M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[goldfinger0303]

I view both you and Jamiet as pretty town, so all that does is solidify my case, Boat

[goldfinger0303]

*solidify my read

[Bonatogether]

If Maniac is telling the truth:

Seems like he potentially inno'd Kgray D2 (cant really find anything else)
Seems like he potentially inno'd Ghug, or less likely me D3 (But still, dont fucking kill me numpties)
N3 he states he didnt get a guilty yet, but that HR is the implicated person by D3 voting or w/e. Then he starts D4 voting HR right of the gate for "afore mentioned reasons" - potentially referring to a guilty?

##vote HR

what's going through Vecna's brain here? He tries to shade HR and claim an inno scan

At this point in time it's 4 HR, 4 Vecna, with vecna's vote pushing it up to 5-4 at T-0:25. Does scum!vecna try to accelerate scum!hr's wagon at that time? I'm guessing no, cause that's just non-optimal. Scum want to get a town miskill here.

HR can't be gf, I'm pretty sure, cause there's an implied guilty scan, according to Vecna. We know Vecna isn't gf, so this eliminates any weird PR nonsense for the movement (ie, goon!vecna isn't taking the shot for gf!hr here)

I believe this just clears HR.

[Bonatogether]

not particularly fond of my vote neither, but with the maniac shit and it being the only real CW to me atm....

vecna still think he can make it through at this point, because he's encouraging the HR wagon on the basis that it's the only possible counterwagon, implying that this is clearly town!vecna and not clearly town!hr, so better to take the kinda bad shot than the really bad one. sets up vecna for saying 'rip, didn't want it, but better than me' if hr flipped town

[Bonatogether]

You should probably not flip the person that possibly couldve been inno'd D3

(even though its not as likely as Ghug, this is just dumb)

Again trying to claim the copscan (assuming he means EoN2 scan, cause he claimed the n3 scan was a guilty on hr)

[Bonatogether]

This is annoying. I've got some mild reasons to townread just about everyone except Maniac at this point.

scum chaqa makes this post

reposting cause true

[Bonatogether]

Also, the fact that TFB literally only came back to drop a giant wall of text to defend himself from me and leave again is some guak-tier irritation at this point.

yeah boat man has a pattern

we have more immediate pressing things but this needs to be resolved sooner or later

[Bonatogether]

##Vote Vecna

this ties it at 5-5, giving Vecna a crucial boost

I think scum only does this if they think vecna is just already gone or HR is about to be dogpiled, which doesn't make sense for the thread dynamics when this was posted.

heavily town this post

[Chaqa]

##Vote Vecna

this ties it at 5-5, giving Vecna a crucial boost

I think scum only does this if they think vecna is just already gone or HR is about to be dogpiled, which doesn't make sense for the thread dynamics when this was posted.

heavily town this post

So am I town or scum?

[Bonatogether]

This has to be one of the worst scum performances in a long time.

The extreme reticence to vote Goldie makes me pretty convinced he's the GF, so this should be a hilariously short game.

The fact that it's this bad should lead you to the opposite conclusion, HR. My scum performances have usually been pretty good. The fact that I was counter-wagon to Vecna and Vecna voted me (there's only one scum other than GF alive) should pretty much clear me. Cop, scan me tonight to prove I'm not the goon. There's no reason the roleblocker would try to push the vote on the GF.

That all being said, good job to everyone except me. I'm easily LVT - least valuable townie here. Frankly surprised Durga would go that far protecting Fox off the bat, tbh.

Terrible defense by goldie here

[Bonatogether]

##Vote Vecna

this ties it at 5-5, giving Vecna a crucial boost

I think scum only does this if they think vecna is just already gone or HR is about to be dogpiled, which doesn't make sense for the thread dynamics when this was posted.

heavily town this post

So am I town or scum?

schrodinger's mafia player

as long as you don't flip him, he can be whatever you want him to be, and use it to justify every read

[Bonatogether]

I'll make you into a junior version of me yet, Bob

please

bob is a good person

don't do this to him

[Bonatogether]

I've been fucking nails this entire game and I've gotten for it is flak from Bona who accuses me of not reading when he's been among the useless players in the game (kudos to him for ending on someone other than me for the first time all game) and HR and one or two others who accuse me of only showing up when pinged when it's just not true [/endrant]

small nitpick cause i'm right

I said you weren't reading my posts beyond the first sentence or so, because you clearly weren't

[Bonatogether]

hi bob!

[DemonRHK]

Vecna's votes really don't give us shit. He barely voted, likely knowing he was badly exposed coming in.

Or couldn't be assed, one of the two.

[TheFlyingBoat]

I've been fucking nails this entire game and I've gotten for it is flak from Bona who accuses me of not reading when he's been among the useless players in the game (kudos to him for ending on someone other than me for the first time all game) and HR and one or two others who accuse me of only showing up when pinged when it's just not true [/endrant]

small nitpick cause i'm right

I said you weren't reading my posts beyond the first sentence or so, because you clearly weren't

I one hundred percent was. Your posts have just sucked, especially your tunnels, but really just about everything.

You were on the wrong side of D2 and instead of celebrating the scum death and reconsidering, you doubled down.

You couldn't seem to comprehend why we thought Durga was scum on D3 and decided to dumb-tunnel again. Instead of celebrating and reconsidering here, you double down.

In D4, you start off dumb-tunneling again, never mention vecna until you cast a vote for him with 2 mins left. In fact you only actually give something resembling a view on him when you ask if he even posted during N3. Other than that you somehow went the entire game without directly saying anything relevant about him. The closest you come other than that is asking Blamp if he liked anything about Vecna after his Vecna iso. So it's not like you read well there either, you just followed us onto a good wagon to prevent a tie.

I also like that you're trying to pretend you made posts that were significantly longer than one sentence this game, especially pre-EoN2 when we had our major arguments

Honestly I'm starting to believe your town, because no scum could possibly play like this.

[ghug]

My only wonder is what the false positive rate is for pinging mafia on the no contraction thing

I am fairly confident I could find an example for everyone still alive in this game, sadly. The Durga one didn't even make sense.

Does this post count? I did one but left another uncontacted.

[TheFlyingBoat]

My only wonder is what the false positive rate is for pinging mafia on the no contraction thing

I am fairly confident I could find an example for everyone still alive in this game, sadly. The Durga one didn't even make sense.

Does this post count? I did one but left another uncontacted.

I note that you intentionally left that part of the post without contact...but why did you leave it uncontracted

[TheFlyingBoat]

also you're* sorry for the typo. I've made a lot of typos in posts dealing with him. I'll blame the anger.

[ghug]

not particularly fond of my vote neither, but with the maniac shit and it being the only real CW to me atm....

vecna still think he can make it through at this point, because he's encouraging the HR wagon on the basis that it's the only possible counterwagon, implying that this is clearly town!vecna and not clearly town!hr, so better to take the kinda bad shot than the really bad one. sets up vecna for saying 'rip, didn't want it, but better than me' if hr flipped town

Like these posts, sadly.