M1021 - Blessings of Lilia - GAME THREAD [hidden]

[DeathLlama8]

No, but why make this gun claim at all if he was scum and had no gun?

You're only answering why he'd claim to aim at Damo.

What is the scum motivation for the claim in the first place?

....I don't know. Because it looks towny?

##UNVOTE

Can't in good faith keep my vote up if I can't answer this question satisfactorily.

you don't need to ascribe scum motivation to every single post someone makes to scumread them. honestly I don't think a fake gun claim does much for town either

[TheFlyingBoat]

I don't think that anything Bona has done has substantially changed my read on him. He still feels very 'bona'-y in his slightly scummy way that I've seen be miskilled a number of times before.

What is more on my mind is the bizarre wagon on Bona D2. Why were more people not discussing their reads or driving the conversation about it.

A question I have yet to hear a good answer to. I have heard plenty of bad ones, but no good ones.

Bona hasn't hunted for scum and was pushing for the miskill on durga and aaro. He's been incredibly lazy this game. Hasn't provided much reads at all, not even on me. Probably hasn't read the game during d3 at all.

Being wrong isn't scum indicative.

[pyxxy]

Always happy to vote Jamie of course. He seems more Interested in voting for me every game regardless of alignment than actually finding scum.

idk man when you post less words than Eden the GM in a 48 hour window, there's not much to say other than you're not being a helpful towny

Jamie is scum.

It’s always pretty easy for scum to daykill me. They can go for the ‘daykill all lurkers’ line or say they can’t read me, or just pile on when some townies start scum reading me, which inevitably happens. Maybe Jamie was looking for a miskill earlier. But when I was ahead. He moved off me and has stayed off me. Two reasons for scum!Jamie to do this, firstly if I’m miskilled he doesn’t have blood on his hands and more importantly, he scum!Jamie would actually think I’m so bad at mafia that he’d sooner me stay alive providing scum have another townie in their miskill sights. So I’m thinking aarodactyl is town too and from Scum POV a better miskill than I am.

I think everyone on me are solid town.

I think perhaps scum Jamie hides on another scumbo who is unlikely to be a string wagon today, so Bonatogether could be his scum buddy,

So I’m going to ##vote Jamie, but will shift to Bonatogether if Jamie wagon doesn’t build.

And like yeah you've wanted to kill Jamie since EOD D2. Shrug. Give us something else to work with, other than insisting on Bona. Who should we absolutely not kill today?

[Jamiet99uk]

Always happy to vote Jamie of course. He seems more Interested in voting for me every game regardless of alignment than actually finding scum.

What have you done to find scum?

[celaph]

The game of chicken. Who will scum save: damo or Maniac or kak or Unvote or Bona?

My money is that unvote gets saved. Terrible wagon.

[Kakarroto]

And while you are at it: why is DL defending you/reading you so high in his reads @maniac

[Maniac]

Always happy to vote Jamie of course. He seems more Interested in voting for me every game regardless of alignment than actually finding scum.

What have you done to find scum?

I looked in the wardrobe and down the back of the sofa. Nothing I’m afraid.

[BesharamSabi]

A question I have yet to hear a good answer to. I have heard plenty of bad ones, but no good ones.

Bona hasn't hunted for scum and was pushing for the miskill on durga and aaro. He's been incredibly lazy this game. Hasn't provided much reads at all, not even on me. Probably hasn't read the game during d3 at all.

Being wrong isn't scum indicative.

Yea but being wrong repeatedly that leads to miskills and then put no effort into reading the game is pretty scummy...

[Bonatogether]

What are people's opinions on Jamie and Sabi?

jamie feels town but i'm terrible at reading him so that doesn't mean much

sabi is borderline unreadable due to their new posting scheme

What new posting scheme. It's been several days now Bona. Yet new material.

despite this, you still manage to contribute nothing aside from baseless and wild conspiracy theories. i can't read that

[celaph]

A question I have yet to hear a good answer to. I have heard plenty of bad ones, but no good ones.

Bona hasn't hunted for scum and was pushing for the miskill on durga and aaro. He's been incredibly lazy this game. Hasn't provided much reads at all, not even on me. Probably hasn't read the game during d3 at all.

