M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Vecna]

We can discuss any number of hypotheticals, but im pretty sure I wouldve been a much better candidate to bus if I was scum, regardless of role.

But she did bus Celaph, because we know they were both scum, and Durga voted for her during the mid-part of the day, both D1 and D2, and she was very reluctant to move from Celaph, to you.

Just remember it for next game and rub it in her face when she claims she doesnt bus.

[Vecna]

Are there any other theories of who she couldve been protecting? Because it wasnt me.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Unend

Keeping my vote on Vecna but this pressure is making him engage and that's good. I'll re-evaluate in the morning if he has posted more. It could be Maniac instead of him, you see.

[Jamiet99uk]

Are there any other theories of who she couldve been protecting? Because it wasnt me.

The other option at the time appeared to be McBob.

[kgray]

Vecna can you look at eod1 and tell me if you think rivera and HR are scumbuddies? Thanks.

[Vecna]

pretty sure its not Maniac either. Anyways, im off to bed.

From the limited shit ive seen this game (and this is mostly gut, so please dont ask for in-depth explenations), id look at TFB, Damo, Bona and RHK. I felt Ghug before as well, but I dont think he's be actually trying to get me to escape rope here with this elaborate white knighting shit as scum.

[Vecna]

Vecna can you look at eod1 and tell me if you think rivera and HR are scumbuddies? Thanks.

I can sort of see why you'd think that based on the many interactions that they had (if memory serves they dont normally interact this much, but my meta hasnt been too sharp this game apparently).

However, that last post HR makes with 1 minute to go about flum seems like a pretty genuine observation that feels very unlikely to come from scum.

The few things ive seen from Rdrivera also have felt pretty inline with his townplay?

[rdrivera2005]

Also you should not be this lazy. You think one of me or HR is scum... pick one then. It should be obvious and frankly the fact that you're making that me/him statement is ridiculous.

I am tired, had a pretty bad day and I am feeling guilty about you, so I don't want to pick this fight. Call me lazy.

And why my statement is ridiculous? I am stating I don't think both of you are scum having a similar vote pattern around Celaph, but I also find hard to believe you are both misguided town that jumped out of Celaph wagon by coincidence. But I can't be sure and there is at least another two scum, so why it's ridiculous I am voting another scumread?

So you think that Foxna is scum. You think that one of kgray/Me is scum. Who else do you scumread? Indeed, aside from dead people - Who do you townread?

I townread Bob, Jamiet, TFB, Damo, Demon and Maniac.
I lean town on Ghug and Chaqa but they aren't a solid townread.
So, my scumpool other then the one's I alrrady listed are Gold, Bona and Donny in this order.

[Chaqa]

Yeah Vecna is town

##vote HR

[Chaqa]

Maybe it’s just HR-gold-Damo

[Chaqa]

Durga doesn't give a shit about PRs.

Doesn’t this fit regardless since Durga didn’t ever vote for celaph?

[Chaqa]

Durga doesn't give a shit about PRs.

Doesn’t this fit regardless since Durga didn’t ever vote for celaph?

* at the end of day 2

[kgray]

Durga doesn't give a shit about PRs.

Doesn’t this fit regardless since Durga didn’t ever vote for celaph?

What does this mean? And she did vote for celaph.

[kgray]

Durga doesn't give a shit about PRs.

Doesn’t this fit regardless since Durga didn’t ever vote for celaph?

What does this mean? And she did vote for celaph.

Okay ignore the second part, but I still don't get the connection to PRs.

[Chaqa]

Doesn’t this fit regardless since Durga didn’t ever vote for celaph?

What does this mean? And she did vote for celaph.

Okay ignore the second part, but I still don't get the connection to PRs.

Ghug is saying Durga doesn’t give a shit about mafia PRs so she wouldn’t bus a goon to protect one, but since she didn’t vote for celaph, it doesn’t necessarily mean anything if she didn’t care about mafia PRs

[ghug]

What does this mean? And she did vote for celaph.

Okay ignore the second part, but I still don't get the connection to PRs.

Ghug is saying Durga doesn’t give a shit about mafia PRs so she wouldn’t bus a goon to protect one, but since she didn’t vote for celaph, it doesn’t necessarily mean anything if she didn’t care about mafia PRs

But she did vote for celaph?

[Chaqa]

Okay ignore the second part, but I still don't get the connection to PRs.

Ghug is saying Durga doesn’t give a shit about mafia PRs so she wouldn’t bus a goon to protect one, but since she didn’t vote for celaph, it doesn’t necessarily mean anything if she didn’t care about mafia PRs

But she did vote for celaph?

Not at EoD

[goldfinger0303]

I always want to vote people because it's funny.

##vote ghug

##vote gold

Gotcha

That's not fair, you know I'm a sucker for early day meme votes.

##Vote HR

[Jamiet99uk]

Ghug is saying Durga doesn’t give a shit about mafia PRs so she wouldn’t bus a goon to protect one, but since she didn’t vote for celaph, it doesn’t necessarily mean anything if she didn’t care about mafia PRs

But she did vote for celaph?

Not at EoD

No not at EoD, but both times that Durga did vote for Celaph, this put Celaph into the lead. So Durga was still willing to put Celaph in harm's way.

[BobMcBob]

Righto, I've been putting this off for a while, but I am actually gonna start my VCA and stuff now. Should be done in 5 hours or less.