M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[kgray]

Why is Fluminator voting for Celaph?

The vote itself is the only time Fluminator makes any mention of Celaph, and it's a naked vote with no explanation.

Unless Celaph has changed his style a ton, this is not the Celaph I remember

When have you played with town!Celaph? Was it just his first game?

[Fluminator]

Yeah, I got old person vibes from him in that one, and I get young person vibes in this one and it's throwing me off.

[Durga]

Oh, whoops. Forgot chaqa and foxc.
I agree with durga(?) that foxc has made surprisingly few serious contributions despite harping on us for not being serious.
Chaqa seems pretty norma

I think kgray said that

[kgray]

celaph be townier so I can discourage your wagon, please

[Durga]

Guess I'll sheep flum ##vote celaph

[Maniac]

he's been vaguely around and throwing a lot of weird shade without really looking for mafia

like

Final thoughts for the night. Bona is cool. I have no issues with TFB. Ghug is making some odd logics but it's nothing alarming. Blamp is pretty cool. We're probably just gonna end up shooting lurker #2 at this rate, but as long as it's not goldfinger... sure, it's acceptable.

these are not the words of someone who particularly cares who dies d1

Honestly I'd be more suspicious of anyone who did particularly care whether someone dies. I have no knowledge of who is what and nobody except ghug and TFB had done anything AI at that point. And we do have a track record of D1 lurker kills... Just being realistic.

So this is this post that originally tweaked my interest in Bob. I’m naturally suspicious of people who start sentences with ‘Honestly’ does that mean they are normally dishonest? But the line that jumped off the page to me was “I have no knowledge of who is what…’. I’ve played quite a few games and I’ve never seen town try and emphasise that they don’t know what everyone else rolled. It just didn’t sit right with me.

Whilst it wasn’t really a ‘gotcha’ moment. Bobs reaction was interesting and defensive and he openly stated he was fearful of dying. Why would town fear dying? Chances are most town will be dead before the end of the game. Dying isn’t a problem, winning as a team is all that matters. (I can almost hear you all screaming - ‘hell Maniac, didn’t you manipulate business lamp to stay alive?’ Yep I manipulated him (sorry business lamp) but it wasn’t through fear, just looking for reactions.

I also really don’t like Bob suddenly jumping on Foxy following Jamie’s case. It looks to me like Bob was scared that his wagon was building and he was looking for any viable alternative. Foxy would get town points if Bob flips scum.

I don’t have too much on anyone else and I’m aware the EOD is when I’m getting my beauty sleep, so I’m not going to switch off Bob today.

[kgray]

Guess I'll sheep flum ##vote celaph

No

You need a better reason to vote Celaph than sheeping Flum

[Hellenic Riot]

##vote TheFlyingBoat

Someone being ever-present for the entire shitposting phase only to pretty much disappear into the aether ever since, and only crop up whenever they're the object of discussions; aside from parroting questions at RHK on data, is a pretty disappointing display.

[TheFlyingBoat]

I find Jamie's argument pretty persuasive. ##VOTE foxcastle

[Fluminator]

There have been so many players this game who start posting the instant they get a vote without commenting on the vote. It's getting comical

[Hellenic Riot]

Quite the summon. Shame it was for even more parroting.

C'mon man, where are the original thoughts of The Young Hero?

[Durga]

##vote TheFlyingBoat

Someone being ever-present for the entire shitposting phase only to pretty much disappear into the aether ever since, and only crop up whenever they're the object of discussions; aside from parroting questions at RHK on data, is a pretty disappointing display.

I don't hate this either

[Durga]

@kgray how do you feel about tfb

[TheFlyingBoat]

blamp, this is a stupid take

also the sudden jump to talk formally from not even capitalizing makes me kinda scumread you cause i do that sometimes when i'm lying. also you go back to not capitalizing like a nerd next paragraph

This seems like a really weird thing to take issue with Bona. Can you explain why you think changing syntax in this particular context is scummy instead of just NAI?

it shows the thought they're putting into the message is at a different level from their other stuff, which immediately begs the question 'why' and 'what were they looking to get out of this'

i scumlean it because new players are usually not changing how much they think about something in the middle like that

Right and what's the answer to those two questions? You clearly have an opinion, why don't you share it?

[Durga]

We should kill Chaqa because it would be funny

[damo666]

##vote TheFlyingBoat

Someone being ever-present for the entire shitposting phase only to pretty much disappear into the aether ever since, and only crop up whenever they're the object of discussions; aside from parroting questions at RHK on data, is a pretty disappointing display.

I find HR's argument pretty persuasive. ##vote TheFlyingBoat

[damo666]

We should kill Chaqa because it would be funny

Why would it be funny?

[TheFlyingBoat]

##vote TheFlyingBoat

Someone being ever-present for the entire shitposting phase only to pretty much disappear into the aether ever since, and only crop up whenever they're the object of discussions; aside from parroting questions at RHK on data, is a pretty disappointing display.

I mean I thought I had some decent questions on bozo's list, which weren't all asked by others and after answer he answered them I personally viewed him as a slight town lean after. But also in my view the most interesting things that happened in the pages between 18 and like 32 were bozo's list, deathllama's return, and bona seizing on blamp with a lot of words but not a lot of actual explanation or backing to the argument, which is why I responded to it.

[kgray]

@kgray how do you feel about tfb

Very neutral. And I've previously scumread him hard when he's been town, so that's not very encouraging.

Him jumping on fox's wagon looks very opportunistic but I like Fox's wagon so I'm conflicted.

I'd vote him with you and HR though. And not *just* to get you off celaph

[kgray]

We should kill Chaqa because it would be funny

Why would it be funny?

My sadness is Durga's entertainment