M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[BobMcBob]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

To the extent that you could call my increasing frustration at voting this game outrage, real.

[damo666]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

[BobMcBob]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

Ah yes, I do love scumreading people on flip reactions. It is always an accurate metric.

[damo666]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

Ah yes, I do love scumreading people on flip reactions. It is always an accurate metric.

It's actually a good one. I pointed durga's out soon after she posted

[worcej]

@Maniac: Who are your top scumreads, and why?

Damo - see previous reason

Goldie - scum not killing me or goldie suggests they are confident we aren’t close to finding g-f so goldie could be our man

Respect the dead.

You’re only saying that because it’s someone who also was tunneling the same slot as you.

[worcej]

I said at the beginning of the turn that I thought Damo and Bob were the most likely. I said that at the beginning of the turn and reaffirmed it at the end when I announced my willingness to switch back to Damo if people didn't like either of the major wagons. No one obliged.

Going to call you out on this being pretty bad because if you wanted Damo, you shouldn’t have ever left his wagon.

You were the first one to move off Damo when he was the lead wagon and then it crumbled apart as you shifted to Donny, which gave others enough momentum to move there.

And meanwhile my voting is purposeless and low effort for not leaving the wagon I want. Makes sense.

I mean, we’re not at Milo or Kilo yet, but if you’re town you need to stop just parking your vote on non-wagons and then not making EOD.

You’re running out of time to die on stupid hills.

AND ONCE AGAIN: point me to what post or phase where you made a case against goldie.

[worcej]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

It comes off as misplaced rage.

If he was actually here at EOD and on a meaningful wagon, then I would give it more credit. But parking your vote on me (when I had no votes) and then peacing out was bad enough for me to think his rage is mostly fake, especially when he set the stage up to be outraged with his vote post.

[worcej]

Okay - so he has an inno (presuming blue is inno) on me and an inno on Maniac. His likely GF claim is an opinion, which I won’t ignore, but it wouldn’t make me want to get Maniac now over damo (assuming no one wants you).

I don't like the fact that he said "presuming blue is inno". Of course blue is inno, you know what your role is. Unless blue means scum in which case you would know.

Oh wait I like this post.

Worcej would indeed obviously know what scan result he gives.

@Worcej: Discuss.

I’m not versed in the mechanics of the game to know if a cop gives anything other than innocent or guilty.

Goldie’s slot is VT, so innocent.

[worcej]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

To the extent that you could call my increasing frustration at voting this game outrage, real.

You have no right to be outraged when you don’t contribute enough anything to the phase.

[worcej]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

Ah yes, I do love scumreading people on flip reactions. It is always an accurate metric.

Scum can use the flip and foster fake outrage at the result to appear town.

[damo666]

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

Ah yes, I do love scumreading people on flip reactions. It is always an accurate metric.

Scum can use the flip and foster fake outrage at the result to appear town.

Precisely. Faux outrage => scum

[Jamiet99uk]

I think I covered this at least once already, but if you're scummy and there's a godfather I don't care what you scanned as.

Maniac was scummy and was scanned.

I agree with one of those things.

You think Maniac's theories about word use and other linguistic details were helpful to town?

[Jamiet99uk]

I don't like the fact that he said "presuming blue is inno". Of course blue is inno, you know what your role is. Unless blue means scum in which case you would know.

Oh wait I like this post.

Worcej would indeed obviously know what scan result he gives.

@Worcej: Discuss.

I’m not versed in the mechanics of the game to know if a cop gives anything other than innocent or guilty.

Goldie’s slot is VT, so innocent.

Fake ignorance?

You are aware there is a Godfather in this relatively vanilla game.

You know that the Godfather causes a false result. You know this because you have played in 20+ games and GMed multiple times, and because the Godfather is a standard role.

You should know that it has been speculated that one of DemonRHK's two inno results was due to scanning the Godfather.

[ghug]

Give me three reasons. I'll accept only one reason if it's not Vecna's D4 vote or the copscan result.

I don't have a third.

Why is this still being discussed after Maniac has been flipped?

They're talking about the Goldie/worcej slot.

[ghug]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

Feels pretty real to me.

[ghug]

As fayk as durga's flip reaction

Ah yes, I do love scumreading people on flip reactions. It is always an accurate metric.

It's actually a good one. I pointed durga's out soon after she posted

Yeah, it's a great tell for Durga.

[ghug]

I can't tell whether Bob is outraged, or fake-outraged.

Anyone?

It comes off as misplaced rage.

If he was actually here at EOD and on a meaningful wagon, then I would give it more credit. But parking your vote on me (when I had no votes) and then peacing out was bad enough for me to think his rage is mostly fake, especially when he set the stage up to be outraged with his vote post.

He's been pissed that we won't kill you/gold for days, and Maniac was probably the towniest person left alive.

[ghug]

Maniac was scummy and was scanned.

I agree with one of those things.

You think Maniac's theories about word use and other linguistic details were helpful to town?

Scummy/helpful for town is a false dichotomy

See: most of your town games

[ghug]

Oh wait I like this post.

Worcej would indeed obviously know what scan result he gives.

@Worcej: Discuss.

I’m not versed in the mechanics of the game to know if a cop gives anything other than innocent or guilty.

Goldie’s slot is VT, so innocent.

Fake ignorance?

You are aware there is a Godfather in this relatively vanilla game.

You know that the Godfather causes a false result. You know this because you have played in 20+ games and GMed multiple times, and because the Godfather is a standard role.

You should know that it has been speculated that one of DemonRHK's two inno results was due to scanning the Godfather.

Nothing he said contradicts this.

[Jamiet99uk]

I agree with one of those things.

You think Maniac's theories about word use and other linguistic details were helpful to town?

Scummy/helpful for town is a false dichotomy

See: most of your town games

It is scummy not to try to help town. I will fucking die on that hill.

If you think otherwise, explain the point of playing, as town, if not to try to help town?

Where did Maniac do townie things that were likely to help find scum and contribute to a town win?