M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

If Sabi, or anyone else, presses me to explain in further detail during the Night phase.... well, you may all draw your own conclusions. The Night is not the time for such things if you ask me.

[President Eden]

If Sabi, or anyone else, presses me to explain in further detail during the Night phase.... well, you may all draw your own conclusions. The Night is not the time for such things if you ask me.

just post what you decided to do at EON

[Jamiet99uk]

If Sabi, or anyone else, presses me to explain in further detail during the Night phase.... well, you may all draw your own conclusions. The Night is not the time for such things if you ask me.

just post what you decided to do at EON

I will.

[TheFlyingBoat]

that's the second one dummy

That's why I corrected you.

but you're wrong

Sorry but I was TheFlyingJOAT a few games so. I'm basically a subject matter expert

[Bonatogether]

this is what you get for being a SIMP

lol how long has it been? 20 minutes?

"20 minutes" sorry I misread this:

i have thoughts about that day but i'm keeping my mouth shut

that's why catchup is small

i think our essential situation is basically the same as it was coming into the day. game plan doesn't change for tomorrow

as you planning to go afk for the rest of N3.

Funny no one's called you a SIMP despite being right next to me in your own SIMP rankings...maybe we're not so different after all, Bona

specifically this part

this is posted after a 2 hour dip from d2, and right before EoD. He was aware enough of the vote count despite being 'not really engaged' to post end of day reads. he puts the NFT man (already likely town), jamie (town), and the pyx as scum. i think he might have put a scum in there, which makes the pxy look worse? not willing to go far out on that. As for list 2, I think he definitely puts a scum in there. I believe that is most likely to be ghuginator, in line with the rest of the stuff so far.

i've definitely become more confident in this read with how things have gone.

Ah okay so you believe that Maniac was the Flipper and chose VT, which means [redacted what I had here in my draft, I can always post it after night ends].

That's probably why I didn't understand your scumread on me at first, because I honestly just want to see N3 go through and hopefully [more redacted from my draft] and then that helps sort things out on D4. As it stands I'm really not sure who to believe, which means I feel sucked in by the most influential posters Brainbomb and Eden. But that's not good for town. I should be thinking through things on my own. I swear I'm trying.

If you do currently believe that Maniac was Flipper scum, then I don't see an argument (before D4) that would change you reading me as scum, if your entire feeling is based off Maniac's list.

Which I don't think is the case? It feels like you're withholding some thoughts for D4, which is totally reasonable. I'm just responding to what you kindly highlighted for me.

It would be much easier if you thought Maniac was VT and that he had a real scum read on me. To that I would just say, his entire scum read on me by EOD D2 was...because I was a low poster on D1? Which, I mean, that's why I voted Kak on D1
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?us ... 7Cpyx&g=73

Maniac doesn't mention me ever again after D2. Probably because he was too busy defending himself? And theoretically as Flipper he wouldn't want to draw attention to any scum (i.e. me) that he tried to slip past you previously with his own scum read. Right?

I do scum read chaqa for already vocalising that if I flip miller I must be the flipper.

Brainbomb, Demon and Chaqa are your scum

In which case this quote seals the deal on your argument, Bona. Brainbomb has done great work for town. Chaqa was town on Maniac's first list, scum now that Flipper Maniac knows he's gonna die. Demon is just another person interacting with Maniac on D3, so Maniac throws him in for shits and giggles.

You do agree that "Brainbomb, Demon and Chaqa" are all town, yeah? I think I currently believe this to be true.

Meta-comment, let me know if this was a good response. The word "response" seems like slang for a specific kind of reply, in a way that I don't quite understand yet.

i am going to be largely afk tomorrow, by coincidence, but for OOG reasons.

there are only 3 ideas in a mafia thread and 2 of them are mafia, checks out

skipping responding to some paragraphs

"It would be much easier if..." -> easier for who? I'm confused

"In which case this quote seals the deal on your argument, Bona." -> I disagree. Mafia don't often repeat interactions that they initiate as part of a direct mafia agenda. I'm also not sure why this would seal the deal against what I had.

"Meta-comment, let me know if this was a good response. The word "response" seems like slang for a specific kind of reply, in a way that I don't quite understand yet." -> Imo, you're getting there. It's posts but not yet digging into full reasonings for mafia. you should stop trying and sheep me for the rest of the game.

[Bonatogether]

That's why I corrected you.

but you're wrong

Sorry but I was TheFlyingJOAT a few games so. I'm basically a subject matter expert

BonaTV news finds this story to be: false

[BesharamSabi]

If Sabi, or anyone else, presses me to explain in further detail during the Night phase.... well, you may all draw your own conclusions. The Night is not the time for such things if you ask me.

I won't press till eon.

[BesharamSabi]

I guess since we are just sitting till eon I'm going to work on spreadsheet so it forces me to reread.

[BusinessLamp]

Last thought for now, as I'm clogging the game thread. Let me know if I'm completely off base here.

I doubt that mafia is ever going to NK me, because as a newbie, I've got no experience with end game situations so I'm undoubtably going to be a weaker than average player for late-game town.

Nah I mean I got killed night three last game. but also I somehow only voted mafia night one LOL

[President Eden]

I’m going to do some VCA based on both Maniac scenarios.

FWIW I think Jamie is basically 100% guilty of Maniac is actually VT, so I think we should keep that in mind if we do decide Maniac is VT

[pyxxy]

"In which case this quote seals the deal on your argument, Bona." -> I disagree. Mafia don't often repeat interactions that they initiate as part of a direct mafia agenda. I'm also not sure why this would seal the deal against what I had.

No I'm saying it seals the deal for your argument, like you can just peace out for another Day phase, you've already solved the problem. Bad choice of idiom on my part. Basically I'm already trying to sheep you here...just, against myself.

[rdrivera2005]

If the JOAT is able, I think it now makes sense to shoot either Flum or rivera.

I vote rdr

The bulk of the ghug "not voting scum" case collapses with Maniac as scum.
Jamiet lying when not under pressure to take out Maniac makes no sense as the alternative.

Rdr's reaction look like defeated scum who've lost 2 of their partners.

Find a game where I surrendered as scum? The biggest advantage of being town is that you don't need to stay alive to help the team. I don't mind being Vig shot if you are the kill tomorrow or vice-versa. You are scum tryng desperately to find s way out from the trap you got.

[DemonRHK]

Attention restaurant customers...

[President Eden]

Attention restaurant customers…

>season 20 on youtube
how is this show still going?

[DemonRHK]

Flum's current mafia mindset: A tale of two simultaneous approaches.

[DemonRHK]

Jamie every time he checks the thread.

[DemonRHK]

Live look at sabi and brain doing ISOs, spreadsheets, and theories...

[DemonRHK]

List y'all I've been slamming red bull and tequila the shitposting WILL continue until morale improves.

[DemonRHK]

EXCLUSIVE video of rdr's current online status.

[President Eden]

demon brother go drunk you’re home