M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

i stopped reading at alphabetically, wtf

[BusinessLamp]

ive been paying less attention today than i thought, wow

[ghug]

ghug i dont get what you're doing right now

do you really think jamie is scum

we could do ghug instead

Your scumread of me continues to feel so halfhearted and unjustified.

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes, I absolutely believe scum Jamie is capable of an intense tunnel over catching someone in a lie. Do you not?

He spent most of today coasting on the townreads he's earned, and the recent Chaqa push is entirely based on willful misinterpretation.

What will it take for us to have a game together in which you don't scumread me?

Do I have to send you nudes?

literally never say that again please

I'll have you know I'm a perfectly decent specimen of manhood and I'm sure I could show Ghug a thing or two.

[kgray]

ghug i dont get what you're doing right now

do you really think jamie is scum

we could do ghug instead

Your scumread of me continues to feel so halfhearted and unjustified.

if it were that serious you'd know

[Bonatogether]

Honestly not sure about tfb, his post and earlier did give me scummy vibes, but its been more recent than anything else

so, boat man acting under pressure has been sus, but you're not willing to vote off of that?

[BobMcBob]

Stop memeing, Jamiet is a bad vote compared to what's else is up there.

Never felt too strongly about celaph, so since ghug is off I'm off too.

##vote bob

Is this because I made a solid response to your scumread of me so you need to gloss over it real quick?

I haven't even seen your response. I'm stealing glances at this when I can, but my family came down for the weekend to help me out with repairs and I just finished with a contractor getting estimates

Ah, well why did you move off celaph then? Did you see anything?

[Durga]

we could do ghug instead

Your scumread of me continues to feel so halfhearted and unjustified.

if it were that serious you'd know

get a room

[TheFlyingBoat]

But he doesn't do that as town, he normally finds a read he feels passionate about (like scum!bozo or kgray/celaph scumteam) and digs into it and talks about nothing else. I feel like you're just making these arguments up?

I disagree. Look at his play in M1020. He took a wide ranging view at the game, generated full reads list and did plenty of work beyond tunneling easy targets.

> kgray cites my finest moments in multiple games
> boat man: but 1 time he didn't play fully to that meta

what a nerd

I also literally never got the game numbers for those games lmao

[Chaqa]

Jamie wagon feels

[ghug]

Jamie wagon feels

Maybe you'd feel better about it if you joined it.

[Donny Dude]

Honestly not sure about tfb, his post and earlier did give me scummy vibes, but its been more recent than anything else

so, boat man acting under pressure has been sus, but you're not willing to vote off of that?

Yes to sus
TFB popped up on my radar only today hence why.

[goldfinger0303]

All right, I'm off til the end of phase. Whoever we end up on, I hope they're scum.

I don't like celaph or Vecna, of the leaders. Try to stay off them.

[kgray]

i just feel like boatman has mostly just buddied me and jamie and scumread easy targets that others were already sussing. i was pretty convinced by his enthusiasm against flum but maybe it really was too much given it all started because he was convinced by jamie's point that flum had 'lied'

[BobMcBob]

Jamie wagon feels

No it's brilliant! Fully sick!

[bozotheclown]

It seems like more people should be voting for Vecna.

[BobMcBob]

I disagree. Look at his play in M1020. He took a wide ranging view at the game, generated full reads list and did plenty of work beyond tunneling easy targets.

> kgray cites my finest moments in multiple games
> boat man: but 1 time he didn't play fully to that meta

what a nerd

I also literally never got the game numbers for those games lmao

What a very strange defense

[Bonatogether]

@TFB

Do you really not have any better scumread than a slot that has been essentially absent for 95% of the game? What do you think about the other wagons? What do you think about your own wagon & the people on it?

I like the Foxna wagon a good deal and it is bigger than the wagon on any other of my scum reads besides Celaph, but I like the people on the wagon on Foxna more and view them about equally on my scumdar now.

My other scum reads alphabetically are bona, celaph, damo, durga, and rdr for a primary scum pool of six. The people on Celaph's wagon rub me the wrong way even though I like the wagon itself. Goldfinger would probably be the next man onto my scum pool. I don't like Vecna obviously. I am fine with you and ghug, but I don't know if 2 of 5 would be bussing so early.

I like everyone but Demon on the Vecna wagon a fair deal, but ultimately I still think Demon is town despite finding his game weird.

I don't like the Bob wagon at all. rdr and damo are both sus to me. Donny has been very very inactive. Maniac is insane, but supposedly that's just Maniac.

I like kgray and Chaqa even though they are on my wagon, which makes me sad. I don't like bona, durga, or celaph obviously, so I suppose it makes sense they are on my wagon. Reasons for why can be found either in my most recent posts or in my reads list from the start of the day.

If YOU don't townread a player, why does it make sense they are on your wagon? That doesn't follow. It's very possible to scumread a player and not have them end up on your wagon, but more importantly, by phrasing it like this, you're ignoring the fact that your own actions got you here. You're making it seem like it was our personal dislike (as opposed to an honest scumread) that is the reason that you are getting voted. That's totally disingenuous.

[Chaqa]

If we're gonnna flash someone let's flash Maniac or HR

[TheFlyingBoat]

i stopped reading at alphabetically, wtf

I have an alphabetical notes list that I was reading down, hence why it is in alpha order. I figured I would make it clear what the order was before Bona mocks my ordered/unordered question, which I thought was a perfectly fine question to ask and lead to me probing ghug more later.

If you want it ordered most scum to least I'd go:

Vecna,Celaph,rdr,Durga,Bona,Damo