M73 - Fowl Play - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[bozotheclown]

I do think it's interesting independently that the first thing damo said was kak maybe being flipper

Not sure what to make of it really

Kakarroto's after deadline post was about the flipper, and it seems he did not have an accurate understanding of the role. Still, it could have been a fake town slip and he chose VT to throw us off because some of his teammates tried to save him.

[Jamiet99uk]

how much changes from our worldview if both kak and cel were scum and kak was the flipper as damo seems to think was the case.

are we looking at most of the scumteam actually on kak

A wild but interesting theory.

[Jamiet99uk]

if I die kill Jamie

If I die kill Billy Ray Cyrus.

[Jamiet99uk]

What made you go from not liking the assumption that celaph is scum to condemning him to death D2 in the course of a page?

Im resigned to the reality live in. I dont see anyone but celaph dying d2

A lot can happen in 48 hours

Also speaking of Jamiet, while I haven't seen any major red flags he has been awfully absent this game. Or at least it feels like it.

Excuse me, I was the third-highest poster during D1.

[BesharamSabi]

Im resigned to the reality live in. I dont see anyone but celaph dying d2

A lot can happen in 48 hours

Also speaking of Jamiet, while I haven't seen any major red flags he has been awfully absent this game. Or at least it feels like it.

Excuse me, I was the third-highest poster during D1.

According to the spreadsheet most of your posts were involving me so he probably didn't read them

[Jamiet99uk]

Good morning (local) peeps. Got a few questions for the audience.

@TFB: At an hour to go, kak was your second read, then at 15 minutes he was your third. What caused him to soften on him, but still vote for him?

@bozo: After an entire day of nothing but meta and shitposts, you went from voting FOR boat to voting WITH boat. Why?

@Maniac: Also from on to with boat, same question as above.

@snowy: You disappeared just before EoD on a vanity wagon then reappeared to wag your finger at the wagon, says you believed kaka to be a PR. If this is the case why did you not make any attempt yourself to react (as you chided everyone for) to the wagon and attempt to form a counter?

I do not accept the premise of your question, I voted for BusinessLamp as my preferred wagon 5 hours before EOD. When BusinessLamp was not a possibility in the last hour, I voted for TFB on snowy's recommendation. 43 seconds before EOD, with the vote tied, I voted for Kakarroto because I thought he was marginally more likely to be mafia than celaph. I did not consider TFB's vote when making that decision, since I did not know TFB's alignment.

Why did you decide to go with Snow's recommendation?

Do you still think BusinessLamp is scum?

[TheFlyingBoat]

Good morning (local) peeps. Got a few questions for the audience.

@TFB: At an hour to go, kak was your second read, then at 15 minutes he was your third. What caused him to soften on him, but still vote for him?

@bozo: After an entire day of nothing but meta and shitposts, you went from voting FOR boat to voting WITH boat. Why?

@Maniac: Also from on to with boat, same question as above.

@snowy: You disappeared just before EoD on a vanity wagon then reappeared to wag your finger at the wagon, says you believed kaka to be a PR. If this is the case why did you not make any attempt yourself to react (as you chided everyone for) to the wagon and attempt to form a counter?

It was mostly Chaqa skyrocketing up my list which I why followed out up with a vote on Chaqa

[BesharamSabi]

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

The fact that you put in this effort may not be Alignment Indicative at all.

What is the scum motivation to do this?

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

But what is the scum motivation to make something that can help town?

[snowy801]

What is the scum motivation to do this?

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

But what is the scum motivation to make something that can help town?

Is it helpful?

I am still uncertain what your spreadsheet is supposed to reveal

[TheFlyingBoat]

sabi is far more arrogant tonight than during day 1. the ability to converse in scumchat inevitably changes tone and cockiness

Yep you caught me brainbomb. I spent all this time making a spreadsheet to help town as a member of mafia.

Almost like my confidence came from accomplishing a project I wanted to do for a while now.

But nah it's because I am just making fun of how much of a simp eden is for spreadsheets in scum chat.

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

The fact that you put in this effort may not be Alignment Indicative at all.

I agree alone it is probably NAI and would be a good way to handle the perceived view of their game just being sandbagging to win if scum. At the same time given everything else they've done I've got a pretty strong town read on them

[bozotheclown]

Good morning (local) peeps. Got a few questions for the audience.

@TFB: At an hour to go, kak was your second read, then at 15 minutes he was your third. What caused him to soften on him, but still vote for him?

@bozo: After an entire day of nothing but meta and shitposts, you went from voting FOR boat to voting WITH boat. Why?

