M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Kakarroto]

what about the false role block claim near the beginning? Did ghug ever do that as a member of mafia? (I mean he 'retracted' the retraction later but that was kind of a joke to emphasize his opinion in my eyes and at the time it seems everyone read it as the same as me)

[worcej]

what about the false role block claim near the beginning? Did ghug ever do that as a member of mafia? (I mean he 'retracted' the retraction later but that was kind of a joke to emphasize his opinion in my eyes and at the time it seems everyone read it as the same as me)

ghug has made weird false claims and retracted them back as a player.

To me, making that false claim at the time wouldn't have moved my needle if I was in this game because of that.

[ghug]

I await Ghug's response with interest.

What am I supposed to respond to? I'm scum because it's possible? Sure, it's possible, but I'm not.

[ghug]

If ghug is mafia, would he do such a hail mary tunnel on me though? He pretty much just had locked me in, save for the moment to get on damo. It's pretty annoying I give you that, but that feels pretty towny to do.

If ghug is scum, he wants the final 3 to be Bob, myself, and him.

MK'ing you or Jamie right now accomplishes that goal.

If you believe the last scum wants you around because you're bad at reading people, maybe you should consider that your reads are wrong.

[ghug]

what about the false role block claim near the beginning? Did ghug ever do that as a member of mafia? (I mean he 'retracted' the retraction later but that was kind of a joke to emphasize his opinion in my eyes and at the time it seems everyone read it as the same as me)

ghug has made weird false claims and retracted them back as a player.

To me, making that false claim at the time wouldn't have moved my needle if I was in this game because of that.

I actually do so these things almost exclusively as town, but that probably won't be true at some point, so I can't fault this logic.

[ghug]

I dislike the "i await ghug's response" from Jamie a lot. Seems like an attempt to fan the flames on something that doesn't really have substance.

[worcej]

If ghug is mafia, would he do such a hail mary tunnel on me though? He pretty much just had locked me in, save for the moment to get on damo. It's pretty annoying I give you that, but that feels pretty towny to do.

If ghug is scum, he wants the final 3 to be Bob, myself, and him.

MK'ing you or Jamie right now accomplishes that goal.

If you believe the last scum wants you around because you're bad at reading people, maybe you should consider that your reads are wrong.

I didn't say that it was my reads for why scum want me in the final three...

[worcej]

I dislike the "i await ghug's response" from Jamie a lot. Seems like an attempt to fan the flames on something that doesn't really have substance.

He does these type of posts all the time.

What makes you not like them now?

[ghug]

If ghug is scum, he wants the final 3 to be Bob, myself, and him.

MK'ing you or Jamie right now accomplishes that goal.

If you believe the last scum wants you around because you're bad at reading people, maybe you should consider that your reads are wrong.

I didn't say that it was my reads for why scum want me in the final three...

Seems like a good reason though, doesn't it?

[ghug]

I dislike the "i await ghug's response" from Jamie a lot. Seems like an attempt to fan the flames on something that doesn't really have substance.

He does these type of posts all the time.

What makes you not like them now?

Well, a) I'm not exactly Jamie's biggest fan this game, and b) this is more empty than most. There's literally nothing for me to respond to in that post, and he knows that.

[worcej]

If you believe the last scum wants you around because you're bad at reading people, maybe you should consider that your reads are wrong.

I didn't say that it was my reads for why scum want me in the final three...

Seems like a good reason though, doesn't it?

It seems possible, but probably not your reason why.

[worcej]

Well, a) I'm not exactly Jamie's biggest fan

FTFY

[ghug]

I didn't say that it was my reads for why scum want me in the final three...

Seems like a good reason though, doesn't it?

It seems possible, but probably not your reason why.

I'm not scum, though. I'd probably want to kill Bob at that KILO though, which is not the narrative you seem to be implying.

[worcej]

All the trolling aside, you've (ghug) done nothing noteworthy for me to consider you lock!town. All of the other players have shown some scum motivation with healthy doses of town motivated posts and reasonings.

Maybe I suck at reading players, but you're just... here... and that's enough for me to believe you're the last scum.

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 9.02

Kakarroto (1) ghug
BobMcBob (1) Kakarroto
Jamiet99uk (1) BobMcBob
ghug (1) worcej
Unvote (1) Jamiet99uk

EOD is in 1 hour

Queen Victoria’s husband, Prince Albert, wasn’t the first to introduce Christmas trees to Britain from his native Germany—Queen Charlotte did that in the late 1700s. But, Victoria and Albert are credited with popularizing the custom in the mid-1800s.

[ghug]

All the trolling aside, you've (ghug) done nothing noteworthy for me to consider you lock!town. All of the other players have shown some scum motivation with healthy doses of town motivated posts and reasonings.

Maybe I suck at reading players, but you're just... here... and that's enough for me to believe you're the last scum.

And I can't fault that step of the logic (though I can and will fault the belief that I've done nothing noteworthy to consider townie, and I don't know what Kak and Jamie have done to convince you of their towniness.

[ghug]

)

[worcej]

All the trolling aside, you've (ghug) done nothing noteworthy for me to consider you lock!town. All of the other players have shown some scum motivation with healthy doses of town motivated posts and reasonings.

Maybe I suck at reading players, but you're just... here... and that's enough for me to believe you're the last scum.

And I can't fault that step of the logic (though I can and will fault the belief that I've done nothing noteworthy to consider townie, and I don't know what Kak and Jamie have done to convince you of their towniness.

TL;DR versions:

• Jamie's tunnels for stupid reasons are his major flag of being town. If he's scum, he was responsible/notably involved with bussing 3/4 of his teammates. While I think that's entirely possible, Jamie did not need to bus celaph like he did, which is what really screwed the pooch on Durga ultimately.
• Donny's lack of wanting to cause a tie and not valuing his life when he was almost killed screamed town to me. His posts and reasonings were semi-consistent with someone trying to figure it out. Kak has come in and been trying to ask questions and get reads on people's intent motivation. It's like 75% Donny that I town more than Kak's recent behaviors.

[worcej]

Leaving work and have a few errands to run, will try to not miss EOD but honestly I'm pretty set on my vote staying on ghug at this point so if I miss it I have no 'ragrets'.

[BobMcBob]

All the trolling aside, you've (ghug) done nothing noteworthy for me to consider you lock!town. All of the other players have shown some scum motivation with healthy doses of town motivated posts and reasonings.

Maybe I suck at reading players, but you're just... here... and that's enough for me to believe you're the last scum.

And I can't fault that step of the logic (though I can and will fault the belief that I've done nothing noteworthy to consider townie, and I don't know what Kak and Jamie have done to convince you of their towniness.

TL;DR versions:

• Jamie's tunnels for stupid reasons are his major flag of being town. If he's scum, he was responsible/notably involved with bussing 3/4 of his teammates. While I think that's entirely possible, Jamie did not need to bus celaph like he did, which is what really screwed the pooch on Durga ultimately.
• Donny's lack of wanting to cause a tie and not valuing his life when he was almost killed screamed town to me. His posts and reasonings were semi-consistent with someone trying to figure it out. Kak has come in and been trying to ask questions and get reads on people's intent motivation. It's like 75% Donny that I town more than Kak's recent behaviors.

Is it possible worcej and Jamie are scum together? Because none of those are indicators Jamie is town. And his read mysteriously flipped from when he came into the game.