M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[goldfinger0303]

Well, now we don't have to deal with people scumreading him anymore.

##VOTE gold

Say it ain't so, ghug.

##Vote HR

[Maniac]

Rip business lamp. Hope you enjoyed the game and will play again.

##vote HR for reasons I’ve already stated and also In honour of our dearly departed Blamp

[goldfinger0303]

Can I start a conversation here on a somewhat controversial topic?

Should cop come out now and say the results of their scans, if they've hit any scum that are not currently a main wagon?

Like, if you've scanned HR or Vecna and got a scum result, keep quiet. But if you scanned like, Jamiet or Chaqa, for example, and got a scum result you should definitely claim now. The trade is worth it.

[Bonatogether]

Can I start a conversation here on a somewhat controversial topic?

Should cop come out now and say the results of their scans, if they've hit any scum that are not currently a main wagon?

Like, if you've scanned HR or Vecna and got a scum result, keep quiet. But if you scanned like, Jamiet or Chaqa, for example, and got a scum result you should definitely claim now. The trade is worth it.

the cop will know what to do when the time comes

[rdrivera2005]

who would kill blamp

1
Anyone that is reading the game and saw how obvtown Lamp was.

RIP Lamp and hope you play again.

I think one of HR/Kgray is scum just don't know which one. Vecna/Fox isn't a bad wagon too.

##vote Vecna

Also you should not be this lazy. You think one of me or HR is scum... pick one then. It should be obvious and frankly the fact that you're making that me/him statement is ridiculous.

I am tired, had a pretty bad day and I am feeling guilty about you, so I don't want to pick this fight. Call me lazy.

And why my statement is ridiculous? I am stating I don't think both of you are scum having a similar vote pattern around Celaph, but I also find hard to believe you are both misguided town that jumped out of Celaph wagon by coincidence. But I can't be sure and there is at least another two scum, so why it's ridiculous I am voting another scumread?

[goldfinger0303]

Can I start a conversation here on a somewhat controversial topic?

Should cop come out now and say the results of their scans, if they've hit any scum that are not currently a main wagon?

Like, if you've scanned HR or Vecna and got a scum result, keep quiet. But if you scanned like, Jamiet or Chaqa, for example, and got a scum result you should definitely claim now. The trade is worth it.

the cop will know what to do when the time comes

Alright, alright. I'm no good at reading people, apparently, so I like to talk mechanics... But I suppose that's all a bit out of place in this setup

[Bonatogether]

Can I start a conversation here on a somewhat controversial topic?

Should cop come out now and say the results of their scans, if they've hit any scum that are not currently a main wagon?

Like, if you've scanned HR or Vecna and got a scum result, keep quiet. But if you scanned like, Jamiet or Chaqa, for example, and got a scum result you should definitely claim now. The trade is worth it.

the cop will know what to do when the time comes

Alright, alright. I'm no good at reading people, apparently, so I like to talk mechanics... But I suppose that's all a bit out of place in this setup

yeah. just let em be and don't pressure him

[ghug]

Can I start a conversation here on a somewhat controversial topic?

Should cop come out now and say the results of their scans, if they've hit any scum that are not currently a main wagon?

Like, if you've scanned HR or Vecna and got a scum result, keep quiet. But if you scanned like, Jamiet or Chaqa, for example, and got a scum result you should definitely claim now. The trade is worth it.

the cop will know what to do when the time comes

This cannot be said with confidence.

There's no benefit to a cop claiming now before EoN in any case.

[kgray]

1
Anyone that is reading the game and saw how obvtown Lamp was.

RIP Lamp and hope you play again.

I think one of HR/Kgray is scum just don't know which one. Vecna/Fox isn't a bad wagon too.

##vote Vecna

Also you should not be this lazy. You think one of me or HR is scum... pick one then. It should be obvious and frankly the fact that you're making that me/him statement is ridiculous.

I am tired, had a pretty bad day and I am feeling guilty about you, so I don't want to pick this fight. Call me lazy.

And why my statement is ridiculous? I am stating I don't think both of you are scum having a similar vote pattern around Celaph, but I also find hard to believe you are both misguided town that jumped out of Celaph wagon by coincidence. But I can't be sure and there is at least another two scum, so why it's ridiculous I am voting another scumread?

Because it's not like we have played the same game so there are enough differences that you should be able to at least guess at which is scum if you think it's one or the other. And besides, if you believe HR, he didn't jump off of celaph by coincidence - he did it because I told him to

[Vecna]

##vote maniac

ill see if i can do some meaningfull shit this day, and whether its needed

[damo666]

##vote Bona for reasons set out previously.

Am willing to switch to any of HR Vecna gold Maniac if Bona wagon does not attract support.

[damo666]

Anybody roleblocked?

[Chaqa]

I would assume someone was

[damo666]

I would assume someone was

I assume from that comment you weren't.

[damo666]

There are 2 players who were on neither celaph nor durga, namely

BONA and MANIAC

Fits in nicely with my Bona Gold Maniac theory.

[Chaqa]

I would assume someone was

I assume from that comment you weren't.

I was not

[Chaqa]

There are 2 players who were on neither celaph nor durga, namely

BONA and MANIAC

Fits in nicely with my Bona Gold Maniac theory.

Seems too simple

[damo666]

There are 2 players who were on neither celaph nor durga, namely

BONA and MANIAC

Fits in nicely with my Bona Gold Maniac theory.

Seems too simple

Maybe so but both being town being off both scum wagons seems improbable to me so I would say at least 1 is scum and if it is only one my money would be on Bona.

[Chaqa]

I thought about the game state some more last night and this morning, and I'm second-guessing my scum!HR read a bit. Not completely, but enough I'm willing to look elsewhere today.

I'm going to channel Bozo and put a survey of sorts out there.

Does anyone else feel we should flip TFB at some point so that we understand Day 2 better? If so, I imagine we would want to make that choice today, so that we aren't potentially missing something for the next 3-4 day phases.

Bona wants to vote TFB regardless, but what about everyone else?

[rdrivera2005]

I thought about the game state some more last night and this morning, and I'm second-guessing my scum!HR read a bit. Not completely, but enough I'm willing to look elsewhere today.

I'm going to channel Bozo and put a survey of sorts out there.

Does anyone else feel we should flip TFB at some point so that we understand Day 2 better? If so, I imagine we would want to make that choice today, so that we aren't potentially missing something for the next 3-4 day phases.

Bona wants to vote TFB regardless, but what about everyone else?

We already lost a lot of momentum last day with Durga being a runaway wagon. If we go for a policy TFB lynch today we lose another day and I don't think it's a good choice. If you scumread him like Bona, fine, but voting for info today doesn't seem a good choice.