M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

Well done kgray for working out the puzzle*.

I think the last 2 scum are Bona and HR.

##VOTE BONA

Fingers crossed Bona is the dk and flips GF.

If GF not flipped by D9 then we got to seriously consider G and M if they remain alive.

However I had Vecna and Gold as unlikely pair so Maniac more likely of the 2.

* No town points for kgray for solving though considering scum killed demon. Just puts a tiny '?' next to kgray.

In what world does kgray solving the puzzle add a question mark?

Scum killed demonRHK implying they may have sussed him as cop, kgray explained demonRHK's clues so maybe kgray solved it as scum? Bit elaborate because of the RBs but she's not an absolute clear.

[Jamiet99uk]

Six pages later, P.156, and EoD is coming. Suddenly Bona totally changes his tune:

"Celaph wagon is trash and everyone on it should feel trash"

A total U-turn since he was calling Celaph scum just a few pages earlier, and had done so several times.

people asked me and i gave a reason for this at the time

I'm here trying to write up last minute thoughts. tl;dr kgray blamp very towny. I like the support from Bona, but not sure why he went form calling me scum bussing TFB to calling my wagon trash.

your wagon is trash cause it's not boat man

It was a trash reason.

You were behaving as if you suddenly thought there was only one scum, or that the object of the game was "Kill TFB at all costs = instawin".

[kgray]

Well done kgray for working out the puzzle*.

I think the last 2 scum are Bona and HR.

##VOTE BONA

Fingers crossed Bona is the dk and flips GF.

If GF not flipped by D9 then we got to seriously consider G and M if they remain alive.

However I had Vecna and Gold as unlikely pair so Maniac more likely of the 2.

* No town points for kgray for solving though considering scum killed demon. Just puts a tiny '?' next to kgray.

Working out the puzzle does not put a ? next to my name, wtf

[kgray]

Well done kgray for working out the puzzle*.

I think the last 2 scum are Bona and HR.

##VOTE BONA

Fingers crossed Bona is the dk and flips GF.

If GF not flipped by D9 then we got to seriously consider G and M if they remain alive.

However I had Vecna and Gold as unlikely pair so Maniac more likely of the 2.

* No town points for kgray for solving though considering scum killed demon. Just puts a tiny '?' next to kgray.

In what world does kgray solving the puzzle add a question mark?

Oh, thank you bona

[kgray]

Well done kgray for working out the puzzle*.

I think the last 2 scum are Bona and HR.

##VOTE BONA

Fingers crossed Bona is the dk and flips GF.

If GF not flipped by D9 then we got to seriously consider G and M if they remain alive.

However I had Vecna and Gold as unlikely pair so Maniac more likely of the 2.

* No town points for kgray for solving though considering scum killed demon. Just puts a tiny '?' next to kgray.

In what world does kgray solving the puzzle add a question mark?

Scum killed demonRHK implying they may have sussed him as cop, kgray explained demonRHK's clues so maybe kgray solved it as scum? Bit elaborate because of the RBs but she's not an absolute clear.

I literally solved it after he flipped lmao. Jamie and I had a whole convo about it.

I am basically clear, it just has nothing to do with solving demons hints, and solving demon’s hints doesn’t make me any less clear.

[kgray]

Okay I’m playing lots of diplomacy today but I’ll be back to reread some people later. Like pretty much everybody else, I don’t think gold or maniac should be flipped. I’m okay with Rivera, I’m not sure about HR, and I still am not convinced bona is scummy.

[Jamiet99uk]

Okay I’m playing lots of diplomacy today but I’ll be back to reread some people later. Like pretty much everybody else, I don’t think gold or maniac should be flipped. I’m okay with Rivera, I’m not sure about HR, and I still am not convinced bona is scummy.

You have one scumread.

Ok.

[kgray]

Oh and actually I don’t mind a ghug wagon for now. ##vote ghug

Yes yes I’m here with Rivera. Not ideal.

[kgray]

Okay I’m playing lots of diplomacy today but I’ll be back to reread some people later. Like pretty much everybody else, I don’t think gold or maniac should be flipped. I’m okay with Rivera, I’m not sure about HR, and I still am not convinced bona is scummy.

You have one scumread.

Ok.

Nah I just don’t feel that strongly about anyone being scum at the moment. And there’s only 2 scum left anyway so maybe you don’t have to be so critical all the time?

[damo666]

In what world does kgray solving the puzzle add a question mark?

