M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[bozotheclown]

Nice result, I have to re-evaluate my reads with Donny coming in with a critical celaph vote (unless it turns out TFB is mafia also, which I doubt).

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why do I get the feeling I could give you my username and password, let you log into my account, let you read my town role pm, and then still have you come back and tell me I was scum?

This is an exact facsimile of my relationship with Ghug.

Well, I do kinda like your deciding vote on celaph.

Yes, I'm a very decisive and dynamic individual, you're right. Thanks.

[goldfinger0303]

Good fucking job everyone. Let's go. :Hype:

Never again will I make the mistake of not trusting in ghug.

HR - I don't think I have ever played a game with celaph before, so I didn't understand half the arguments people were making against them. They were a null read for me pretty consistently. And of the main wagons when I left, I liked Bob and Boat better than celaph and Vecna.

[Chaqa]

I was Roleblocked.

is this a joke?

Is this a scumslip?

[Hellenic Riot]

Nice result, I have to re-evaluate my reads with Donny coming in with a critical celaph vote (unless it turns out TFB is mafia also, which I doubt).

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

How do you think that tallies with how long the TFB wagon took to overtake celaph and start consolidating?

[Bonatogether]

Why do I get the feeling I could give you my username and password, let you log into my account, let you read my town role pm, and then still have you come back and tell me I was scum?

i don't believe town makes the moves that you made, such as literally ignoring everything people told you (kgray telling you my meta) and asked you (my question as to why you were phrasing things as though you hadn't done legitimately scummy things)

I mean you can't have it both ways. I can't be attacked for using what others give me as your meta analysis and applying it to what I see from you and then also attack me for not taking kgray's word as the word of god on the matter. I weighed them both against each other and given your most recent town game vs the games from a year ago that kgray mentioned, I figured I'd like basing my read on the common refrain wrt your meta style over kgray's analysis from games that were played a year ago that I didn't have the ability to read myself.

When did I EVER attack you for using what other people told you? You only talked about m1016 or whatever the fuck you were prattling on about. You keep not reading beyond the first fucking sentence of my messages in these dipshit 'responses' you keep pushing out for some reason.

Those games are not from a year ago, those are from like, 5, 6 months ago? You could also take kgray's word, or ask @bob or whoever else was in those games.

[bozotheclown]

And now I can't claim they all sheeped me. Dang & Blast.

Why didn't you change your vote back to celaph before EOD?

[Jamiet99uk]

I was Roleblocked.

is this a joke?

I'm not sure.

@Durga: Was I joking?

[Bonatogether]

And before you say m71 was your most recent town game, you died D1 so I don't count it.

i got killed for being weird LMAO, what makes that one different?

[Hellenic Riot]

And now I can't claim they all sheeped me. Dang & Blast.

Why didn't you change your vote back to celaph before EOD?

Because jumping between the two main wagons is very liable to cause a tie and I'm not that much of an idiot.

[kgray]

Nice result, I have to re-evaluate my reads with Donny coming in with a critical celaph vote (unless it turns out TFB is mafia also, which I doubt).

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

bob looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

[BusinessLamp]

Donny is the only one I trust now

[Chaqa]

There's a lot of valuable VCA from this I think.

[Hellenic Riot]

why do you doubt boatman is mafia?

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

bob looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

The idea that I'd bus for 99.9% of a day and then move off right before I got any credit for it deeply amuses me

[ghug]

I was Roleblocked.

is this a joke?

Is this a scumslip?

Is this scum theater?

[kgray]

Donny is the only one I trust now

i think we can trust bona too

[TheFlyingBoat]

is this a joke?

Is this a scumslip?

Is this scum theater?

Are we scum buddies?

[Chaqa]

is this a joke?

Is this a scumslip?

Is this scum theater?

Not this time

[Bonatogether]

Donny is the only one I trust now

i thought you were my sidekick

[TheFlyingBoat]

It just seems like TFB must have been voted by mafia to try to save celaph.

maybe... but bona's push really feels like his normal town!bona pushes and i'm not considering scum!lamp. durga is possible and hr could be, but it'd be weird for him to sit on celaph all day and wait for me to yell at him to move off to actually move off. i guess he'd do that though.

bob looks worse i think, because of the way he voted/pressured celaph early but then backed off when celaph started becoming more widely scumread

The idea that I'd bus for 99.9% of a day and then move off right before I got any credit for it deeply amuses me

It's so ludicrous, no one would expect it, therefore you must have done it!