M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

Maniac had an odd claim, but that really only matters if he wakes up. A look will need to be taken at the reactions to the claim if he does, vecna really tried to leverage it to his advantage. Not sure if it will amount to anything, but meh. I think the pool should be sufficiently small enough to hunt the last goon from here. A focus needs to be made on some of the early day one interactions i think. Can't see the links being more obvious than prior to being able to talk things over.

I think the last goon resides in bona, rdr, ghug, damo. Not seeing kgray sheeping me with a conserted defense attempt being mounted. Not seeing jamie as anything but locktown after the fox stiff. Overall, gold, kgray, and jamie are the towncore.

Like i had said before, my scumhunting is ass. I am usually good for one. Kgray and jamie get most of the credit for vecna. Even though i didn't read most of what vecna said yesterday at all, i kept the tunnel in hard. Little did i know i was on the right track lol. Ya gotta love dumb luck.

Gonna hope to see you all on the other side. Focus up, read carefully, look for clues.

keep calm, carry on, Respect the dead. i'll miss you guys.

MANIAC INNO LIKELY GF is the capital letters

GET TUBED BONA

[Jamiet99uk]

Well except it's "MANIAC INNO LIKELY GF R", but yes.

Respect the dead.

##Vote Maniac

[ghug]

Do we not just yeet Maniac out?

No? He was obviously trying to draw a nightkill?

[kgray]

Do we not just yeet Maniac out?

*how* do you not know better than this. even i know better than this.

I'm an occam's razor guy. Fake claimers must die.

see: jasnah in the game i was cop

see also: the priest game where we had two vts claim priest and they kept you from finding ghug for forever.

i don't see why maniac claims there if he's the gf when he had so little pressure and vecna was a clear contender to go home instead. i know demon just said respect the dead... but idk i'm not convinced this makes maniac scum

[Jamiet99uk]

Gold scan blue?

meaning innocent i assume?

It's reasonable to assume this because DemonRHK said "Gold ain't it" in his first D4 post, and didn't vote for Goldfinger at all during that day.

[Chaqa]

I think Kgray's got the idea though.

So we can keep Maniac and gold out of the running for a bit, I think?

[Jamiet99uk]

Do we not just yeet Maniac out?

No? He was obviously trying to draw a nightkill?

The dead Cop just left us a message advising us to kill Maniac, however.

[kgray]

Gold scan blue?

meaning innocent i assume?

It's reasonable to assume this because DemonRHK said "Gold ain't it" in his first D4 post, and didn't vote for Goldfinger at all during that day.

yes, i also thought it was reasonable to assume this, and that's why i assumed it

but yeah, also good points

[kgray]

Do we not just yeet Maniac out?

No? He was obviously trying to draw a nightkill?

The dead Cop just left us a message advising us to kill Maniac, however.

that just means he got an inno, doesn't mean he knows anything more about whether or not he's the godfather than we do

[goldfinger0303]

Fuckin rip Demon. You did good with your crumbs. And nice try with Maniac trying to bait that NK.

I would say we table Maniac for the time being. I know Chaqa loves his Occam's Razor, but I view his fake claim as townie....but Demon says he's likely GF....respect the dead and all.

So I'll go with a Maniac kill today if you wish, but let's at least explore other options.

Also, get wrecked HR.

##Vote HR.

I'm gonna be in the pool of HR, bona, damo and Maniac today.

[Bonatogether]

It's the first letters of his sentences in his EON posts.

N2: DURGA IS GUILTY

N3: GOLD SCAN BLUE

N4: MANIAC INNO LIKELY GF

checks out

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok so let's think.

Goldfinger and Maniac both scanned "innocent" for DemonRHK, while Durga of course scanned "guilty". That's what we know from the scans (thanks, DemonRHK, good job).

Either Goldfinger or Maniac could in fact be the Godfather. DemonRHK thought that Maniac probably was.

They were both already in the scum pool.

I think it's reasonable to wagon them because if one of them is the Godfather, then the other one is towncleared.

