M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

I don't think Goldie is scum anyway

[Hellenic Riot]

I don't think Goldie is scum anyway

Would you like to qualify that with some reasoning? It will provide a nice distraction while he's busy choking

[Chaqa]

I don't think Goldie is scum anyway

Would you like to qualify that with some reasoning? It will provide a nice distraction while he's busy choking

He did some stuff that gave past me town vibes, but I don't remember what it was. I trust my towndar though, so he's not really on my priority list atm.

[Hellenic Riot]

I don't think Goldie is scum anyway

Would you like to qualify that with some reasoning? It will provide a nice distraction while he's busy choking

He did some stuff that gave past me town vibes, but I don't remember what it was. I trust my towndar though, so he's not really on my priority list atm.

The fact an explanation this shite makes me townread you more is very irritating

[DemonRHK]

Gold feels more disinterested rather than scummy.

[Chaqa]

Would you like to qualify that with some reasoning? It will provide a nice distraction while he's busy choking

He did some stuff that gave past me town vibes, but I don't remember what it was. I trust my towndar though, so he's not really on my priority list atm.

The fact an explanation this shite makes me townread you more is very irritating

I've never bought into the "find 30 pieces of evidence and carefully notate them all and disseminate it to justify my reads" thing. I get vibes from people and trust them. It served me very well catching jasnah and snowy a few games ago, and also celaph here, and my town reads are usually vibe based.

Mostly town reads generally

[Maniac]

Rip bozo

[goldfinger0303]

HR, idk how more to say it... I've been trying to make ghug love me the entire game, and he's playing quite hard to get. I withdrew it when I had logged in and noticed ghug had moved on. My last post was just stating preferences for wagons.

You're also reading it with somewhat of a single-track mind. My last post was stay off celeph and Vecna, not just celaph. Burn me alive if both of them end up being scum, but that just proves I'm shitty town.

[Hellenic Riot]

He did some stuff that gave past me town vibes, but I don't remember what it was. I trust my towndar though, so he's not really on my priority list atm.

The fact an explanation this shite makes me townread you more is very irritating

I've never bought into the "find 30 pieces of evidence and carefully notate them all and disseminate it to justify my reads" thing. I get vibes from people and trust them. It served me very well catching jasnah and snowy a few games ago, and also celaph here, and my town reads are usually vibe based.

Mostly town reads generally

I'd say most people get their reads from 'vibes'. The thing about a text-based Mafia game however is that all of those 'vibes' are coming from the things people post, because you certainly ain't getting it from body language. Apart from when someone runs away when being pressured.

Just because you can't be bothered to remember which posts gave you said vibes doesn't mean it didn't come from them. I can assure you I don't have a 30 post database on why I townread Bob, but ze vibez I got during both EoD's were extremely townie.

[Hellenic Riot]

HR, idk how more to say it... I've been trying to make ghug love me the entire game, and he's playing quite hard to get. I withdrew it when I had logged in and noticed ghug had moved on. My last post was just stating preferences for wagons.

You're also reading it with somewhat of a single-track mind. My last post was stay off celeph and Vecna, not just celaph. Burn me alive if both of them end up being scum, but that just proves I'm shitty town.

No, goldie. You don't get to say you only voted celaph as a joke when you clearly indicated otherwise at the time. What changed from him being someone you didn't feel that strongly about to someone you really wanted people to stay off, in the space of ten minutes? Vecna's utterly irrelevant to this, regardless of his alignment.

[DemonRHK]

HR, idk how more to say it... I've been trying to make ghug love me the entire game, and he's playing quite hard to get. I withdrew it when I had logged in and noticed ghug had moved on. My last post was just stating preferences for wagons.

You're also reading it with somewhat of a single-track mind. My last post was stay off celeph and Vecna, not just celaph. Burn me alive if both of them end up being scum, but that just proves I'm shitty town.

Good sir, join jamie and I on the Vecna train. Free hugs! Punch and pie! DENTAL! You do not need to provide love unrequited.

[Chaqa]

The fact an explanation this shite makes me townread you more is very irritating

I've never bought into the "find 30 pieces of evidence and carefully notate them all and disseminate it to justify my reads" thing. I get vibes from people and trust them. It served me very well catching jasnah and snowy a few games ago, and also celaph here, and my town reads are usually vibe based.

Mostly town reads generally

I'd say most people get their reads from 'vibes'. The thing about a text-based Mafia game however is that all of those 'vibes' are coming from the things people post, because you certainly ain't getting it from body language. Apart from when someone runs away when being pressured.

Just because you can't be bothered to remember which posts gave you said vibes doesn't mean it didn't come from them. I can assure you I don't have a 30 post database on why I townread Bob, but ze vibez I got during both EoD's were extremely townie.

It's not that I can't be bothered, I just literally can't remember. I don't even remember most things that happened more than a game ago most of the time lol

When people mention remembering exact details of a game from 2015 or something I'm flabbergasted

Anyways, I think one thing that made me townread Goldie was his reaction to my roleblock claim.

[goldfinger0303]

HR, idk how more to say it... I've been trying to make ghug love me the entire game, and he's playing quite hard to get. I withdrew it when I had logged in and noticed ghug had moved on. My last post was just stating preferences for wagons.

You're also reading it with somewhat of a single-track mind. My last post was stay off celeph and Vecna, not just celaph. Burn me alive if both of them end up being scum, but that just proves I'm shitty town.

No, goldie. You don't get to say you only voted celaph as a joke when you clearly indicated otherwise at the time. What changed from him being someone you didn't feel that strongly about to someone you really wanted people to stay off, in the space of ten minutes? Vecna's utterly irrelevant to this, regardless of his alignment.

HR...I can't believe you're being serious here about this

[BobMcBob]

Hr, of your 3 scenarios do you feel is most likely?

Scenario A makes the people I townread look the most townie, and I'm okay to handwave Bob's VCA away because I think he was extremely townie in his posting through both EoD's. So I lean toward that. Scenario B is also reasonably plausible though.

Oh of course I got flamed for my VCA lol.

[kgray]

Durga, HR, Blamp, and Maniac are my top 4 scum suspects

wait lamp? why?

[kgray]

@bona who do you think it is besides boatman?

[Maniac]

@Maniac: You said yesterday that you found Vecna suspicious. Is that still your view?

Did I? If I did it must’ve been a fleeting thought.

[Maniac]

Ghug has done that thing that qualifies him as Town with a capital T.

[Chaqa]

Durga, HR, Blamp, and Maniac are my top 4 scum suspects

wait lamp? why?

No real reason, it just fits

[Maniac]

##vote HR

His D1 vote could be trying to save scum buddy Bob or TFB.
His D2 vote could be moving from scum buddy Celaph to Scum Buddy TFB for town cred.
What really jumps out to me though is his strong scum reading of Celaph and then almost zero advocating for his daykill especially in final minutes when it was still likely. HR I’m general strikes me as a leader who when he is convinced someone is scum will push that kill. His sliding on to someone who he hasn’t really expressed a strong scum read on seems out of town!HR character.