@Maniac: Also from on to with boat, same question as above.

@snowy: You disappeared just before EoD on a vanity wagon then reappeared to wag your finger at the wagon, says you believed kaka to be a PR. If this is the case why did you not make any attempt yourself to react (as you chided everyone for) to the wagon and attempt to form a counter?

I do not accept the premise of your question, I voted for BusinessLamp as my preferred wagon 5 hours before EOD. When BusinessLamp was not a possibility in the last hour, I voted for TFB on snowy's recommendation. 43 seconds before EOD, with the vote tied, I voted for Kakarroto because I thought he was marginally more likely to be mafia than celaph. I did not consider TFB's vote when making that decision, since I did not know TFB's alignment.

Why did you decide to go with Snow's recommendation?

Do you still think BusinessLamp is scum?

snowy has a good record on early reads (when town).

I still think BusinessLamp could be mafia, but I am far from certain.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Well, I feel like an human being again. Sorry for missing EOD and not voting. If GMs think I should be replaced I fully understand.

I read EOD and night posts Some things I got from them:

Chaqa is scum, that comment to Eden is all I need to know this.

Sabi is probably town, their tone looks angry town and not fake angry scum like the last time they was scum and I called for their kill.

I should be around more now, but it's still Carnaval here until tomorrow, so who knows....

Good catch up and analysis given how long you were gone. Have fun at Carnival and see you tomorrow!

[BesharamSabi]

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

But what is the scum motivation to make something that can help town?

Is it helpful?

I am still uncertain what your spreadsheet is supposed to reveal

It visually shows who is and isn't interacting with who. It's a supplement to check with people's reads and also voting. Should be more helpful once we catch scum.

So far Bona, boatman, and Eden are fans of it so shrug emoji.

[BesharamSabi]

Anyway I do need to focus at work
I don't want to be fired a month into this new job because of mafia.

Bye

[TheFlyingBoat]

just to see if I can keep the streak going I think my towncore rn would by pyxxy, brain, Jamie, bona? In that order

Jamie and bona congratulations on your returnee spots to the council

What have brain and pyxxy done to get on there? Like I have a slight town read on both but I don't think either has done anything to get town cored.

[BusinessLamp]

Good morning (local) peeps. Got a few questions for the audience.

@TFB: At an hour to go, kak was your second read, then at 15 minutes he was your third. What caused him to soften on him, but still vote for him?

@bozo: After an entire day of nothing but meta and shitposts, you went from voting FOR boat to voting WITH boat. Why?

@Maniac: Also from on to with boat, same question as above.

@snowy: You disappeared just before EoD on a vanity wagon then reappeared to wag your finger at the wagon, says you believed kaka to be a PR. If this is the case why did you not make any attempt yourself to react (as you chided everyone for) to the wagon and attempt to form a counter?

I do not accept the premise of your question, I voted for BusinessLamp as my preferred wagon 5 hours before EOD. When BusinessLamp was not a possibility in the last hour, I voted for TFB on snowy's recommendation. 43 seconds before EOD, with the vote tied, I voted for Kakarroto because I thought he was marginally more likely to be mafia than celaph. I did not consider TFB's vote when making that decision, since I did not know TFB's alignment.

I still don’t get how out of all 40 or whatever pages the thing most relevant to your suspicions was the fact that I /might have/ faked not knowing the game started.

[Chaqa]

I could see TFB and Maniac, but I’m pretty sure Snowy is town.
Idk about bozo

I dont townread any of those people other than snowy

Why are people townreading Snowy?

Annoying asshole snowy = town snowy

[Jamiet99uk]

What is the scum motivation to do this?

You may simply be the kind of person who finds it satisfying to set yourself a task and complete it.

But what is the scum motivation to make something that can help town?

Maybe it is primarily helping you to appear to be helping town.

As scum I often look for town-seeming efforty things I can do which don't require me to lie.

[Jamiet99uk]

I could see TFB and Maniac, but I’m pretty sure Snowy is town.
Idk about bozo

I dont townread any of those people other than snowy

Why are people townreading Snowy?

Annoying asshole snowy = town snowy

Oh so you think he's always town every game then?

[TheFlyingBoat]

there are plenty of level headed folks who pushed both cel and kak who can easily just be collectively wrong on both instances - and this includes myself. I reread celaph and found a number of posts that dont raise any alarms at all

Probably a decent point, but I think Celaph's inactivity and meh posting when he does post does lend itself to being probable scum!celaph. I'll give him a re-read after work (probably only going to be able to begin around 11pm PST due to a late night meeting with the India team) but idk for now I still lean scum.