M1021 - Blessings of Lilia - GAME THREAD [hidden]

[aarodactyl]

Ok. I think I've caught up with the thread and have responded to every question about me. I'm going to say some quick impression that I have of people and then dip for a while.

bona - I think he seems townie, but I wish he wouldn't get so worked up. This goes for a lot of people in this game, but if someone is pushing you in a way that seems unfair, you can just say that and then stop responding. You don't have to get the last zinger in.

tfb - I think his interactions with bona seem townie. I think if other people got so defensive about a possible scum tell, it would be scummy, but it seems to fit tfb.

damo - I still don't have a read on him, but I think D1 was likely (TvT)vT, so that makes him town I guess. I don't really like how he's pushing the (TvT)vT narrative because it feels like he's trying to buddy me, but at the same time I'm also pushing the same narrative so I can't really count that against him.

snowy - feel scummy but that might just be because I'm prone to scum reading people that scum read me. His reasons for voting me seem pretty empty, especially considering he's never even read a game I've played. So voting me based on vibes is wild.

ghug - probably is the priest. Honestly just including this to see if anyone actually reads these types of posts. Should vote out asap.

celaph - They were a town read, but I think null now. I should probably reread their iso but I don't have the time.

Maniac - Damo claims they've had good posts today, but they still feel scummy to me. The vote on me felt incredibly arbitrary yesterday. It was also weird how they'd pop up and provide posts that didn't relate to the game and then disappear. I think they're a bit scummy to me now, but also it's hard to read maniac and I've never seen him play as scum.

I know there's other people playing, but I don't have good reads on them at all. So null I guess.

[aarodactyl]

People usually D1 me? Guess I never noticed

I thought someone said that about you early game or maybe I assumed it from something. I guess to ask an actual question, why were you playing so weird D1?

[snowy801]

People usually D1 me? Guess I never noticed

I thought someone said that about you early game or maybe I assumed it from something. I guess to ask an actual question, why were you playing so weird D1?

I was setting up rivera to die for my sins

[Jamiet99uk]

- Maniac hasn't done one townie thing this game besides police font sizes yet people town read him??? What are people seeing that I'm not? Like damo said he was town because he stopped voting for damo?

I hate to defend Maniac (or answer for Damo) but you've not understood what Damo said properly.

Damo didnt' say he changed his read on Maniac because Maniac withdrew his vote from Damo. Damo said he changed his read on Maniac because of Maniac's stated reason for changing his vote.

This was the post in question:

What are you seeing in this that is a PR slip? I don't see it.

rdr has a trademark statement that goes "I am 100% vanilla town™"
damo is insinuating that rdr's refusal to make this post revealed he was a PR, which is kind of silly if you ask me
rdr was probably killed because aaro is scum

Looks like I’m wrong about Damo ##unvote

I can’t see scum!Damo knowing he may be an info daykill drawing any attention to a possible reason why scum nightkill rdriveria. Snowy also gets towncred for the same reason.

As you'll see it's not just an "unvote", but the reasoning for the unvote.

I hope this was helpful.

[aarodactyl]

People usually D1 me? Guess I never noticed

I thought someone said that about you early game or maybe I assumed it from something. I guess to ask an actual question, why were you playing so weird D1?

I was setting up rivera to die for my sins

I have no idea what this means.

[Jamiet99uk]

On topic of scum pairing: what is everyone's top 3 different scum pairing reads so far?

Fuck knows.

[aarodactyl]

- Maniac hasn't done one townie thing this game besides police font sizes yet people town read him??? What are people seeing that I'm not? Like damo said he was town because he stopped voting for damo?

I hate to defend Maniac (or answer for Damo) but you've not understood what Damo said properly.

Damo didnt' say he changed his read on Maniac because Maniac withdrew his vote from Damo. Damo said he changed his read on Maniac because of Maniac's stated reason for changing his vote.

This was the post in question:

rdr has a trademark statement that goes "I am 100% vanilla town™"
damo is insinuating that rdr's refusal to make this post revealed he was a PR, which is kind of silly if you ask me
rdr was probably killed because aaro is scum

Looks like I’m wrong about Damo ##unvote

I can’t see scum!Damo knowing he may be an info daykill drawing any attention to a possible reason why scum nightkill rdriveria. Snowy also gets towncred for the same reason.

As you'll see it's not just an "unvote", but the reasoning for the unvote.

I hope this was helpful.

I personally don't see why this makes Maniac more town. All he's saying is that he town reads damo. Am I missing something?

[Jamiet99uk]

I thought someone said that about you early game or maybe I assumed it from something. I guess to ask an actual question, why were you playing so weird D1?

I was setting up rivera to die for my sins

I have no idea what this means.

Rdrivera was Jesus Christ and Snowy is a horribly misunderstood Judas Iscariot.

