M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

It’s almost like I can have opinions that don’t rely on me casting my vote to justify them!

A vote on Donny just to make my vote match up with my Sus doesn’t mean shit

[BobMcBob]

Okay time to make fun of TFB/overexplain my voting patterns.

I think my day 1 vote reasoning was pretty darn obvious. I very much townread flum, and I didn't like the reasoning for the rdr wagon. TFB had been scummier than either of them so I tried joining the flashwagon in the hopes that we might actually flip scum.

Day 2 was admittedly strange. I preferred the celaph wagon to TFB for quite a long time, but I was never particularly convinced that he was scum, as stated in my earlier post most of my scumreading him came from other reads on him that I trusted. But TFB kept digging himself into a hole and making himself look worse and more petty, and I was swayed somewhat by kgray and blamp's noise. Then TFB voted celaph and for some reason that just didn't sit right with me and put me off the wagon. I can't remember exactly why, it was probably more vibes and mindset at the time, and not so much logical reasoning, but when I said TFB's vote made me not want to vote celaph, that's basically what happened. I tried to move to celaph at EoD for tie prevention after seeing how the votes moved, but got in too late.

Day 3 I was pretty convinced Durga was scum but I also very much scumread HR so I didn't have any problem with voting him. My main reason for staying there was to try and make the day slightly less of a stale, infoless runaway wagon scenario than it was looking to be, which obviously failed miserably and we lost a ton of momentum anyway. I moved to Durga because my vote didn't matter at that point and I just felt like being there.

Day 4 I scumread goldie heavily, far more so than Vecna, but I moved to Vecna for consolidation to make sure there was no tie after seeing how the votes were falling.

Also I got the impression that the "strong contingent" of people refusing to vote me was literally just Bona who had no other ideas in the game and also blamp. If there was anyone else, they weren't really speaking out about it to my memory. Also "rock solid 5" is heavily misinterpreting how voting works.

[BobMcBob]

It’s almost like I can have opinions that don’t rely on me casting my vote to justify them!

A vote on Donny just to make my vote match up with my Sus doesn’t mean shit

I guess I shouldn't expect you to build a case or a push on anyone ever, I'm sorry.

[Chaqa]

It’s almost like I can have opinions that don’t rely on me casting my vote to justify them!

A vote on Donny just to make my vote match up with my Sus doesn’t mean shit

I guess I shouldn't expect you to build a case or a push on anyone ever, I'm sorry.

lmao fuck off, I’ve made tons of cases and I have explained my thought process several times, not my problem if you don’t read them

[Jamiet99uk]

It’s almost like I can have opinions that don’t rely on me casting my vote to justify them!

A vote on Donny just to make my vote match up with my Sus doesn’t mean shit

I guess I shouldn't expect you to build a case or a push on anyone ever, I'm sorry.

lmao fuck off, I’ve made tons of cases and I have explained my thought process several times, not my problem if you don’t read them

Up until the middle of Day 5 you townread Donny. What changed?

[Chaqa]

I guess I shouldn't expect you to build a case or a push on anyone ever, I'm sorry.

lmao fuck off, I’ve made tons of cases and I have explained my thought process several times, not my problem if you don’t read them

Up until the middle of Day 5 you townread Donny. What changed?

I don’t have the strongest pure scum suspicion on Donny. While I think he’s the most likely to be scum of anyone left, I’m mostly just struggling to find scumreads right now.

What absolutely cannot happen is Donny getting to endgame, because his lack of participation and as far as I can tell lack of attention to the game will be devastating he makes it to final 5 or final 3.

[Jamiet99uk]

lmao fuck off, I’ve made tons of cases and I have explained my thought process several times, not my problem if you don’t read them

Up until the middle of Day 5 you townread Donny. What changed?

I don’t have the strongest pure scum suspicion on Donny. While I think he’s the most likely to be scum of anyone left, I’m mostly just struggling to find scumreads right now.

What absolutely cannot happen is Donny getting to endgame, because his lack of participation and as far as I can tell lack of attention to the game will be devastating he makes it to final 5 or final 3.

Ack, that's a fair point.

I strongly think we should flip HR, and probably Maniac. But you're right that if Donny remains alive until EoG that presents a problem.

He's not a great information kill. He's not a scumread of mine. But...

[rdrivera2005]

Up until the middle of Day 5 you townread Donny. What changed?

I don’t have the strongest pure scum suspicion on Donny. While I think he’s the most likely to be scum of anyone left, I’m mostly just struggling to find scumreads right now.

What absolutely cannot happen is Donny getting to endgame, because his lack of participation and as far as I can tell lack of attention to the game will be devastating he makes it to final 5 or final 3.

Ack, that's a fair point.

I strongly think we should flip HR, and probably Maniac. But you're right that if Donny remains alive until EoG that presents a problem.

He's not a great information kill. He's not a scumread of mine. But...

