MAFIA 71: "PAPERS PLEASE" - GAME THREAD [Hidden]

[brainbomb]

is it more beneficial to kill someone from the other scumteam today?

[rdrivera2005]

What do you find odd about their interactions?

It seems like she kept leading him to vote for different people and he kept following along with her. It came off as weird when I reread her posts.

But maybe knowing her alignment it clouded my perspective when I did the reread so I guess this was a dumb thing for me to do.

I can't see what you are talking about. I did follow Durga (in fact she followed me) on voting meme because I thought he could be scum and because I was townreading her. I didn't follow her on Macca or Bona and she didn't follow me on Fox, so I don't see this weird interaction you are talking about.

Point me to what you find weird.

[brainbomb]

i keep starting posts and then realizing they aren’t helpful and then stopping

resulting in this content-free post

you’re welcome

eden having self restraint is sus

after this durga calls the fight with ghug NAI and begs eden not to sub out. And in between says sabi is town and that sabi is playing much better; then talks about playing fire emblem

[Tom Bombadil]

i keep starting posts and then realizing they aren’t helpful and then stopping

resulting in this content-free post

you’re welcome

eden having self restraint is sus

after this durga calls the fight with ghug NAI and begs eden not to sub out. And in between says sabi is town and that sabi is playing much better; then talks about playing fire emblem

And?

[brainbomb]

what am I not explaining well enough here

how is this not totally obvious

[brainbomb]

the interactions are there
the subtext is there
the connections are all there

I cant fill in blanks anymore than I already have but everything you need to complete that scumteam is all there

[ghug]

Folks I have done the durga reread,

hold the applause please and thank you!

If I die, don't kill Foxcastle

Very odd because earlier in her post she also wanted flum to not die. kinda weird that she dropped flum.

(http://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/ ... 70#p278470)

GM NOTE:

Reminder of Rule 05: Players should not be messaging each other about the game, in any way whatsoever, outside of sanctioned threads / spaces.

I assume you are not doing that but just to clarify; thanks.

Okay but was there really a reason to GM slip that snowy and I aren't scum together

Very odd word choice here. "arent scum together" instead of saying we aren't scum. I guess this was a scumslip???

GM NOTE:

Reminder of Rule 05: Players should not be messaging each other about the game, in any way whatsoever, outside of sanctioned threads / spaces.

I assume you are not doing that but just to clarify; thanks.

Okay but was there really a reason to GM slip that snowy and I aren't scum together

This feels like her telling her teammates her wagon. Is there a way to figure out who switch votes from that point on from peter bot or do i need to manually search the pages and make a note for everyone that switched when she announced this?

She was saying the GM wouldn't tell them not to talk to each other if they were allowed to talk to each other. How would that be a scumslip?

[ghug]

Who townreads brain and can you explain why?

Kgray did. I feel like the stress in arguing overnight kinda gave me town vibes but I don't feel strongly about it.

[ghug]

Guys what if

We actually played this game

Although I'm totally cool with just killing ghug today for shits and giggles

It would help if you explained your reads better. Like why you townread brain more than saying he’s been acting towny. Or why you scumread me.

But also, we could just kill ghug for shits and giggles.

I think my biggest reads D2 are townreads of rdr and Flum which did not exist yesterday. Have you any changes since yesterday snowy?

What do you make of the trajectory my wagon has taken? Why is it just shits and giggles now when you actually wanted to kill me yesterday?

[ghug]

Guys what if

We actually played this game

Although I'm totally cool with just killing ghug today for shits and giggles

It would help if you explained your reads better. Like why you townread brain more than saying he’s been acting towny. Or why you scumread me.

But also, we could just kill ghug for shits and giggles.

I think my biggest reads D2 are townreads of rdr and Flum which did not exist yesterday. Have you any changes since yesterday snowy?

I don't know what to tell you, except I do

Uhh *checks notes* I added bozo to my townreads and damo to my scumreads if that helps

Since you're so keen on explaining your reads what's up with rivera and Flum?

What reason is there to townread bozo?

[brainbomb]

I would support eliminating macca over you and fluminator rather than you.
do you have any interest in forming a wagon together?

[ghug]

I would support eliminating macca over you and fluminator rather than you.
do you have any interest in forming a wagon together?

Feel free to join me on Macca. I'm liking Flum more today, he should probably get another day. Tom and bozo could also use pressure.

[brainbomb]

ghug?

my above post is to you

[brainbomb]

##vote macca

[Tom Bombadil]

Guys what if

We actually played this game

Although I'm totally cool with just killing ghug today for shits and giggles

It would help if you explained your reads better. Like why you townread brain more than saying he’s been acting towny. Or why you scumread me.

But also, we could just kill ghug for shits and giggles.

I think my biggest reads D2 are townreads of rdr and Flum which did not exist yesterday. Have you any changes since yesterday snowy?

What do you make of the trajectory my wagon has taken? Why is it just shits and giggles now when you actually wanted to kill me yesterday?

Not much has changed. I was just mirroring what snowy said. Your wagon doesn't need any help though. I don't really read too much into your wagon getting so large. You would have at most 2 teammates, so less reason to be wary of no apparent protection.

I have a little fear that kgray was kiled to set you up, but thats WIFOM.

[rdrivera2005]

what am I not explaining well enough here

how is this not totally obvious

Brain, I think you are explaining well your case on Sabi and Squigs. I can see this interaction you pointed, but I can't reach a conclusion. I am not saying it's not possible and I am not totally averse of flipping Sabi today or tomorrow as they are acting in a way I can see scum doing specially after a teammate flip. But the interaction with Eden doesn't feel staged, I can't see what you are seeing.

[brainbomb]

What about squiggs current play so far do you find to be his best moments?

[brainbomb]

Well I suppose I should give my pre-reread one now and then a post-reread tomorrow night some time after I am done with Diplomacy.

Team 1: Durga, ghug, Macca Team 2: Flum, lfischl, Captainmeme

Once again, this will likely change significantly post-read because Flum's comment is nagging at me hard. But then again maybe if I unfold his story maybe I'll find that I was right all along.

so the durga on a team with macca read makes no sense because it would require durga to be bussing in a situation with 5 other options she couldve gone for none of which was on her team. why does durga give up a runaway wagon to go bus macca and risk getting macca killed there?

that team composition requires durga to do things she simply doesnt do shes not a moron

[brainbomb]

durgas excitement to kill off bona was my pledge to be next to die if I was wrong. she blissfully joined as soon as I said that and made a comment it was too good of an offer to pass on. she then later leaves this wagon to push macca

so basically what im saying is from this macca cannot be scum with durga

[brainbomb]

was this already talked about by anyone else?