M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[DeathLlama8]

rdr, why is "bob is sleeping" a reason not to vote?

that was meant to follow this

[Jamiet99uk]

where's lfischl when you need him

Lfischl is participating in this game about as much as he usually does.

[Jamiet99uk]

Fluminator, can you please just answer my question?

[BobMcBob]

Also I've been swayed. ##Vote Foxc

This is the second time you've voted celaph and moved away. Are you worried that Flum joining you would make him a viable wagon?

No Jamie's fox argument was actually just quite good imo. I fully intended to leave the vote there when I made it.

[Fluminator]

Fluminator, can you please just answer my question?

Which one? I answered a lot of your questions earlier when I engaged with TFB

[TheFlyingBoat]

I've caught you being sus for one.
Lot of interesting stuff regarding bozo and donny and Jamiet. A few others like Chaqa and Kgray and Durga have given me some stuff too although I haven't fully analyzed it yet.

You haven't caught me being sus. You're just OMGUSing. As for the interesting stuff, care to actually say what that is? Or are you just going to dissemble and name drop until time runs out?

If you were actually reading my posts (which you apparently aren't) you'd know my thoughts on donny and bozo right now.

You mean where you said you wanted to scum read donny for finding the M61 stuff and confirming you but missing the later post you made? That would be interesting but you also couched it in the same post by saying you gut feel he is townie. Then you do roughly the same thing on bozo and said you're wifomming yourself on him. Both times on the two guys you say you have the most interesting information on you are unwilling to take any actual stand.

So I guess I'll ask the question: gun to your head town read or scum read on Donny and why? Same question for bozo.

[Jamiet99uk]

Fluminator, can you please just answer my question?

Which one? I answered a lot of your questions earlier when I engaged with TFB

This question:

The trust tell post isn't trolling though. Trolling is bugging people in a funny way to get a reaction. Nothing about the Trust tell was intended to be funny. It had a purpose.

You have repeatedly been asked to explain what that purpose was.

I have not seen you give a clear answer.

Please explain what your thinking was, that made you decide to make up a lie? Why did you think, at the moment you did it, that doing this would help town?

[Jamiet99uk]

Also I've been swayed. ##Vote Foxc

This is the second time you've voted celaph and moved away. Are you worried that Flum joining you would make him a viable wagon?

No Jamie's fox argument was actually just quite good imo. I fully intended to leave the vote there when I made it.

I would like Vecna to talk about this.

Tbh I'd like Vecna to post at all.

[BobMcBob]

I like Jamie's enthusiasm and I'm on board with ##vote fox

I'd be happier if you liked my arguments, rather than my enthusiasm. Do you think I'm right?

I think you're quite possibly town, for what that's worth.

[Durga]

@Durga do you think Flum is town or scum? I feel like you've been avoiding giving a direct opinion.

Null. He's usually pretty good at scum hunting as town so I'd rather keep him around in case.

Who do you have a strong feeling about?

A strong scum feeling? No one yet. I think tfb is a good shot today. I'd also be open to damo or RHK as I feel like both are awkward. DL and bob i keep going back and forth on. I feel pretty good about HR and ghug and honestly probably bozo.

Who are your scum reads other than flum?

[Jamiet99uk]

I like Jamie's enthusiasm and I'm on board with ##vote fox

I'd be happier if you liked my arguments, rather than my enthusiasm. Do you think I'm right?

I think you're quite possibly town, for what that's worth.

I'm quite definitely town.

[BobMcBob]

Okay Donny is a big old lump of eh. His reaction to flum trust tell is not good.
Ghug has done actually nothing except tfb argument which looks fine and also calling damo bad vibes.
Durga is playing in this game of mafia.
Bona is absolutely consistent with how Bona plays, nothing off at least.
Jamie is not ringing any alarm bells currently.
Kgray is feeling also pretty standard, and if she's vibing with my ideas than that signals a town mindset to me.
TFB hasn't done much but leaning town off arguing.
I vibe with blamp so far. Also DL8 surprisingly, after that start.
Flum is probably town.
Damo? More like lame-o
I have spoken on celaph, pretty standard so far but with one significant question mark.
Maniac is bad.
HR is a nuisance.
Demon has nothing going for him and a stupid post about data.
Rdr is pretty standard.

Huh, what's that? Mostly the lurkers look worse. Couldn't be... Call it a cop out if you want but this is my real thoughts, would currently maybe vote Donny, celaph, HR, Demon, damo, Maniac.

Oh I forgot goldfinger too damnit. Give him a pass. I really need to actually check my lists for completeness lol.

