M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

Considering kgray's RB claim my conclusions look wrong.

So one of my supposed townclears must be wrong. I guess rdr is the most logical, voting celaph at the last minute once the game was up?

Or of course TFB might be scumPR.

My head hurts.

Why did you townread rdr so strongly to begin with?

Looking back I can't see why. Gut I suppose.

[Jamiet99uk]

Damo, I think it's time for your medicine.

[Chaqa]

I never claimed to have an innocent scan on Bona.

Who is Bofa then?

Bofa deez nuts

GOTeem

[kgray]

All this “VCA” assuming scum only ever save their teammates is so frustrating and experienced players should know better by now. How many times has believing that lead to town losses? Why people think it’s more likely that scum make a sincere push on a teammate as a bus and then abandon it when they could capitalize on the towncred is beyond me. Throwing in a last-minute vote for a teammate for towncred is infinitely more likely.

Do better Damo

OK if you are town which of my assumptions are wrong.

I take your point about you and HR being an unlikely pairing.

The most likely thing I have wrong is only 1 busser (or the wrong busser). If there were 2 bussers (let's assume Vecna plus unknown) why not switch to TFB to tie? It must be somebody townreading TFB. This would be ghug, Jamie or rdr. But these are all strong townreads.

Conclusion: something is wrong.

Yeah I mean I think I should go back and see if any of the late celaph voters joined that wagon out of nowhere. People townreading TFB could've easily just voted for celaph because they actually townread TFB.

I think Donny looks the best of those late celaph voters, by the way, since he's been scumreading celaph since D1. I remember that he shied away from bussing as scum previously, and he questioned Durga feeling "better" about celaph D1. I find that unlikely to come from scum on D1 especially if Durga is also scum as I suspect. Plus he said he was feeling better about celaph when he was more active D1 but didn't take that opportunity to take his vote off celaph.... Feels like normal townie thought progression and second-guessing to me. And D2 there was a lot of him trying to figure out what was going on with the celaph wagon and my vote specifically. Just a lot of interactions revolving around celaph and I feel he'd have been more distant if they were scumbuddies.

[kgray]

Vecna is my best guess.

Will you vote for Vecna?

I would but Durga is my strongest scumread so I'm staying there for now.

[kgray]

I must admit I'm not comfortable with my Blamp vote.

##vote Vecna

what made you change your mind?

[damo666]

I must admit I'm not comfortable with my Blamp vote.

##vote Vecna

what made you change your mind?

Concluding that my assumptions must be wrong somewhere.

[TheFlyingBoat]

I must admit I'm not comfortable with my Blamp vote.

##vote Vecna

what made you change your mind?

Concluding that my assumptions must be wrong somewhere.

which assumptions do you think is most likely wrong

[damo666]

what made you change your mind?

Concluding that my assumptions must be wrong somewhere.

which assumptions do you think is most likely wrong

At least one of my assumed towns must be wrong, rdr being my immediate guess.

[damo666]

Just wanted to share with the class, I'm the cop and i have an innocent on Bofa

Exactly what did you mean by this Chaqa?

[Chaqa]

Just wanted to share with the class, I'm the cop and i have an innocent on Bofa

Exactly what did you mean by this Chaqa?

See my last post

[TheFlyingBoat]

Concluding that my assumptions must be wrong somewhere.

which assumptions do you think is most likely wrong

At least one of my assumed towns must be wrong, rdr being my immediate guess.

If rdr is wrong what do you think the scum pool looks like given the second order effects of that being true in your analysis?

[ghug]

@kargy what happens to your reads if boat is scum?

[damo666]

Just wanted to share with the class, I'm the cop and i have an innocent on Bofa

Exactly what did you mean by this Chaqa?

See my last post

I don't understand.

[ghug]

Exactly what did you mean by this Chaqa?

See my last post

I don't understand.

He wanted someone to ask who Bofa is so that he could say "bofa deez nuts", which sounds like "both of these nuts".

[Jamiet99uk]

I am willing to believe that both of Chaqa's nuts are innocent, and have never sinned.

[ghug]

I am willing to believe that both of Chaqa's nuts are innocent, and have never sinned.

I don't think he needs to be a cop to answer this question, though I also find your conclusion dubious.

[damo666]

which assumptions do you think is most likely wrong

At least one of my assumed towns must be wrong, rdr being my immediate guess.

If rdr is wrong what do you think the scum pool looks like given the second order effects of that being true in your analysis?

What?

[damo666]

See my last post

I don't understand.

He wanted someone to ask who Bofa is so that he could say "bofa deez nuts", which sounds like "both of these nuts".

Well, absolutely hilarious. Very helpful.

[Chaqa]

Sorry Damo, it's a pretty common Millenial/Zoomer joke lol