Scum killed demonRHK implying they may have sussed him as cop, kgray explained demonRHK's clues so maybe kgray solved it as scum? Bit elaborate because of the RBs but she's not an absolute clear.

I literally solved it after he flipped lmao. Jamie and I had a whole convo about it.

I am basically clear, it just has nothing to do with solving demons hints, and solving demon’s hints doesn’t make me any less clear.

Yes you 'appeared' to solve it post flip but you may have solved it previously. I don't think you are scum but it cannot be ruled out. You are not 'basically clear'. You are quasi-clear due to un cc'd R claims (but that could be a set up) and appearing to solve demon's puzzle does not make you any more clear.

Anyway I put you at about 95% town which is a lot more than most do fret not.

[damo666]

Oh and actually I don’t mind a ghug wagon for now. ##vote ghug

Yes yes I’m here with Rivera. Not ideal.

I don't think ghug is a good flip yet. I think we need to settle Bona and HR first.

[damo666]

This is my Scum to Town ranking

Bona
HR
rdr
gold/Maniac*
ghug
Donny
TFB
Bob
Chaqa
kgray
Jamie

*obviously one or both are clear upon GF flip

[Chaqa]

I would vote rivera

[damo666]

I would vote rivera

Better there than on me anyway!

[Chaqa]

I could also be convinced to vote TFB

Anyway I’m out til later, more car shopping

Happy hunting

[rdrivera2005]

I would vote rivera

Why? This kind of thing is really scummy. You just signal you could vote someone that other people already show interest and wait to see if the wagon depart, so you don't have to do the dirty job to set a misskill.

By the way, TFB voting me on the basis of a EOD2 read is also lazy as fuck as if we didn't catch 3 scum after that.

[Chaqa]

I would vote rivera

Why? This kind of thing is really scummy. You just signal you could vote someone that other people already show interest and wait to see if the wagon depart, so you don't have to do the dirty job to set a misskill.

By the way, TFB voting me on the basis of a EOD2 read is also lazy as fuck as if we didn't catch 3 scum after that.

I just don’t know who to vote. I’m obviously wrong about one of my townreads. Maybe it’s Bona. Or ghug or Jamie. Or HR. Or you.

Damo seems like the obvious kill but I don’t know

[Jamiet99uk]

I would vote rivera

Why? This kind of thing is really scummy. You just signal you could vote someone that other people already show interest and wait to see if the wagon depart, so you don't have to do the dirty job to set a misskill.

By the way, TFB voting me on the basis of a EOD2 read is also lazy as fuck as if we didn't catch 3 scum after that.

I just don’t know who to vote. I’m obviously wrong about one of my townreads. Maybe it’s Bona. Or ghug or Jamie. Or HR. Or you.

Damo seems like the obvious kill but I don’t know

Why does it seem to you as if Damo is obviously scum?

How is Damo connected to Celaph, Durga, and/or Vecna?

During D2 you described Damo as someone you had "mild town vibes" about.

Since then we've flipped 3 scum, of course - but what is it about those flips that now makes Damo one of your strongest scumreads? Or, is it something else?

[Chaqa]

Why? This kind of thing is really scummy. You just signal you could vote someone that other people already show interest and wait to see if the wagon depart, so you don't have to do the dirty job to set a misskill.

By the way, TFB voting me on the basis of a EOD2 read is also lazy as fuck as if we didn't catch 3 scum after that.

I just don’t know who to vote. I’m obviously wrong about one of my townreads. Maybe it’s Bona. Or ghug or Jamie. Or HR. Or you.

Damo seems like the obvious kill but I don’t know

Why does it seem to you as if Damo is obviously scum?

How is Damo connected to Celaph, Durga, and/or Vecna?

During D2 you described Damo as someone you had "mild town vibes" about.

Since then we've flipped 3 scum, of course - but what is it about those flips that now makes Damo one of your strongest scumreads? Or, is it something else?

I don’t really scumread anyone at this point.

Damo didn’t vote for celaph, which isn’t really damning given neither did Vecna.

Tbh I think maniac or gold is The Godfather and we only have a goon to catch so it’s gonna be tough, or both scum remaining are deep covered

[Jamiet99uk]

I don’t really scumread anyone at this point.

Damo didn’t vote for celaph, which isn’t really damning given neither did Vecna.

Tbh I think maniac or gold is The Godfather and we only have a goon to catch so it’s gonna be tough, or both scum remaining are deep covered

These are not the words of someone who sincerely thinks it is "obvious" that we must kill Damo.

Yet obvious was the word that you used.