Tiny Hunt I Game Thread

[Squigs44]

@y2k - you keep saying you think there are two scum left. This would imply that you think one of Bo or Jamie is town. You scumread and voted for both of them prior to their deaths. Has your attitude changed since then? Which one do you think was town and why? Or is there another reason why you think there is two scum left?

[Squigs44]

Crossposted with ya Y2k. Are you saying you think Bo is town because of Vecnas claim?

[y2kjbk]

We know Vecna was town, why would he lie about knowing that bosox was town?

[worcej]

Worcej and yav, we need one of you to come to Rdrivera. If you don't, we likely lose this game because worcej will kill the wrong person if it's a tie. (Also @damo your vote was not formatted correctly, so we need you to retype it formatted correctly this time).

@worcej, I know you think scum is Y2k and I. Independent of your scumread of us, do you think Rdrivera is townier or scummier?

@yav - I think Y2k has been very townie today with his arguments with Worcej. You seem to disagree. Is this the case?

Clarify: townier or scummier compared to what?

[Squigs44]

Worcej and yav, we need one of you to come to Rdrivera. If you don't, we likely lose this game because worcej will kill the wrong person if it's a tie. (Also @damo your vote was not formatted correctly, so we need you to retype it formatted correctly this time).

@worcej, I know you think scum is Y2k and I. Independent of your scumread of us, do you think Rdrivera is townier or scummier?

@yav - I think Y2k has been very townie today with his arguments with Worcej. You seem to disagree. Is this the case?

Clarify: townier or scummier compared to what?

Let me rephrase: Is he in your townlist because he has done townie things? Or is he only in your town list because you think I'm scum? Looking at his gameplay, do you think he has more actions that read town or more actions that read scum?

[rdrivera2005]

We know Vecna was town, why would he lie about knowing that bosox was town?

Because if I am reading right what is Vecna role, he couldn't be sure about Bo's alignment. I can't discuss it more without throwing the game to scum I think.

[y2kjbk]

So you don’t think he could have been lying, you think he could have been mistaken?

[Squigs44]

So you don’t think he could have been lying, you think he could have been mistaken?

Rdrivera is the only right one, once again. Yes, he could have been mistaken. Using it as a reaction test just like the five other things he did. I actually think you passed the test Y2k. A big reason I'm townreading you.

[y2kjbk]

Or that he was just bullshitting knowing that? I don’t buy it.

[yavuzovic]

@yav - I think Y2k has been very townie today with his arguments with Worcej. You seem to disagree. Is this the case?

You're wrong. All townlists I published today included y2k. I was trying to see his reaction. But not rivera
##vote Squigs

[rdrivera2005]

Rdrivera I'm starting to get some really townie vibes from you and I don't like it at all.
Let's play a game. Let's pretend for a moment that WarLegend announces that both of us are town, and we have to work together to win this game. On the assumption I am town, what would you say about the other four in the game?

I would say that worcej is definitely the judge. Do you agree?
Damo is likely town, but there is room for doubt there.
You pointed something out to me that gives me a strong townread of Yav, so I'm guessing you agree with me there, if I picked up the same thing you thought.
That leaves Y2k. The problem is, I thought Y2k is a certain role that I think is still in the game. So unless you are that role, then damo has to be the one lying. If you are that role, then Y2k is scum. Either way, it's one scum left in the game, unless it's damo and Y2k as scum. That could be an interesting scum team.

I don't know if you are being genuine or trying to hunt for roles.
Anyway, if I have a way to be sure you are town I will have to reavaluate a kit of things.
I am disliking a lot the way y2k have been playing, but I have a hard time seeing him as scum with Jamiet and Bo. I might need to revaluate all game in this case. And if it's Damo we already lost and he is brilliant.

[y2kjbk]

If I had a nickel for every reaction test in this thread I could go buy a nice dinner lol

[yavuzovic]

I can't stay here. I nay come after EoD. I hope game still continues

[Squigs44]

I can't lynch worcej knowing he is townier than Squigs and y2kjbk.
I'll stay on Squigs. My scumpool is Squigs & y2k for now.
And also why were we voting for worcej, by the way?

You said Y2k was in your scum pool at the beginning of the day. Also I guess your vote of Y2k overshadowed the post you made before that saying you townread him. My apologies for misinterpreting that.

