M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BesharamSabi]

This actually means Sabi isn't linked too strongly to celaph, more so linked to TFB, which does reassure me a bit because I wasn't leaning too much toward Sabi being scum.

Seems like the link is celaph to Blamp and Bozo, which is EXACTLY what snowy was saying, and he got killed.

I think we got them gang.

Yea my link is with tfb, which I made abundantly clear. I townread boatman, he's in my core with Bona and Ghug.

[Chaqa]

This actually means Sabi isn't linked too strongly to celaph, more so linked to TFB, which does reassure me a bit because I wasn't leaning too much toward Sabi being scum.

Seems like the link is celaph to Blamp and Bozo, which is EXACTLY what snowy was saying, and he got killed.

I think we got them gang.

Yea my link is with tfb, which I made abundantly clear. I townread boatman, he's in my core with Bona and Ghug.

Ghug is probably scum tbh

[Chaqa]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

[rdrivera2005]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

I just don't see where this conclusion came, could you explain?

[Chaqa]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

I just don't see where this conclusion came, could you explain?

Read Part 1 on the previous page.

Blamp is also a good target.

[Bonatogether]

I hadn't caught up. Just looked at voters on peterbot

again, why did you think kak was scummy throughout the day

lack of engagement

why do you think that is scummy?

[ghug]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

I just don't see where this conclusion came, could you explain?

That's the one part of his write-up I fully agree with.

[President Eden]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

hard veto, check back in 24 hours

[Bonatogether]

I mean Donny pulled it off last game.

that shouldn’t have worked and obviously people will be hyper-aware of it this game so it wouldn’t be a viable strategy. Do betterrrrrr

Idk man this is what it feels like to me. Shrug emoji

you have to connect reasons to why scum would do it

copy paste the rest of our discussion here

[Maniac]

Here:


And here:


And pretty much implied here:

Yeah, fair dues, but apart from those examples, when have I ever said I’d daykill anyone who voted for Celaph?

I've proved I wasn't lying, as you knew I would easily be able to do.

What was the point of accusing me of lying when you knew that accusation wouldn't stick?

Just for shits and giggles really and to pass the time.

[Bonatogether]

I mean Donny pulled it off last game.

This is different because that was 1) d1, 2) he was not very active and was just throwing his vote on teammates to avoid dealing with town, which is clearly not what blamp is doing

But what is blamp doing besides trying to save his scummates while bussing one of his own (half heartedly may I add)

show why scum!blamp only acts this way in these circumstances, and then how that lines up with his theorized scumbuddies acting. making a claim about 3 scum on d2 requires a lot of work that i just haven't seen put in to justify it

[Chaqa]

again, why did you think kak was scummy throughout the day

lack of engagement

why do you think that is scummy?

Isn’t that a little hypocritical?

[Chaqa]

lack of engagement

why do you think that is scummy?

Isn’t that a little hypocritical?

Sorry, this was meant to quote Damo, not Bona

[Bonatogether]

Scumteam
sabi
pyxxy
ghug
and one other person among tfb-eden-rivera

Sabi could easily be scum here, sure
I don't feel pyxxy as scum yet. Maybe
I can't read ghug at all
legit list, could be expanded a lot i feel

[Bonatogether]

@eden - I can’t help you with your puzzle

@Bona - you’re in my town core team; congratulations. But you’re off target with your SIMP analysis. Firstly, where is snowy on your list? Apart from that the only thing we know is the person with the lowest SIMP value (Kak) is town. You’ve then deduced that the person with the second lowest SIMP value, Celaph, must be scum. Think you need to re-look at this.

@Sabi - you’re also I’m my town core, so much so that I’d die on that hill. I recall when I first started playing I toyed with creating a spreadsheet like yours, but I’m lazy so it never happened. I just can’t see scum faking this, and if scum!Sabi is faking this, you deserve to win. I might just sheep you this game.

@celaph voters. - I’ve re-read Celaph and still can’t see anything scummy about them. Y’all wrong.

Kak disappeared for most of d1 and celaph did not. Celaph had discussion and isn't responding to discussion about himself. He continues to not make up the shortfall. There is a difference. The raw SIMP score is not especially meaningful but in context it is useful, I believe.

Snowy was not exceptionally noteworthy wrt SIMP. All of his scores are between -5 and 5 except for his with Jamie (-7, which appears to be not engaging as much) and kak (12, who rarely posted enough to engage with anyone until the end). By this analysis, he had a level of mutual interactions similar to every other person in the game who was active except Jamie, and that is only by a little.

I think I am missing something... when did we make SIMP scores...

Wtf game did I sub into?

it's somewhere in the late 90s

[BesharamSabi]

This actually means Sabi isn't linked too strongly to celaph, more so linked to TFB, which does reassure me a bit because I wasn't leaning too much toward Sabi being scum.

Seems like the link is celaph to Blamp and Bozo, which is EXACTLY what snowy was saying, and he got killed.

I think we got them gang.

Yea my link is with tfb, which I made abundantly clear. I townread boatman, he's in my core with Bona and Ghug.

Ghug is probably scum tbh

I don't see it tho. He's not giving me scum vibes and I have seen scum ghug

[BesharamSabi]

If celaph flips scum I would very much endorse the JOAT popping Bozo.

I just don't see where this conclusion came, could you explain?

Read Part 1 on the previous page.

Blamp is also a good target.

I'm glad we are on same page about blamp

[BesharamSabi]

This is different because that was 1) d1, 2) he was not very active and was just throwing his vote on teammates to avoid dealing with town, which is clearly not what blamp is doing

But what is blamp doing besides trying to save his scummates while bussing one of his own (half heartedly may I add)

show why scum!blamp only acts this way in these circumstances, and then how that lines up with his theorized scumbuddies acting. making a claim about 3 scum on d2 requires a lot of work that i just haven't seen put in to justify it

Snowy and Chaqa had made connections between blamp, celaph and bozo as scum trio. There's a connection between all three (and Maniac if you add his weird defense over celaph).

[Jamiet99uk]

Yeah, fair dues, but apart from those examples, when have I ever said I’d daykill anyone who voted for Celaph?

I've proved I wasn't lying, as you knew I would easily be able to do.

What was the point of accusing me of lying when you knew that accusation wouldn't stick?

Just for shits and giggles really and to pass the time.

Teehee.

But your vote is still on me. Do you think I am scum? Why do you think that, if you do?

[Bonatogether]

@damo

sabi claimed vt day one under minimal pressure and said just kill me then so people can actuall scum hunt

I noticed you are listing players you think are vt’s and you did not include sabi

is there any constructive reason why youd be advertising who you think is a vt?

Wait, can I know ask why isn't sabi pinging more people's scum vibes?

Will dig for context.

Sabi is in my scum-pool.

yeah sabi hasn't towned very hard at all imo