M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BesharamSabi]

##call gm or anyone in general:

If none of the phases are hammered, what is the phase for next Wednesday the 9th? My work trip was confirmed that day so I just need to know

[ghug]

##call gm or anyone in general:

If none of the phases are hammered, what is the phase for next Wednesday the 9th? My work trip was confirmed that day so I just need to know

It's the middle of day 5

[ghug]

##call gm or anyone in general:

If none of the phases are hammered, what is the phase for next Wednesday the 9th? My work trip was confirmed that day so I just need to know

It's the middle of day 5

JK it's night now so it's the end of N4

[DemonRHK]

Sabi...I have concerns.

why would celaph hedge you so hard D1 and only claim you were scum when the very real chance they were going to flip?

No idea, haven't read eod yet. Could you link?

EOD1

[Chaqa]

and yea brain is fine that chat thing isn’t real. probably. like 99%. there, I put a percentage, figure out what role I’m softing this time

You're the Candice arent you

[bozotheclown]

My preliminary assessment is that I must be mafia.

[President Eden]

I don’t see any reason to townread Bona

what.

bro you cannot be serious lmao.

you flat out do not believe this. i refuse to believe you believe this.

you could have sold me on “not ready to townclear Bona” but the kid has been solving his fucking ass off all game and correctly lit celaph on fucking fire for almost a week now.

someone vig this man

I do believe this.

• Bona has proven to be highly capable as scum.

• His posts aren’t standing out to me as much as they usually do.

• One of the biggest contributions I do remember is the Simp score work which, while great, is data analysis, which has a history of being something scum hide behind.

• Another big contribution is killing celaph, but he was an early voter day 1, when celaph wasn’t active, and it’s very easy to imagine scum looking at last game and deciding celaph is dead weight not worth protecting. Day 2 means even less to me, because there’s no fucking way celaph wasn’t heavily bussed after how D1 went down

Town tends to lose games where we catch scum early I think in part because there become a bunch of more obvious kills and we don’t spend time aggregating data on the people who come out of the scum deaths looking good. Let’s not exclude half the game from the PoE again because we caught one.

open scumclaim

[BesharamSabi]

Sabi...I have concerns.

why would celaph hedge you so hard D1 and only claim you were scum when the very real chance they were going to flip?

No idea, haven't read eod yet. Could you link?

EOD1

Going to have to reread eod1 but I honestly dunno. He was sussing me that whole day tbf and shading me. But I need to reread it again. (I'm not dodging answering this)

[BesharamSabi]

##call gm or anyone in general:

If none of the phases are hammered, what is the phase for next Wednesday the 9th? My work trip was confirmed that day so I just need to know

It's the middle of day 5

JK it's night now so it's the end of N4

Thank you. As long I don't die or we hammer I don't need to be subbed out.

[ghug]

what.

bro you cannot be serious lmao.

you flat out do not believe this. i refuse to believe you believe this.

you could have sold me on “not ready to townclear Bona” but the kid has been solving his fucking ass off all game and correctly lit celaph on fucking fire for almost a week now.

someone vig this man

I do believe this.

• Bona has proven to be highly capable as scum.

• His posts aren’t standing out to me as much as they usually do.

• One of the biggest contributions I do remember is the Simp score work which, while great, is data analysis, which has a history of being something scum hide behind.

• Another big contribution is killing celaph, but he was an early voter day 1, when celaph wasn’t active, and it’s very easy to imagine scum looking at last game and deciding celaph is dead weight not worth protecting. Day 2 means even less to me, because there’s no fucking way celaph wasn’t heavily bussed after how D1 went down

Town tends to lose games where we catch scum early I think in part because there become a bunch of more obvious kills and we don’t spend time aggregating data on the people who come out of the scum deaths looking good. Let’s not exclude half the game from the PoE again because we caught one.

open scumclaim

Well at least we're disagreeing on everything again.

[pyxxy]

hoooooooly shit thank god my vote change was too late

Yes, but what the fuck was that?

I was wavering for most of the last hour (while also playing in the FB speedboat bot game so half focused) and I wanted it off my conscience if Celaph flipped town. I figured I was safe at 9-5-3 to change and make it 8-6-3.

Topped the board btw (game finally ended after 4+ hours)

https://webdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=399381

[Jamiet99uk]

because jamie likes metal music and slayer is a metal band.
its a follow up of my from the maf chat joke

worst of the big four
I'd have Testament instead of Slayer.

Seriously.

[BusinessLamp]

FYI this weekend (Friday night to Sunday night) I will be flying to Cali to celebrate a friend’s bday but I’m still gonna try and be as active as I can muster.

[Jamiet99uk]

@DemonRHK why did you go missing for 48 hours??

[Bonatogether]

I don’t see any reason to townread Bona

what.

bro you cannot be serious lmao.

you flat out do not believe this. i refuse to believe you believe this.

you could have sold me on “not ready to townclear Bona” but the kid has been solving his fucking ass off all game and correctly lit celaph on fucking fire for almost a week now.

someone vig this man

I do believe this.

• Bona has proven to be highly capable as scum.

I want to push back on this because everyone has said that I was too scummy to be scum. I didn't pick up on that. I was misreading the situation to overstate how towny I was, and so I don't think that justifies a claim of me being highly capable as scum.

[ghug]

what.

bro you cannot be serious lmao.

you flat out do not believe this. i refuse to believe you believe this.

you could have sold me on “not ready to townclear Bona” but the kid has been solving his fucking ass off all game and correctly lit celaph on fucking fire for almost a week now.

someone vig this man

I do believe this.

• Bona has proven to be highly capable as scum.

I want to push back on this because everyone has said that I was too scummy to be scum. I didn't pick up on that. I was misreading the situation to overstate how towny I was, and so I don't think that justifies a claim of me being highly capable as scum.

Ok but you're also like pretty smart and unlikely to do exactly that again, and it did work to an extent in that game.

[DemonRHK]

@DemonRHK why did you go missing for 48 hours??

First half of D2: Shirking work and played Civ all day, hang out with the SO all night.

Second half: Got called out for shirking work, had to work twice as hard.

I am not a smart man

[President Eden]

My preliminary assessment is that I must be mafia.

this is exactly the kind of hard-hitting contribution I was hoping for if I happened to clear you

[Chaqa]

Final group of celaph voters:
Demon
Bona
pyxxy
worcej
brainbomb
Blamp
TFB
damo

People who ended on celaph D1:
Bona
Eden
brainbomb
Demon
Kak
Chaqa

I find people who voted for celaph on D2 but not D1 to be interesting:
pyxxy - never voted celaph D1
worcej - wasn't around D1
Blamp - Stronb bus candidate
TFB - counterwagon
damo - never voted celaph D1

[Bonatogether]

I do believe this.

• Bona has proven to be highly capable as scum.

I want to push back on this because everyone has said that I was too scummy to be scum. I didn't pick up on that. I was misreading the situation to overstate how towny I was, and so I don't think that justifies a claim of me being highly capable as scum.

Ok but you're also like pretty smart and unlikely to do exactly that again, and it did work to an extent in that game.

pack it up boys, ghug called me smart

more seriously, sure? idk what i'd do but it's not this super great performance you're talking about