Your would vote list was donny, myself, and 4 of the bottom 5 posters very conviently leaving out gold until called on it. That kinda seems like an intentional omission.

It initially started as a reread of Donny, realised there was nothing to say and that I had time to go over more people, which eventually turned into rereading "everyone" but out of order. And then I didn't double check that I'd got everyone, so I missed some lame people accidentally.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Kgray are you going to vote?

@Vecna are you going to post?

[Hellenic Riot]

Null. He's usually pretty good at scum hunting as town so I'd rather keep him around in case.

Who do you have a strong feeling about?

A strong scum feeling? No one yet. I think tfb is a good shot today. I'd also be open to damo or RHK as I feel like both are awkward. DL and bob i keep going back and forth on. I feel pretty good about HR and ghug and honestly probably bozo.

Who are your scum reads other than flum?

What's awkward about damo, other than the fact he's damo?

[Chaqa]

I don't like that Rivera is still on no-kill especially after finding reasons to agree with multiple people's scumreads (especially the flum one is bothering me).

I feel like town!Chaqa would care more. He apparently hated the boatman wagon but has done nothing to counter it and I don't know who he actually scumreads, if anyone.

HR not commenting on the boatman wagon that he started but hinting he'd move to Donny is kind of yucky.

I’m voting for Durga because I scumread her. I laid out reasons why and her attitude has just reinforced it.

Generally I play my establishing townreads more than scumreads anyway, and if I try to get involved to save someone or push someone harder it usually just results in them or myself dying, so I don’t really feel motivated to do so.

[Durga]

Who do you have a strong feeling about?

A strong scum feeling? No one yet. I think tfb is a good shot today. I'd also be open to damo or RHK as I feel like both are awkward. DL and bob i keep going back and forth on. I feel pretty good about HR and ghug and honestly probably bozo.

Who are your scum reads other than flum?

What's awkward about damo, other than the fact he's damo?

Random assertions. Baseless votes. Lack of engagement.

Oh wait, you're right.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Fluminator, I'm waiting.

[Durga]

I don't like that Rivera is still on no-kill especially after finding reasons to agree with multiple people's scumreads (especially the flum one is bothering me).

I feel like town!Chaqa would care more. He apparently hated the boatman wagon but has done nothing to counter it and I don't know who he actually scumreads, if anyone.

HR not commenting on the boatman wagon that he started but hinting he'd move to Donny is kind of yucky.

I’m voting for Durga because I scumread her. I laid out reasons why and her attitude has just reinforced it.

Generally I play my establishing townreads more than scumreads anyway, and if I try to get involved to save someone or push someone harder it usually just results in them or myself dying, so I don’t really feel motivated to do so.

I'm your only scum read? Which happened to be after I said we should kill you? Classic

[Chaqa]

Wait this situation seems reaally familiar.....

it reminds me of the time Chaqa made that stupid crumb and Eden went ham on him for it

I'm not familiar with the phrase "went ham" but I don't think Chaqa and Fluminator are all that similar in their approaches, so I'm not sure this comparison is useful.

I've not totally caught up on the posts that I've missed, but unless Fluminator gave a very good explanation of his behaviour, I'll be unlikely to change my view (so, ok, I should go and look).

the situation being that eden was so sure because chaqa changed his story regarding his crumb that he was scum, when chaqa was town

like idk, maybe flum is scum, but i don't think your case is that strong and i don't think being finnicky over something like this is helpful - either way, i'm not shocked you're tunnelling in on it, i was just shocked tfb agreed.

Durga is mischaracterizing what happened with that crumb. I never changed my story. Eden didn’t believe I would stumble onto a crumb after fucking up the first one.

Durga/Flum scum team?

[kgray]

Null. He's usually pretty good at scum hunting as town so I'd rather keep him around in case.

Who do you have a strong feeling about?

A strong scum feeling? No one yet. I think tfb is a good shot today. I'd also be open to damo or RHK as I feel like both are awkward. DL and bob i keep going back and forth on. I feel pretty good about HR and ghug and honestly probably bozo.

Who are your scum reads other than flum?

Do you think boatman digs this hard into his Flum read with this much aggression if he's scum? I really don't...

I definitely think Fox was scummy but don't want to vote Vecna. I don't feel good about ghug. Rivera is giving me off vibes. I'm not really suspicious of DL but he's my early guess for the person that will trick me (could also be you lol), but I wouldn't vote him today. RHK seems sus but would scum really do that data analysis thing? bozo had a period of activity I liked but that's faded a lot. chaqa might be my best guess but I also feel like that's just a lazy default read, kind of like ghug...

I just feel like I have so many reasons to back out of scumreads.