M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BusinessLamp]

replaced one scummy out of game issues wrinkle with a new busy work wrinkle

The best explanations are based on truth.

stop trying to buddy him with more Aristotle quotes

[Chaqa]

the QRD (and then I REALLY REALLY need to get something done today smh) on where I’m at:

I do think Kak died as a result of mafia saving a teammate.
Decreasingly I think that teammate was celaph. Increasingly I think it was Boat. Not to dictate what anybody does, but it would be really helpful if we knew both of their alignments by the start of the next day. I had intended to take care of that myself… but I strongly doubt I’ll be allowed to do so now.

But regardless, some considerations:
• if celaph is mafia and Boat is town, Chaqa’s analysis on celaph being mafia is very strong.
• if Boat is mafia and celaph is town, then I think Maniac is also suspicious for reasons spelled out by Demon and Lamp. incidentally I think both of those guys are town for spelling that out.
• if they’re BOTH mafia… idk man that’s wild.
• if they’re both town then oops lol. Maniac can still be sus here but I would re-examine everything if that’s so.

Oh goddammit Eden you dork

This is absolute comedy now

[BusinessLamp]

Jamie/Blamp/Sabi > Maniac > TFB >>>> bozo in likelihood to be scum.

Now, perhaps you're bad at math, but ">" means greater than. And the use of "/" distinguishes a sense of equality and not "more than".

here I was thinking “/“ indicated division

[Chaqa]

Eden at any point were you concerned that maybe the cop would cc you here? this is pretty high risk the way this went down

I appreciate you but we’ve crossed the Rubicon, cast all the dice into the River and then drunkenly burned down the bridges in anger at having lost the dice.

No, I was not worried about me cc’ing myself.

It’s okay eden you’ll be safe and sound I promise

Source: trust me bro

[worcej]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

[Chaqa]

the QRD (and then I REALLY REALLY need to get something done today smh) on where I’m at:

I do think Kak died as a result of mafia saving a teammate.
Decreasingly I think that teammate was celaph. Increasingly I think it was Boat. Not to dictate what anybody does, but it would be really helpful if we knew both of their alignments by the start of the next day. I had intended to take care of that myself… but I strongly doubt I’ll be allowed to do so now.

But regardless, some considerations:
• if celaph is mafia and Boat is town, Chaqa’s analysis on celaph being mafia is very strong.
• if Boat is mafia and celaph is town, then I think Maniac is also suspicious for reasons spelled out by Demon and Lamp. incidentally I think both of those guys are town for spelling that out.
• if they’re BOTH mafia… idk man that’s wild.
• if they’re both town then oops lol. Maniac can still be sus here but I would re-examine everything if that’s so.

Thank you for this post, finally someone explains what they expect from killing Celaph instead of just repeating "it will sure show a lot, haha".

Lmao pyx like five people have done this already.

[brainbomb]

Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made

[Jamiet99uk]

I wasn't here for D1 - I didn't know I was subbed in until N1 and even then was not available to really give this game attention until yesterday.

So, just to summarise, you've decided that if Celaph dies and flips scum, I become your #1 scumread because of my EoD vote, BUT you've made no attempt to go back and see what my stated reasoning was for said vote.

Superlative detective work right there, Holmes.

No, you're in equal footing with Blamp and Sabi as suspicious. I'd be focusing my attention on analyzing the three of you.

You notice how I listed it right?

Jamie/Blamp/Sabi > Maniac > TFB >>>> bozo in likelihood to be scum.

Now, perhaps you're bad at math, but ">" means greater than. And the use of "/" distinguishes a sense of equality and not "more than".

Oh I'm sorry, equal first rather than first alone.

Great clarification.

[Jamiet99uk]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

There's no need to be so fucking rude.

[brainbomb]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

Out of the crooked fuckstick of humanity, no straight thing was ever made

[damo666]

Eden at any point were you concerned that maybe the cop would cc you here? this is pretty high risk the way this went down

I appreciate you but we’ve crossed the Rubicon, cast all the dice into the River and then drunkenly burned down the bridges in anger at having lost the dice.

No, I was not worried about me cc’ing myself.

dont worry I was roleblocked last night so youll be in my arms tonight instead. with our puppy hildy

I suggest you ISO Bob

[Jamiet99uk]

Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made

You're damned if you do, and you're damned if you don't.

