M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

@TFB why is Sabi unlikely scum

can we just use this time to have a referendum on Sabi and their alignment, thanks everyone

Town Security Council Motion 001: On the subject of BesharamSabi
Proposal: do you think Sabi is town?

Yay: Chaqa
Nay:
Abstain:

[brainbomb]

@TFB why is Sabi unlikely scum

can we just use this time to have a referendum on Sabi and their alignment, thanks everyone

Town Security Council Motion 001: On the subject of BesharamSabi
Proposal: do you think Sabi is town?

Yay: Chaqa
Nay:
Abstain: brainbomb

[President Eden]

Not put him as town but don't wave him bringing up the fight as a reason he's scummy. Bringing up the fight is NAI.

You two just need to communicate.

Everything PE said, whether correct or not, was game related. I think ghug's reaction was scum indicative and my preference would be to resolve ghug's slot today.

Bozo, kindly, you don't know ghug outside of the game so I feel like you don't know what is going on outside of the game. Him bringing up the fight is NAI.

bizarre deflection as bozo made no comment whatsoever on whether ghug bringing up the fight was alignment indicative

[President Eden]

@TFB why is Sabi unlikely scum

can we just use this time to have a referendum on Sabi and their alignment, thanks everyone

Town Security Council Motion 001: On the subject of BesharamSabi
Proposal: do you think Sabi is town?

Yay: Chaqa
Nay:
Abstain:

brb invading Ukraine

[brainbomb]

James Yanik disapproves

[Chaqa]

Everything PE said, whether correct or not, was game related. I think ghug's reaction was scum indicative and my preference would be to resolve ghug's slot today.

Bozo, kindly, you don't know ghug outside of the game so I feel like you don't know what is going on outside of the game. Him bringing up the fight is NAI.

bizarre deflection as bozo made no comment whatsoever on whether ghug bringing up the fight was alignment indicative

He did though?

[BesharamSabi]

Bozo, kindly, you don't know ghug outside of the game so I feel like you don't know what is going on outside of the game. Him bringing up the fight is NAI.

bizarre deflection as bozo made no comment whatsoever on whether ghug bringing up the fight was alignment indicative

He did though?

Yea: "think ghug's reaction was scum indicative"

What part of that isn't a comment eden?

[Chaqa]

That said, it's not super relevant as Bozo is clear and with no ghug in the game it probably doesn't matter to anything atm.

[President Eden]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

[Chaqa]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

I think we're best served just ignoring all of it *for the moment*

[BesharamSabi]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

Instead of dropping the subject you want to scrutinize it further. All I'm saying is if someone doesn't know what's going out of the game they should not comment on it which will further make things worse. Also ghug isn't here to defend himself against these allegations.

Can we just drop it.

[BesharamSabi]

That said, it's not super relevant as Bozo is clear and with no ghug in the game it probably doesn't matter to anything atm.

How is bozo clear of apparently Jamiet is the cop?

[BesharamSabi]

Bozo was only clear because eden gave a "scan" but Jamiet claimed cop and scanned Maniac as guilty.

Am I missing something?

Isn't there one cop?

How are we clearing bozo then?

[President Eden]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

Instead of dropping the subject you want to scrutinize it further. All I'm saying is if someone doesn't know what's going out of the game they should not comment on it which will further make things worse. Also ghug isn't here to defend himself against these allegations.

Can we just drop it.

No.

I made an entire case on ghug which has nothing to do with his departure from the game. bozo and indeed everyone else is entitled to comment on it.

Stop trying to control the conversation and distort what happened into a personal fight.

[Chaqa]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

Instead of dropping the subject you want to scrutinize it further. All I'm saying is if someone doesn't know what's going out of the game they should not comment on it which will further make things worse. Also ghug isn't here to defend himself against these allegations.

Can we just drop it.

I don't think it's unfair for Eden to still be suspicious of ghug's slot. None of his original scumread was based off ghug's reactions, even if we factor our the additional scumread from it.

[President Eden]

@TFB why is Sabi unlikely scum

can we just use this time to have a referendum on Sabi and their alignment, thanks everyone

Town Security Council Motion 001: On the subject of BesharamSabi
Proposal: do you think Sabi is town?

Yay: Chaqa
Nay:
Abstain:

Yay but with severe reservations.

[Chaqa]

That said, it's not super relevant as Bozo is clear and with no ghug in the game it probably doesn't matter to anything atm.

How is bozo clear of apparently Jamiet is the cop?

Long story. We can come back to it later.

[BesharamSabi]

I read further into bozo’s statement, maybe wrongly. Thought he meant the reaction to my case and not whatever that outburst was the next day.

Nonetheless I find Sabi’s implicit premise that you cannot have a belief about ghug’s reaction to a totally in game case on him if you don’t know him outside the game to be highly logically suspect

Instead of dropping the subject you want to scrutinize it further. All I'm saying is if someone doesn't know what's going out of the game they should not comment on it which will further make things worse. Also ghug isn't here to defend himself against these allegations.

Can we just drop it.

No.

I made an entire case on ghug which has nothing to do with his departure from the game. bozo and indeed everyone else is entitled to comment on it.

Stop trying to control the conversation and distort what happened into a personal fight.

Bring up the slot without bringing up the reaction over the fight from m71 is what I'm saying.

[BesharamSabi]

That said, it's not super relevant as Bozo is clear and with no ghug in the game it probably doesn't matter to anything atm.

How is bozo clear of apparently Jamiet is the cop?

Long story. We can come back to it later.

No, I want to hear it. Why are we clearing bozo if Jamiet is the cop?

[President Eden]

Instead of dropping the subject you want to scrutinize it further. All I'm saying is if someone doesn't know what's going out of the game they should not comment on it which will further make things worse. Also ghug isn't here to defend himself against these allegations.

Can we just drop it.

No.

I made an entire case on ghug which has nothing to do with his departure from the game. bozo and indeed everyone else is entitled to comment on it.

Stop trying to control the conversation and distort what happened into a personal fight.

Bring up the slot without bringing up the reaction over the fight from m71 is what I'm saying.

Now you are the one reading into what bozo said. He made no specific comment about what aspect of ghug’s reaction was scummy. You inserted that interpretation into it and then tried to shut down bozo’s comment. Which is EXACTLY what I was originally saying.