But flipping me and revealing I am town doesn't do anything for yavu's logic here is my point. Your assumption on my flip being valuable is if I flip scum and quite frankly any scum flip is a reap of information, regardless who it is.KoalaAttack wrote: ↑Fri Jan 20, 2023 3:30 amworcej wrote: ↑Fri Jan 20, 2023 3:22 amAgain, a fault in your logic is you disregard the existence of busing and assume all logical based arguments are being made in good faith.
We could have a situation here where lfischl and myself are both town and yavu is actually scum. What he said via his logic does not stop him from flipping both of us because at no point is his basis "if X is town" - he is starting from a scum position.
So, say we flip me and you see I am the town doctor that I claimed. Yavu's logic is meaningless and would actually warrant you going the next step and flipping lfischl next.
I am not saying this proves you are Mafia. I am simply saying that unveiling you presents us with strictly more information, relatively speaking, than unveiling someone else. And while you make a good point why the confidence level might not be as high, I still think that's the case unless I get a better alternative.
As for your Doctor claim, so far from the claim itself and responses, I can't build a case stronger than basic "armchair psychology" which is a weaker signal that yavuzovic's post.
Once I flip doctor from a DK, that's a whole shit ton of egg on the collective town's face for wasting one of their limited kills on a claimed PR. If scum don't have a role block, they are going to need to kill me sooner than later because the lower the pool of players gets, the more likely I am to save someone.