[Bonatogether]

Maniac had an odd claim, but that really only matters if he wakes up. A look will need to be taken at the reactions to the claim if he does, vecna really tried to leverage it to his advantage. Not sure if it will amount to anything, but meh. I think the pool should be sufficiently small enough to hunt the last goon from here. A focus needs to be made on some of the early day one interactions i think. Can't see the links being more obvious than prior to being able to talk things over.

I think the last goon resides in bona, rdr, ghug, damo. Not seeing kgray sheeping me with a conserted defense attempt being mounted. Not seeing jamie as anything but locktown after the fox stiff. Overall, gold, kgray, and jamie are the towncore.

Like i had said before, my scumhunting is ass. I am usually good for one. Kgray and jamie get most of the credit for vecna. Even though i didn't read most of what vecna said yesterday at all, i kept the tunnel in hard. Little did i know i was on the right track lol. Ya gotta love dumb luck.

Gonna hope to see you all on the other side. Focus up, read carefully, look for clues.

keep calm, carry on, Respect the dead. i'll miss you guys.

MANIAC INNO LIKELY GF is the capital letters

GET TUBED BONA

hmm this message from k gary is very cryptic

[Bonatogether]

Fuckin rip Demon. You did good with your crumbs. And nice try with Maniac trying to bait that NK.

I would say we table Maniac for the time being. I know Chaqa loves his Occam's Razor, but I view his fake claim as townie....but Demon says he's likely GF....respect the dead and all.

So I'll go with a Maniac kill today if you wish, but let's at least explore other options.

Also, get wrecked HR.

##Vote HR.

I'm gonna be in the pool of HR, bona, damo and Maniac today.

I think Vecna's actions last EoD make this a terrible vote for now

[Jamiet99uk]

MANIAC INNO LIKELY GF is the capital letters

GET TUBED BONA

hmm this message from k gary is very cryptic

Well, I've just worked out that if you put all of the capital letters in Kgray's post together, it spells:

"Get Tubed Bona"

[Bonatogether]

GET TUBED BONA

hmm this message from k gary is very cryptic

Well, I've just worked out that if you put all of the capital letters in Kgray's post together, it spells:

"Get Tubed Bona"

strange

i wonder what it means

[Chaqa]

Ok so let's think.

Goldfinger and Maniac both scanned "innocent" for DemonRHK, while Durga of course scanned "guilty". That's what we know from the scans (thanks, DemonRHK, good job).

Either Goldfinger or Maniac could in fact be the Godfather. DemonRHK thought that Maniac probably was.

They were both already in the scum pool.

I think it's reasonable to wagon them because if one of them is the Godfather, then the other one is towncleared.

We should wagon scum candidates that aren't them. If we flip a Godfather they're clears

[ghug]

Do we not just yeet Maniac out?

No? He was obviously trying to draw a nightkill?

The dead Cop just left us a message advising us to kill Maniac, however.

I have the same information he did and disagree with his conclusion.. He also said he's bad at scumhunting.

( RHK you done good)

[goldfinger0303]

Ok so let's think.

Goldfinger and Maniac both scanned "innocent" for DemonRHK, while Durga of course scanned "guilty". That's what we know from the scans (thanks, DemonRHK, good job).

Either Goldfinger or Maniac could in fact be the Godfather. DemonRHK thought that Maniac probably was.

They were both already in the scum pool.

I think it's reasonable to wagon them because if one of them is the Godfather, then the other one is towncleared.

We should wagon scum candidates that aren't them. If we flip a Godfather they're clears

This is the correct answer for now.

[ghug]

Ok so let's think.

Goldfinger and Maniac both scanned "innocent" for DemonRHK, while Durga of course scanned "guilty". That's what we know from the scans (thanks, DemonRHK, good job).

Either Goldfinger or Maniac could in fact be the Godfather. DemonRHK thought that Maniac probably was.

They were both already in the scum pool.

I think it's reasonable to wagon them because if one of them is the Godfather, then the other one is towncleared.

##VOTE Jamie