M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[President Eden]

Eden why did you have issues with ghug questioning Bona towncore but not brain saying something similar about Nona?

the answer to this depends on whether you read my post (beyond skimming to see that accusing ghug based in part on his statements about Bona) or not

I haven’t read it yet but I will.

the motivation is very different. if your takeaway is “Eden hates when people question Bona” then you missed the mark on what the treatise against ghug was saying.

the timing of ghug’s objection and his consistent misrepresentation of what is happening is all consistent with mafia trying to stop the formation of a town core that can run away with the game, and not particularly consistent with a townie trying to figure out what that town core should be, as ghug is trying to posture himself

brain’s comment is an observation that some people haven’t been questioned a lot. there’s no clear agenda behind it

[Chaqa]

Hey Eden, pick a number between 1 and 10

[President Eden]

Hey Eden, pick a number between 1 and 10

4.2069

[brainbomb]

Howdy!

Are you scum again son?

I was really scared to read my role pm, but we good lol.

One more thought for the night
Celaph was scared to read role pm but sees hes godfather and realizes he doesnt need to do much day 1 and might get cop scanned so hes “good”

additionally this tells us hes good because his scum partners are also good at being scum and thus hes good.

discuss if you agree with these points because I think this might rule out some team compositions if celaph is good with what he saw and if it was like pyxxy, sabi, business I dont think he even says this

[brainbomb]

at the very least I think celaph is happy he rolled godfather

[Chaqa]

Hey Eden, pick a number between 1 and 10

4.2069

Acknowledged.

[President Eden]

monkaS

[brainbomb]

that reaction seems more in line with being unafraid of two cop scans imo

[Chaqa]

at the very least I think celaph is happy he rolled godfather

Or he just said it for shits and giggles.

Also, celaph has rolled scum soooo much in the last 10-15 games. Like jeez

[President Eden]

[furiously checks player list to be sure he isn’t #4]

[brainbomb]

at the very least I think celaph is happy he rolled godfather

Or he just said it for shits and giggles.

Also, celaph has rolled scum soooo much in the last 10-15 games. Like jeez

but based on his lurky play and this statement doesnt it seem more likely to come from a person immune to cop scans than a flipper?

[President Eden]

oh no brainbomb

i’m so sorry

[President Eden]

at the very least I think celaph is happy he rolled godfather

Or he just said it for shits and giggles.

Also, celaph has rolled scum soooo much in the last 10-15 games. Like jeez

but based on his lurky play and this statement doesnt it seem more likely to come from a person immune to cop scans than a flipper?

if there’s significance to be attached to it then yes, it strongly points to genuine Godfather and not Flipper-Godfather.

unclear how much to attach, but I’m willing to buy that part for sure.

[brainbomb]

at the very least I think celaph is happy he rolled godfather

Or he just said it for shits and giggles.

Also, celaph has rolled scum soooo much in the last 10-15 games. Like jeez

Yea I dont think so. I think its a genuine reaction implying thank god I dont have to do shit and ill get towncleared anyway

[BesharamSabi]

Reading blamp day 2,

I don't understand why he went from "brainbomb accept pyxxy as towncore" at start of day 2 to being like "daddy brain we need to vote out pyxxy" by end of D2.

All over +1ing posts?

This seems like a wild escalation.

In b4 Bona ask me what is the scum motivation for this.

[Bonatogether]

Reading blamp day 2,

I don't understand why he went from "brainbomb accept pyxxy as towncore" at start of day 2 to being like "daddy brain we need to vote out pyxxy" by end of D2.

All over +1ing posts?

This seems like a wild escalation.

In b4 Bona ask me what is the scum motivation for this.

well you never take the time to connect the dots lol

finding stuff is part 1 of scum hunting

[BesharamSabi]

##vote celaph

leggooooo

14 minutes earlier(and the whole day 2was celaph is town)

anyway wow we really have a 6-6-5 huh.

I’m cool with any of these flipping but vaguely think it should be a D1 wagon and more probably FTB specifically.

trying my best to avoid making dirty stinking info kill arguments but it’s hard not to think about those ramifications when all 3 wagons are good here.

that said it’s kinda weird to me that we’re all just kinda cool with all 3 of these. very uncommon on webDip

I'm not cool with Maniac - what information will we gain from that flip?

celaph is likely town

That reaction of voting for someone you were screaming from dawn was town seems so off. Like why would you be excited to vote for you town read like that? Only a reaction of scum bussing makes sense since he was never connected with making celaph town?

Idk that vote seems so off tone from all his celaph comments.

Is this another one of my Sabi is grasping at straws theory?

[brainbomb]

ghug mentions of celaph

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?us ... elaph&g=73

overall not great stances and I hover between ghug is just experiencing fomo about celaph dying and him having the wrong take on it. not sure if ghug ever was blatantly saving celaph or just was mistaken

[Chaqa]

monkaS

I do actually need a whole number though

[brainbomb]

celaph mentions of ghug

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?us ... =ghug&g=73

celaph is just hard trying to pocket ghug and I cant tell if this is scum protectionism or celaph just doesnt want ghug to realize hes actually trying to curry him