M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

No one in this community is good at reading him. The more people saying he’s scum, the more likely he isn’t.

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

You did not. Stop trying to take credit for my scumhunting.

[kgray]

(And pls just forget how I also tried to lead the charge off celaph)

[TheFlyingBoat]

No one in this community is good at reading him. The more people saying he’s scum, the more likely he isn’t.

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

You did what now?

[Hellenic Riot]

No one in this community is good at reading him. The more people saying he’s scum, the more likely he isn’t.

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

I think you'll find I led the charge on celaph, even if I decided to hedge later on.

[Bonatogether]

HR Vecna and Bona hanging out in scumchat?

this post was 4:26 am for me

[TheFlyingBoat]

Also if that's your argument, Chaqa, in what world am I that low on your list given I've been on Durga since D1 and celaph since N1?

[Bonatogether]

I think we should flip Bona first but I doubt that will be the most popular view.

yeah you've been saying this

[kgray]

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

I think you'll find I led the charge on celaph, even if I decided to hedge later on.

How is it you 'led the charge' on celaph but I backed out of my Durga scumread?

[Chaqa]

(And pls just forget how I also tried to lead the charge off celaph)

I was literally about to post this haha

To me "lead the charge" doesn't necessarily mean getting everyone on the same page, more that I was onto them early.

[Bonatogether]

No one in this community is good at reading him. The more people saying he’s scum, the more likely he isn’t.

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

true enough

idk, but i'm just not feeling it from you in this circumstance

[Bonatogether]

i will make a wallpost for you nerds

[Chaqa]

Also if that's your argument, Chaqa, in what world am I that low on your list given I've been on Durga since D1 and celaph since N1?

I don't really think you're scum. If you looked at my town to scum list, you were near the top, but IF you are scum and Day 2 was about mafia bussing celaph to save you, it is the most critical piece of information we wouldn't have otherwise.

[Chaqa]

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

true enough

idk, but i'm just not feeling it from you in this circumstance

Reminds me of when you didn't trust me that time when [insert any mafia game or any Among Us game here]

[Chaqa]

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

I think you'll find I led the charge on celaph, even if I decided to hedge later on.

Ghug and I brought that wagon back from irrelevance just when you moved your vote toward TFB, immediately after Durga did the same. You see how bad that looks, and now to claim credit for the celaph wagon, right?

[TheFlyingBoat]

Also if that's your argument, Chaqa, in what world am I that low on your list given I've been on Durga since D1 and celaph since N1?

I don't really think you're scum. If you looked at my town to scum list, you were near the top, but IF you are scum and Day 2 was about mafia bussing celaph to save you, it is the most critical piece of information we wouldn't have otherwise.

I was below bona and that's all I actually remember. Don't recall my absolute position

[goldfinger0303]

alright town council what’s on tonight’s agenda

still catching up, think goldie, blamp are good shots

I was gonna joke post the GM note announcing my death to a vig shot, but I'm not sure if impersonating that is allowed.

[BusinessLamp]

I was the vote that put Celaph in the lead.
I had Durga high on my list of scum N2.

Yet still I get all these put-downs implying I am stupid.

Maybe you just don't like it, but I'm not bad at this game.

jamie is town

he's not town for that post

not the arguments behind it but the sentiment

[ghug]

Yeah Chaqa, since we have nothing else to do, care to elaborate on that a bit? I'm scumreading bona as well

He gets scumread and voted out for these exact same "reasons" almost every game.

M71: http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msg?g=7 ... &var=death

M69: http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msg?g=6 ... &var=death

M66: http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msg?g=6 ... &var=death

M1016: http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msg?g=1 ... &var=death

M63: http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msg?g=6 ... &var=death

I'd have to go back and find people's arguments for voting him, but I know of the ones I was in, it's like a gaggle of parrots giving the exact same reasons to vote Bona every time, and it's never right.

I wasn't in his scum game, so I can't speak to that, but nothing I'm seeing from Bona this game is at all any different from the above games or the ones where he lived or was nightkilled as town.

Bona is like me. Either people can't read him or don't understand his logic and therefore think it's scummy.

Nah, I understand Bona's logic.

How would he be playing differently if he were scum?

[ghug]

No one in this community is good at reading him. The more people saying he’s scum, the more likely he isn’t.

feel like i'm being pocketed here

I'm relatively sure whenever I'm scum I push to kill you because you suspect me regardless of my alignment.

I led the charge on celaph and Durga, why would I be scum here

It's amazing how many of us think we led the charge on Durga and celaph.

[kgray]

I was gonna reread stuff this evening but now I have no motivation. If I am blessed with death, my final thoughts are that Rivera is the scum of the earth and if HR is mafia then I think Rivera is mafia also. And I'm coming around on HR being mafia so maybe y'all can just get the two of them.