M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

Why do they slaughter my boy like that

Can we kill TFB yet

[BobMcBob]

Can we kill goldie yet?

[goldfinger0303]

Sucks about bona, but given that just about everyone almost turned into a wagon yesterday, the NK should be revealing and we'll have a better shot tomorrow. I think most of us have a different idea of who our towncores are.

[goldfinger0303]

Starting tomorrow I should hopefully have a great deal more time to dedicate to re-reads and hypothesis

[TheFlyingBoat]

why is rivera so scummy to you?

So in addition to what was discussed through D2, I didn't like his D3 at all, like even for rdr that's a pretty high level of ghosting the thread, and I don't like his response to pressure from ghug was immediately voting him in response in D5.

Was there even a good case for him through D2? He was super busy for a bit and OMGUS is peak Rivera

I don't think there's a real case here. His posts near EOD today didn't matter to you?

His posts near EOD today? No? I don't see anything that he wouldn't say as either scum or town. What do you think think I'm missing in that EOD that seemed so townie to you?

[Chaqa]

TFB needs to go.

[TheFlyingBoat]

TFB needs to go.

Have you finally found out what useful info you'd get from it or do you scum read me?

[TheFlyingBoat]

Because to date despite me asking you like 5 times I still have yet to get answer from you other than you making vague hand wavey generalities about how it would add more info to look at D2/3 wagons without any real explanation of which reads change.

[Chaqa]

TFB needs to go.

Have you finally found out what useful info you'd get from it or do you scum read me?

Option 1: You're the Godfather and the useful info will be clearing Gold and Maniac.

Option 2: You're the Goon and we can flip Gold and Maniac to find the Godfather

Option 3: You're town and we didn't kill someone who's been actively solving and not just chiming in when their name is mentioned

[Chaqa]

Because to date despite me asking you like 5 times I still have yet to get answer from you other than you making vague hand wavey generalities about how it would add more info to look at D2/3 wagons without any real explanation of which reads change.

We already had this talk like a few days ago, no?

I determined Vecna's alignment was linked to yours and Vecna was scum

[TheFlyingBoat]

TFB needs to go.

Have you finally found out what useful info you'd get from it or do you scum read me?

Option 1: You're the Godfather and the useful info will be clearing Gold and Maniac.

Option 2: You're the Goon and we can flip Gold and Maniac to find the Godfather

Option 3: You're town and we didn't kill someone who's been actively solving and not just chiming in when their name is mentioned

Yeah except I was chanting for Durga, Celaph, and Vecna to go early while your most memorable contributions were defending a guy who has contributed literally zero to this game and calling for an info kill on me that has yet to make sense. All three of your options could apply better to you, to Bob, to donny, and to rdr

[TheFlyingBoat]

Because to date despite me asking you like 5 times I still have yet to get answer from you other than you making vague hand wavey generalities about how it would add more info to look at D2/3 wagons without any real explanation of which reads change.

We already had this talk like a few days ago, no?

I determined Vecna's alignment was linked to yours and Vecna was scum

Wait so you think I have been hard bussing the role blocker since D1?

[Chaqa]

Have you finally found out what useful info you'd get from it or do you scum read me?

Option 1: You're the Godfather and the useful info will be clearing Gold and Maniac.

Option 2: You're the Goon and we can flip Gold and Maniac to find the Godfather

Option 3: You're town and we didn't kill someone who's been actively solving and not just chiming in when their name is mentioned

Yeah except I was chanting for Durga, Celaph, and Vecna to go early while your most memorable contributions were defending a guy who has contributed literally zero to this game and calling for an info kill on me that has yet to make sense. All three of your options could apply better to you, to Bob, to donny, and to rdr

I defend my townreads. Bona was town - it was a bad kill.

If you're town, I'll admit it was a bad kill, but I don't get town vibes from you, and your entire town lean in my head has been because you were celaph's counterwagon. Clearly Day 2 is not as clear-cut as I thought, unless someone like Kgray is scum.

If you're town, give us some original thoughts into the game state at some point. Do some hunting. Don't just ctrl+F your name and meme around.

Say what you will about Bona - he had different views on things and wasn't just coasting.

[Chaqa]

Because to date despite me asking you like 5 times I still have yet to get answer from you other than you making vague hand wavey generalities about how it would add more info to look at D2/3 wagons without any real explanation of which reads change.

We already had this talk like a few days ago, no?

I determined Vecna's alignment was linked to yours and Vecna was scum

Wait so you think I have been hard bussing the role blocker since D1?

It's one possibility. Clearly the last two scum are well-hidden.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Option 1: You're the Godfather and the useful info will be clearing Gold and Maniac.

Option 2: You're the Goon and we can flip Gold and Maniac to find the Godfather

Option 3: You're town and we didn't kill someone who's been actively solving and not just chiming in when their name is mentioned

Yeah except I was chanting for Durga, Celaph, and Vecna to go early while your most memorable contributions were defending a guy who has contributed literally zero to this game and calling for an info kill on me that has yet to make sense. All three of your options could apply better to you, to Bob, to donny, and to rdr

I defend my townreads. Bona was town - it was a bad kill.

If you're town, I'll admit it was a bad kill, but I don't get town vibes from you, and your entire town lean in my head has been because you were celaph's counterwagon. Clearly Day 2 is not as clear-cut as I thought, unless someone like Kgray is scum.

If you're town, give us some original thoughts into the game state at some point. Do some hunting. Don't just ctrl+F your name and meme around.

Say what you will about Bona - he had different views on things and wasn't just coasting.

I absolutely haven't been coasting. I've been giving original thoughts and analysis others haven't provided this entire game, it's not my problem if you can't or don't read them. I've hunted well and I've called this canard out for it is this entire game. Yes I was wrong on Flum, yes I was wrong on Bona, but I stand by that both were good shots and justifiable ones at the time.

[TheFlyingBoat]

Like either you have to make the argument I've bussed nearly my entire team or I've been pretty good on the hunt.

[kgray]

We already had this talk like a few days ago, no?

I determined Vecna's alignment was linked to yours and Vecna was scum

Wait so you think I have been hard bussing the role blocker since D1?

It's one possibility. Clearly the last two scum are well-hidden.

What does this even mean? How can you know they're "well-hidden"?

[Chaqa]

Hmmm yeah this is about how a town should defend there I think.

Okay. So it isn't you.

It isn't me, probably isn't kgray, ghug, or Jamie.

Gold and Maniac are out.

Bob, Damo, Donny, HR, Rivera.

I feel Bob, HR, and Rivera have to be town.

So damo and Donny are the two I'm left with.

What do you think about those last five (Bob, Damo, Donny, HR, Rivera.)?

[kgray]

I'm about to throw all the towncred Chaqa gets for being RB'd out the window.

[Chaqa]

Wait so you think I have been hard bussing the role blocker since D1?

It's one possibility. Clearly the last two scum are well-hidden.

What does this even mean? How can you know they're "well-hidden"?

Well, who are the two "obvious" scum?