M1023: Mafarmia [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[celaph]

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

Doing a quick scan of past games, I feel like Bona's shitposting and being mafia are actually negatively correlated. He was mafia last game and had less shitposting than this D1. His game before he was town and shitposting levels were higher. Granted, that town game he was PR and we had 48 hours days so it's not too representative, but it goes to show that I don't think shitposting is a good metric for scumminess.

[celaph]

Initial thoughts:

• Damo and rdr both felt town motivated for the no-nonsense way they entered the thread.
• I don't recall if I've ever seen scum Kak before, but the way he both sent songs and genuinely interacted with the thread felt towny.
• I like Bona so far.
• I'm curious as to what conclusions Bozo draws from talking to Bona and I about our pre-game interactions.

[BunnyGo]

Obviously not a lot to go on, NOT gonna vote for the following today

Bozo - too useful if town
Chaqa - because he has bleated
damo - because that would be silly
ghug - see bozo
heartthrob - NEW
Kak - too noisy to be scum
rdr - sheepclaim

So am left with

Bona
Bo
Bunny
celaph
lfischl
worcej

Of these worcej gets a pass as he hasn't spoken yet and celaph will give himself away if scum.

Bo a la worcej, Bona already under pressure. Leaves Bunny or fish.

I'll ##vote lfischl.

Why do you think that Bona is already under pressure? My vote on him is certainly not serious at the moment and I'm not sure that Bunny's is either.

@Bunny, why did you vote Bona?

probably generational issues as rdr put it. I can't read all his bs without seeing scum!bona everywhere. Every post he made in the first 5 pages pinged me last night; this was before the "scum slip". I don't know why, it just does.

[Bonatogether]

I feel like bona is scum just because of the volume of shitposting he has done, I haven’t played in a while, does he do this as scum?

Doing a quick scan of past games, I feel like Bona's shitposting and being mafia are actually negatively correlated. He was mafia last game and had less shitposting than this D1. His game before he was town and shitposting levels were higher. Granted, that town game he was PR and we had 48 hours days so it's not too representative, but it goes to show that I don't think shitposting is a good metric for scumminess.

wait you're literally lying - i was doc or some shit in the last game

[BunnyGo]

Initial thoughts:

• Damo and rdr both felt town motivated for the no-nonsense way they entered the thread.
• I don't recall if I've ever seen scum Kak before, but the way he both sent songs and genuinely interacted with the thread felt towny.
• I like Bona so far.
• I'm curious as to what conclusions Bozo draws from talking to Bona and I about our pre-game interactions.

No opinion on me, ghug, chaqa?

Thoughts on bo's strange post?

[Kakarroto]

now that you know he has mild covid, how would you interpret his actions and lines of reasoning?

it seems it enhanced a bit the sillyness in D1 start posts, be it for fun or getting reactions. It's a bit hard to follow the reasoning behind some (like when I do silly things it all makes sense to me but it's hard to explain it to others, I think bunny might be the same in that regard); of course he could do all that as mafia to try to look like silly town, but normally that's hard to perform and town usually sniffs out the mafia behind, like the game where I was the Hexenjäger. I shall read it again, though right now I'm quite tired from today so not right now but the feel I have about it right now is more like more town than mafia for bunny here.

[Bonatogether]

Obviously not a lot to go on, NOT gonna vote for the following today

Bozo - too useful if town
Chaqa - because he has bleated
damo - because that would be silly
ghug - see bozo
heartthrob - NEW
Kak - too noisy to be scum
rdr - sheepclaim

So am left with

Bona
Bo
Bunny
celaph
lfischl
worcej

Of these worcej gets a pass as he hasn't spoken yet and celaph will give himself away if scum.

Bo a la worcej, Bona already under pressure. Leaves Bunny or fish.

I'll ##vote lfischl.

Why do you think that Bona is already under pressure? My vote on him is certainly not serious at the moment and I'm not sure that Bunny's is either.

