MAFIA 75: TROUBLE AT THE PRECINCT [HIDDEN]

[worcej]

Though drama apparently killed his desire to play, snowy did a fucking great job convincing me he was town and had me 100% convinced he wasn’t scum.

[President Eden]

Scum could swap the tag off me tonight, sure. But again - what value does that bring?

You move it to another towny? Okay, fine - nothing changes.
You move it to another scum? Hope you BD doesn’t die.

I would think the best bet would be to not touch me at all because the risk-reward of moving the tag off me is just unnecessary wifom when the scum team is only down one member.

Well, I don’t know how much I even buy it, but there’s an obvious mafia motivation to free you from the tag if you’re mafia. I agree that there’s not a lot of point to freeing you up if you’re town though. That was actually why I brought it up—I was in the middle of writing up my mixed feelings on you and thought I observed that you HAD lost the tag, which is pretty But obviously there was another reasonable explanation for what I was seeing.

All I’m really saying is that I think your behavior bled town but in the interest of thoroughness, I went back and looked at your record expecting to remove you from my POE pool, and found I could see the argument for you being mafia having a good game.

If I was mafia and had this tag, why wouldn’t me and my team have freed me of it on N1?

If I was mafia - I would have peeked on D1 to know what tag I had to plan for the BD movement. I would do it regardless of the concern of accidentally hitting the self oracle. Knowing I have any special tag would be critical for executing the NK and BD actions.

Mechanically, there is no point as mafia to keep the tag on themselves because it effectively neuters the team by taking a vote away.

Otherwise, I am not going to fault you for reading me as defending Byz because that’s exactly what I was doing. I was just doing it as a stupid towny not trusting the origins of the case on Byz.

You’d have peeked with the risk of having oracle tag and just outing yourself as scum d1? Bold.

That answer kind of locks me into thinking you’re town though lol…

[President Eden]

Though drama apparently killed his desire to play, snowy did a fucking great job convincing me he was town and had me 100% convinced he wasn’t scum.

This + your earlier statement about peeking d2 adds up to me from a townie perspective

[bo_sox48]

Can you guys quit fucking up quotes

[President Eden]

Can you guys quit fucking up quotes

Fix your site boomer

[bo_sox48]

That would involve getting rid of the forum entirely

[President Eden]

no wait dont do that

[Bonatogether]

old forum is still around

[ghug]

old forum is still around

Yeah let's go play there.

[Bonatogether]

old forum is still around

Yeah let's go play there.

it's not visible on the front page so we can do whatever

[worcej]

Well, I don’t know how much I even buy it, but there’s an obvious mafia motivation to free you from the tag if you’re mafia. I agree that there’s not a lot of point to freeing you up if you’re town though. That was actually why I brought it up—I was in the middle of writing up my mixed feelings on you and thought I observed that you HAD lost the tag, which is pretty But obviously there was another reasonable explanation for what I was seeing.

All I’m really saying is that I think your behavior bled town but in the interest of thoroughness, I went back and looked at your record expecting to remove you from my POE pool, and found I could see the argument for you being mafia having a good game.

If I was mafia and had this tag, why wouldn’t me and my team have freed me of it on N1?

If I was mafia - I would have peeked on D1 to know what tag I had to plan for the BD movement. I would do it regardless of the concern of accidentally hitting the self oracle. Knowing I have any special tag would be critical for executing the NK and BD actions.

Mechanically, there is no point as mafia to keep the tag on themselves because it effectively neuters the team by taking a vote away.

Otherwise, I am not going to fault you for reading me as defending Byz because that’s exactly what I was doing. I was just doing it as a stupid towny not trusting the origins of the case on Byz.

You’d have peeked with the risk of having oracle tag and just outing yourself as scum d1? Bold.

That answer kind of locks me into thinking you’re town though lol…

Truthfully, I believe the mafia players all know their tags by now. 1/17 chance to get the oracle is mighty low.

[worcej]

That would involve getting rid of the forum entirely

*eyes narrow*

Go on…

[worcej]

old forum is still around

Yeah let's go play there.

it's not visible on the front page so we can do whatever

This is how I know your alignment is CN

[Jamiet99uk]

old forum is still around

Yeah let's go play there.

Ok, I've moved the thread over to the old forum, let's play there.

https://webdiplomacy.net/forum.php?viewthread=1539551

[worcej]

Though drama apparently killed his desire to play, snowy did a fucking great job convincing me he was town and had me 100% convinced he wasn’t scum.

This + your earlier statement about peeking d2 adds up to me from a townie perspective

I don’t follow your logic here… why would that alleviate your concerns?

[ghug]

old forum is still around

Yeah let's go play there.

Ok, I've moved the thread over to the old forum, let's play there.

https://webdiplomacy.net/forum.php?viewthread=1539551

I was really hoping this was a link to Abgemact Is An Asshat Fucktard or Daily Bible Reading or something.

[bo_sox48]

The main advantage of leaving the old forum open is that the spambots go there for some reason.

[bo_sox48]

Lol they're getting real https://webdiplomacy.net/forum.php?view ... 18#1539518

[President Eden]

Though drama apparently killed his desire to play, snowy did a fucking great job convincing me he was town and had me 100% convinced he wasn’t scum.

This + your earlier statement about peeking d2 adds up to me from a townie perspective

I don’t follow your logic here… why would that alleviate your concerns?

I’ll explain in a bit, but I did think of some follow up questions actually.

When precisely did you peek d2?

[worcej]

This + your earlier statement about peeking d2 adds up to me from a townie perspective

I don’t follow your logic here… why would that alleviate your concerns?

I’ll explain in a bit, but I did think of some follow up questions actually.

When precisely did you peek d2?

In the first hour - are you wanting a more specific time?