Being wrong isn't scum indicative.

I think this is a very disingenuous response to Sabi's point. Bona being wrong is a small part of their point with the larger focus being on the fact that Bona doesn't feel like someone trying to solve the game.

[BesharamSabi]

jamie feels town but i'm terrible at reading him so that doesn't mean much

sabi is borderline unreadable due to their new posting scheme

What new posting scheme. It's been several days now Bona. Yet new material.

despite this, you still manage to contribute nothing aside from baseless and wild conspiracy theories. i can't read that

... I literally interogratted damo about his Maniac protection and about his group of 4. I have been trying to push the game forward.

What have you done? You haven't even read the game. Read Bona or sub out.

[BesharamSabi]

Bona hasn't hunted for scum and was pushing for the miskill on durga and aaro. He's been incredibly lazy this game. Hasn't provided much reads at all, not even on me. Probably hasn't read the game during d3 at all.

Being wrong isn't scum indicative.

I think this is a very disingenuous response to Sabi's point. Bona being wrong is a small part of their point with the larger focus being on the fact that Bona doesn't feel like someone trying to solve the game.

THANK YOU.

Bona hasn't iso anyone or done anything to try to solve this game.

[Bonatogether]

What are people's opinions on Jamie and Sabi?

jamie feels town but i'm terrible at reading him so that doesn't mean much

sabi is borderline unreadable due to their new posting scheme

Besides Damo who are you scum reading?

just due to POE, probably DL if I say someone? I have a fair amount of people who are either awol (maniac), i'm not confident i can read them (jamie, pyxxy, DL), and people who are just not very readable (sabi)

[Jamiet99uk]

Always happy to vote Jamie of course. He seems more Interested in voting for me every game regardless of alignment than actually finding scum.

What have you done to find scum?

I looked in the wardrobe and down the back of the sofa. Nothing I’m afraid.

Yourself.
Fuck.
Go.

Rearrange this to find a popular phrase.

##end

[Bonatogether]

Why are you thumbs downing. Look at the game.

Tell me how this amount of participation isn't hurting the game?

It's not optimal, but asking 3 or 5 posts every 24 hours isn't a better solution, imo, cause sometimes people have things come up that preoccupy them for 24 hours or so. It's not bad, it's just a fact of how things happen.

If you don't have time for the game then sub out. People who go more than 24 hours are ruining the game.

asking that you can guarantee no nasty surprises in any given 24 hour period over 2 weeks seems like a high ask.

[BesharamSabi]

What have you done to find scum?

I looked in the wardrobe and down the back of the sofa. Nothing I’m afraid.

Yourself.
Fuck.
Go.

Rearrange this to find a popular phrase.

##end

Jamiet you can't be mad at snowy for being toxic and then do this... :/

[Bonatogether]

Last time I did 10 post was half way thru day 2. We are at the end of day 3. Why can't Bona read me? Why is he still making an excuse...

Because you have only 1 day of actually trying, and it's largely stuff that's just flat useless

[BesharamSabi]

It's not optimal, but asking 3 or 5 posts every 24 hours isn't a better solution, imo, cause sometimes people have things come up that preoccupy them for 24 hours or so. It's not bad, it's just a fact of how things happen.

If you don't have time for the game then sub out. People who go more than 24 hours are ruining the game.

asking that you can guarantee no nasty surprises in any given 24 hour period over 2 weeks seems like a high ask.

He literally didn't post for over 32 hours. It clearly affects the game when people aren't participating

[Bonatogether]

Last time I did 10 post was half way thru day 2. We are at the end of day 3. Why can't Bona read me? Why is he still making an excuse...

Two points:
1) We've had 1 EoD since then and it wasn't an EoD that you were particularly active in so he doesn't really have evidence from that perspective.
2) Generally I agree with you that it is a weak answer. In the worst case, Bona should analyze you outside of the context of your previous posting styles. In a vacuum, are your contributions towny or not?

1) sabi hasn't interact with many people in a productive way, which is how i read most people
2) no

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm not moving from Maniac.

If he's town he should be banned from playing. He has, by his own admission, made no attempt to find scum. He is not playing to town's wincon.

Goodnight.