[worcej]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

There's no need to be so fucking rude.

That's incredibly rich coming from you

[pyxxy]

based on the +1s pyxxy liked all of
kakarrotos posts early game and gave them all a +1

where does pyxxy go from liking the way kak is playing to progressing that kak is OKAY! lets kill this guy sure!

I agree that pyxxy should answer for his actions, but there is nothing here with this +1 thing. As far as I can tell, pyxxy +1'd 3 of Kak's posts. The first one was Kak's opener which was purely fun flavor. The third one was Kak making a joke about among us. The second one is a post with legitimate reads, but it also happens to be a post with bright colors and fun comments. I think all 3 of those +1s can be explained by Pyxxy appreciated the post from a fun and/or funny perspective. Not of that suggests he townread Kak.

Celaph nails me yet again

Combine this with:

I propose we make the counter wagons from pyxxy, flyingboat, and one of our absentee players worcej or rdrivera

discuss
I prefer we not use today to hammer celaph

+0.5 to getting another wagon going, boat seems like a fine choice to drive again

why is boat a good wagon? you drop this in and never mention him again. agreeing with the only person pushing you as scum on their other option seems a strange instinct

It's because I agreed with your opinion on TFB's post here, blamp:

Why on earth would I kill Snowy if I were scum? If I were scum why would any mafia team let me kill Snowy there instead of a better target?

Like it doesn't make sense. Yes Snowy pressured me, but his attacks were weak and self defeating. If he were scum I would want him alive so he could keep making those self defeating attacks so that I could get free engagement points off of it and suck the air out of the room while not fearing being day killed given his best argument against me was that I kept running away from him and hiding when a cursory analysis showed that I had both talked to him and analyzed/talked about him a lot.

On the other hand killing him would lead to bad but easily eaten up arguments like this that are based on the logic that Snowy pressured me therefore I killed him to escape that pressure, which other voters are much more likely to believe than Snowy's presses, so it actually serves to drive up the heat on me which scum!me would want to avoid.

Somebody thought a lot about how he would deal with snowy if he were scum...

this is honestly really salient to me lol this TFB post is weird af

And Boat was the third prominent wagon from D1. If 1+ mafia did indeed switch to Kak/Celaph to save Boat and then help drive the Kak wagon off the cliff, we can increase this hunch if Boat flips scum.

There's a similar argument to be made for the outcome of a Celaph scum flip, except as I wrote in a bigger post earlier, my feelings on possibly town!Celaph have increased because of his consistent posting style/frequency and because of the lack of people explaining (prior to Eden) what they planned to get from a Celaph town/scum flip.

There at least seems to be a lot more confidence from the crowd that everyone will get some information from a Boat DK, even if they're still somewhat unwilling to share what that is.

[Jamiet99uk]

Worcej doing his analysis as if all the posts prior to the current phase have been deleted and only the vote count is left. Great.

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

Out of the crooked fuckstick of humanity, no straight thing was ever made

Are you victimising me because I'm bisexual?

[pyxxy]

Thank you for this post, finally someone explains what they expect from killing Celaph instead of just repeating "it will sure show a lot, haha".

Lmao pyx like five people have done this already.

I'm just bad at reading then rip me not refreshing and seeing this before my response to blamp, now the reasoning is all wrong

[President Eden]

replaced one scummy out of game issues wrinkle with a new busy work wrinkle

The best explanations are based on truth.

stop trying to buddy him with more Aristotle quotes

I thought that was Deykart.

[Jamiet99uk]

No fuckstick, I am focusing on the now and I believe celaph has the best information to be gained by being flipped and provided what I think would be the next logical step of information processing should celaph flip scum.

I don't have unlimited fucking time to go down every damn rabbit hole like you can.

There's no need to be so fucking rude.

That's incredibly rich coming from you

I haven't called you any rude names at any point.

Why are you suddenly being so salty?

I remember a time I thought you and I got along pretty well.

[brainbomb]

I admire pyxxy.
It takes alot to completely ignore questions asked and to just plunder on instead pretending not to know how to go back and read.

Nicely done.

the stubborness is towny in some way

[pyxxy]

I admire pyxxy.
It takes alot to completely ignore questions asked and to just plunder on instead pretending not to know how to go back and read.

Nicely done.

the stubborness is towny in some way

yay my buddying worked!