This argument have some weight but scum tryng to get a Donny wagon D1 and Donny voting for Celaph last minute on D2 points for him being town.

I am still not convinced it's Bob too, even considering TFB have some valid points on his wall and that we can't townclear Bob. I think scum wouldn't waste a RB on N1, so Chaqa is still on the town side even if I didn't agree with almost anything he posts. TFB is also on the town side.

So, I am still around Ghug, HR and Jamiet and even Damo at this point (considering we ruled out Gold and Maniac, as Gold is my top scumread).

##vote Ghug

[damo666]

My preferred voting order is HR Maniac ghug Bob. So happy with the top 3 wagons at the moment. There is at least 1 scum in there probably both.

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 6.01

GOOOOOD MORNING

ghug (2) goldfinger0303 rdrivera2005
BobMcBob (2) TheFlyingBoat Chaqa
Hellenic Riot (2) damo666 Jamiet99uk
Jamiet99uk (1) ghug

Non-votes: BobMcBob, Donny Dude, Hellenic Riot, Maniac

NO ONE IS SET TO ONLY PLAY DIPLOMACY ON PLAYDIP FOR THE REST OF ETERNITY

EOD is in 34.5 hours

The Eisenhower interstate system requires that one mile in every five must be straight. These straight sections are usable as airstrips in times of war or other emergencies.

[damo666]

I don’t have the strongest pure scum suspicion on Donny. While I think he’s the most likely to be scum of anyone left, I’m mostly just struggling to find scumreads right now.

What absolutely cannot happen is Donny getting to endgame, because his lack of participation and as far as I can tell lack of attention to the game will be devastating he makes it to final 5 or final 3.

Ack, that's a fair point.

I strongly think we should flip HR, and probably Maniac. But you're right that if Donny remains alive until EoG that presents a problem.

He's not a great information kill. He's not a scumread of mine. But...

This argument have some weight but scum tryng to get a Donny wagon D1 and Donny voting for Celaph last minute on D2 points for him being town.

I am still not convinced it's Bob too, even considering TFB have some valid points on his wall and that we can't townclear Bob. I think scum wouldn't waste a RB on N1, so Chaqa is still on the town side even if I didn't agree with almost anything he posts. TFB is also on the town side.

So, I am still around Ghug, HR and Jamiet and even Damo at this point (considering we ruled out Gold and Maniac, as Gold is my top scumread).

##vote Ghug

Donny's participation needs to step up but imo he is in the same class as Jamie and rdr, 98% town. Well Donny and Jamie 98%, rdr 97% but that's nitpicking.

[BobMcBob]

NO ONE IS SET TO ONLY PLAY DIPLOMACY ON PLAYDIP FOR THE REST OF ETERNITY

Maybe we should just no-kill today. Nobody deserves that kind of suffering.

[Chaqa]

Current town to scum:

ghug
Jamiet99uk
TheFlyingBoat
Maniac/goldfinger0303 - Above line for inno scan reasons, but also kinda townread them both now
------------------------- line of willingness to vote
BobMcBob
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
damo666
Donny Dude

Those bottom five are all pretty close to each other. I would prefer to vote one of them out today.

[Jamiet99uk]

Current town to scum:

ghug
Jamiet99uk
TheFlyingBoat
Maniac/goldfinger0303 - Above line for inno scan reasons, but also kinda townread them both now
------------------------- line of willingness to vote
BobMcBob
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
damo666
Donny Dude

Those bottom five are all pretty close to each other. I would prefer to vote one of them out today.

Yes, let's vote Hellenic Riot.

[Chaqa]

I don't know. The interactions I had with HR made me think he was town. Voting him would more due to PoE than a pure scumread - that's how most of this goes for me.

If not Donny today, I would rather vote out Damo or Rivera than HR.

Bob is also an option, but he falls more into the "probably shouldn't let him get to the endgame" camp than the "this player oozes scum" camp.

[ghug]

I have been trying, but with little success.

She'd moved on to Jamie. Kill him instead.

This is a scummy post.

Why?

[damo666]

She'd moved on to Jamie. Kill him instead.

This is a scummy post.

Why?

Why do you want to kill Jamie?

[ghug]

This is a scummy post.

Why?

Why do you want to kill Jamie?

He's established that he likes to bus aggressively, his emotional responses aren't what I expect from him, and I townread most others.

[Chaqa]

Why?

Why do you want to kill Jamie?

He's established that he likes to bus aggressively, his emotional responses aren't what I expect from him, and I townread most others.

Do you have some games where Jamie bussed? I remember him getting pissy with me for bussing our teammate once

[ghug]

Why do you want to kill Jamie?

He's established that he likes to bus aggressively, his emotional responses aren't what I expect from him, and I townread most others.

Do you have some games where Jamie bussed? I remember him getting pissy with me for bussing our teammate once

The game where you went 11 v 1. The game where brainbomb and Brian tried to save me after the whole team bussed me all day and we were all caught early, which seems to be the common outcome.