he posts in other games when he is town. You don’t see that fake attempt to contribute there

Yeah it's great scum play to do a fake readlist day 1

This is WIFOM and you know it

[ghug]

##VOTE damo666

Boat vs damo vs Bunny (vs lfischl?) is an interesting D1.

Pull an Abraham and kill your son with me

[damo666]

ill be taking my break now until EOD. good game so far, not really but I still think chaqa needs to die, and I still distrust bunny but not as bad. Im fine killing BK, do not want damo or TFB to be todays elims.

Can you explain why on Damo?

because hes extremely annoying and is proposing wildly idiotic things to waste our eliminations on because he doesnt give a shit.

and I think as scum he would be just a little bit more serious, quieter, maybe more tryhard.

It's day 1.