@Bunny, why did you vote Bona?

probably generational issues as rdr put it. I can't read all his bs without seeing scum!bona everywhere. Every post he made in the first 5 pages pinged me last night; this was before the "scum slip". I don't know why, it just does.

this man is dodging the question like it's nothing

[BunnyGo]

Why do you think that Bona is already under pressure? My vote on him is certainly not serious at the moment and I'm not sure that Bunny's is either.

@Bunny, why did you vote Bona?

probably generational issues as rdr put it. I can't read all his bs without seeing scum!bona everywhere. Every post he made in the first 5 pages pinged me last night; this was before the "scum slip". I don't know why, it just does.

this man is dodging the question like it's nothing

In what sense do you think I'm dodging a question?

[Kakarroto]

but yeah, ghug, since you're here, might we drink a little bit of your wisdom for what you think about the game so far?

It's been dominated by you and BunnyGo distracting us.

I had hoped for more, but I guess then I should turn down sillyness to a lesser degree.

[BunnyGo]

but yeah, ghug, since you're here, might we drink a little bit of your wisdom for what you think about the game so far?

It's been dominated by you and BunnyGo distracting us.

I had hoped for more, but I guess then I should turn down sillyness to a lesser degree.

I'm surprised ghug doesn't mention Bona as the volume poster here.

[Bonatogether]

now that you know he has mild covid, how would you interpret his actions and lines of reasoning?

it seems it enhanced a bit the sillyness in D1 start posts, be it for fun or getting reactions. It's a bit hard to follow the reasoning behind some (like when I do silly things it all makes sense to me but it's hard to explain it to others, I think bunny might be the same in that regard); of course he could do all that as mafia to try to look like silly town, but normally that's hard to perform and town usually sniffs out the mafia behind, like the game where I was the Hexenjäger. I shall read it again, though right now I'm quite tired from today so not right now but the feel I have about it right no is more like more town than mafia for bunny here.

what specifically would tip off genuine silly town vs fake silly scum? can scum be genuinely silly?

[BunnyGo]

##CALL GM: Are you going to give worcej a prod on discord or something to make sure he knows game has started and day ends soon?

[Bonatogether]

probably generational issues as rdr put it. I can't read all his bs without seeing scum!bona everywhere. Every post he made in the first 5 pages pinged me last night; this was before the "scum slip". I don't know why, it just does.

this man is dodging the question like it's nothing

In what sense do you think I'm dodging a question?

you just say what rdr said with a lame add on

[Bonatogether]

no way every post i made pinged you - gimmie an example of a scummy post and explique why you chose it

[Bonatogether]

It's been dominated by you and BunnyGo distracting us.

I had hoped for more, but I guess then I should turn down sillyness to a lesser degree.

I'm surprised ghug doesn't mention Bona as the volume poster here.

cause i have content

[BunnyGo]

this man is dodging the question like it's nothing

In what sense do you think I'm dodging a question?

you just say what rdr said with a lame add on

I'm not going to go reread the first 5 pages.

I'm currently trying to decide whether to give you town points for voting for the new guy on D1 or scum points for just adding noise.

Also waiting for lfischl's sentence.

Also trying to decide why ghug ignored all your noise. Guessing he has a filter on.

[Bonatogether]

In what sense do you think I'm dodging a question?

you just say what rdr said with a lame add on

I'm not going to go reread the first 5 pages.

I'm currently trying to decide whether to give you town points for voting for the new guy on D1 or scum points for just adding noise.

Also waiting for lfischl's sentence.

Also trying to decide why ghug ignored all your noise. Guessing he has a filter on.

you're literally smoking, it's 5 pages and i'm asking for one post. shit aint hard

[BunnyGo]

inadequate time to shitpost

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

[BunnyGo]

inadequate time to shitpost

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

You took 4 posts to say 4 sentences that were roughly 4 words each. It just felt like filler. Not even jokey filler, just filler filler.

[Bonatogether]

inadequate time to shitpost

this thread you went down. Why you want so much noise? Now you say your noise has content? Is just noise. You want to shitpost, but then also want to claim there's nothing in your shitposts, but then also want to claim they're full of content. It's inanity.

setting aside your context-removal and strategic reordering of what i said, how does that connect to me being scum?