[snowy801]

I'm sure Judas had family held hostage... or something

[snowy801]

I thought someone said that about you early game or maybe I assumed it from something. I guess to ask an actual question, why were you playing so weird D1?

I was setting up rivera to die for my sins

I have no idea what this means.

Unrelated, do you think it's just an unfortunate coincidence that this is the first shred of curiosity you've shown this day, and I'm being unfair to you for pointing this out?

[aarodactyl]

- Aaro has been weird since day one. Lots of weird oog excuses for not being around but pops up and says he is here but also doesn't say much or anything. All very cotton candy

Fair enough. I've tried to put time into the game so I don't feel guilty about signing up and being too busy, but it's been hard to put enough energy/critical thinking in.

[damo666]

@Sabi you asked why I scumread you. I don't. I just don't townread you.

Too early for sumpair analysis. Not enough data.

[aarodactyl]

I was setting up rivera to die for my sins

I have no idea what this means.

Unrelated, do you think it's just an unfortunate coincidence that this is the first shred of curiosity you've shown this day, and I'm being unfair to you for pointing this out?

I also don't understand what you're asking here. Can you rephrase it?

[Jamiet99uk]

- Maniac hasn't done one townie thing this game besides police font sizes yet people town read him??? What are people seeing that I'm not? Like damo said he was town because he stopped voting for damo?

I hate to defend Maniac (or answer for Damo) but you've not understood what Damo said properly.

Damo didnt' say he changed his read on Maniac because Maniac withdrew his vote from Damo. Damo said he changed his read on Maniac because of Maniac's stated reason for changing his vote.

This was the post in question:

Looks like I’m wrong about Damo ##unvote

I can’t see scum!Damo knowing he may be an info daykill drawing any attention to a possible reason why scum nightkill rdriveria. Snowy also gets towncred for the same reason.

As you'll see it's not just an "unvote", but the reasoning for the unvote.

I hope this was helpful.

I personally don't see why this makes Maniac more town. All he's saying is that he town reads damo. Am I missing something?

Damo is saying that scum!Maniac would not unvote town!Damo in those circumstances. Scum!Maniac, in Damo's analysis, would happily leave his vote on town!Damo in that scenario and try to get Damo miskilled.

I mean I occasionally miss details, but Damo explained this perfectly well so I'm not sure why both you and Sabi are so confused about it.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm sure Judas had family held hostage... or something

I hope that your family are safe and that nothing at all will happen to them.

[snowy801]

I have no idea what this means.

Unrelated, do you think it's just an unfortunate coincidence that this is the first shred of curiosity you've shown this day, and I'm being unfair to you for pointing this out?

I also don't understand what you're asking here. Can you rephrase it?

Never you mind. I'm mostly rambling to myself, anyway

[damo666]

I hate to defend Maniac (or answer for Damo) but you've not understood what Damo said properly.

Damo didnt' say he changed his read on Maniac because Maniac withdrew his vote from Damo. Damo said he changed his read on Maniac because of Maniac's stated reason for changing his vote.

This was the post in question:



As you'll see it's not just an "unvote", but the reasoning for the unvote.

I hope this was helpful.

I personally don't see why this makes Maniac more town. All he's saying is that he town reads damo. Am I missing something?

Damo is saying that scum!Maniac would not unvote town!Damo in those circumstances. Scum!Maniac, in Damo's analysis, would happily leave his vote on town!Damo in that scenario and try to get Damo miskilled.

I mean I occasionally miss details, but Damo explained this perfectly well so I'm not sure why both you and Sabi are so confused about it.

Thank you Jamie. Spot on.

[snowy801]

@Snowy I'll get there.

Are we there yet

[aarodactyl]

I hate to defend Maniac (or answer for Damo) but you've not understood what Damo said properly.

Damo didnt' say he changed his read on Maniac because Maniac withdrew his vote from Damo. Damo said he changed his read on Maniac because of Maniac's stated reason for changing his vote.

This was the post in question:



As you'll see it's not just an "unvote", but the reasoning for the unvote.

I hope this was helpful.

I personally don't see why this makes Maniac more town. All he's saying is that he town reads damo. Am I missing something?

Damo is saying that scum!Maniac would not unvote town!Damo in those circumstances. Scum!Maniac, in Damo's analysis, would happily leave his vote on town!Damo in that scenario and try to get Damo miskilled.

I mean I occasionally miss details, but Damo explained this perfectly well so I'm not sure why both you and Sabi are so confused about it.

I get this argument but my take is that maniac isn’t being viewed favorably so he’s getting town cred intentionally. I guess it’s a bit WIFOM though

[damo666]

@Snowy I'll get there.

Are we there yet

Not yet. Which of my townreads are wrong?