[Squigs44]

I can't stay here. I nay come after EoD. I hope game still continues

We still have 24 hours yav

[yavuzovic]

Oh, hehe, I thought it os EoD

[yavuzovic]

*is
Why can't I write well

[worcej]

Long post incoming, get ready.

Let's break the game down even more everyone. I'll lay out my analysis with the known facts, assumed facts, and then detail my thoughts on situations.

Confirmed Facts based on Game Mechanics:

1. ND was town. Proof was Vig shot.
2. Ezio was town. Proof was DT's death and the Vig shot.
3. Bozo was town. Proof was soup kill.
4. Vecna was town. Proof is NK - it would be the first recorded scum on scum night kill that I know of if he wasn't. The kill would make very little sense to do since souping or killing me would've won them the game if he was scum.
5. A witch, maybe dead or alive, cannot soup.

Assumptions/Claims made during Game:

1. DT was town. Evidence is Damo's claim from this quote:

   We have 2 known roles. I was debating whether to do this but feel powerless not to do so.
   
   I can confirm Ezio brought down a fellow villager in DT.
   
   For what it's worth I suspect Bo_ is/was witch. If so well done Vig (funny if it's Y2K.
   
   On voting analysis
   
   ##Vote Squigs
   
   Btw please note that despite the fact I joined Ezios wagon on my vote analysis he was towniest.

2. Damo would also be town based on above. Evidence is the above quote. I'll go into more details on this in my next section.
3. I, worcej, am the Judge. Evidence is my HC. You believe it or you don't, not going to rehash it all here.
4. Jaime was the Vig. Evidence is his claim before death. I'll also go into this more in the details below.
5. Bo_ was possibly town. Evidence is the posts by Vecna, two to be exact, peddling this:

   Alright, so that confirms that ND was indeed town and that the vigilante shot Bo_sox. We still have no idea about whether Thomas or Bo was town or a witch, but we could very well be down to 6 town vs 3 witches

   Now ill give you the rest of the scumpool:
   
   Worcej
   Rdrivera
   and Y2k (but youre implying the implyable so its most likely just the first 2)
   
   Yes its 3 remaining. Bo_sox was town

My Assumptions and Opinions for this Game as of Now:

1. Bo_ was town. Vecna pretty much soft peddled this earlier in the day. With his death, it confirms to me that scum wasn't sure what his role was but wanted him dead. Unfortunately Angels didn't protect him directly, so thus he died.
2. Jaime was the Vig. This stands out to me because of how last night played out. Vecna dying was done by the scum for a reason - I was an easy kill, but getting rid of Vecna was mandatory. If they killed me with him alive, they couldn't win and could still possibly lose due to the town having 3 votes available right now.
3. Damo is town, thus DT is town. I don't see why he would lie about it to clear DT - the logic of clearing DT as town, even if both were scum (meaning damo/DT/??? is the scum team) just wouldn't make sense. This ultimately brings us too...
4. There is 3 scum alive right now... This is debunked by only three things - but I think it isn't debunked
   1. Vecna lied for some reason - Can't find why he would right now though...
   2. Damo is lying - Can't see why he would based off logic. Damo strikes me as lazy, not retarded.
   3. Jaime was actually the Vig - plausibly a lie, but I am highly inclined to believe it was true. This is again because, by knowing my claim and going for Vecna first - you ensured you'd win.
5. Y2k is town because he didn't rush to end the day when he had the chance. Scum just need this to go to night and soup me for the win, because...
6. The scum team is Squigs/rDrivera/Yav. This game is already over and it's all a formality until they soup me.

GG you three - my claim, and then the lack of anyone else revealing anything before EOD, fucked the town. I earned LVP (Least Valuable Player).

[worcej]

Edit on assumption 2 - they would have 4 votes - Damo, Y2k, Vecna, and Lump

[Squigs44]

Worcej, you have several incorrect assumptions. I'm pretty sure Jamie and Bo are scum. If you use the rest of the 24 hours to mope around that we have already lost, then you are guaranteeing we lose. So please, please help town out.
Worcej, let's play a game. Let's say that WarLegend makes a post guaranteeing that Jamie and Bo are scum, and that I am town. We have to work together to find the last scum. Who do you decide is scum? Would you join me on Rdrivera, go after Y2k, or vote for Yav or damo?