M1019 – Once Upon A Time… [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

Various people are saying they suspect TFB but aren't voting for him. Sad.

##Vote Doom instead then

Do you understand the "mechish" reason why not?

I can't say that I do. Could you explain it to me?

[Jamiet99uk]

I think Jamie voters are all town.

Now if Jamie is town this implies both scum are off Jamie. Now this doesn't make a lot of sense (unless perhaps they think it's too early).

So I think Jamie must be scum.

Just what

I concur with Durga's comments.

[BunnyGo]

Various people are saying they suspect TFB but aren't voting for him. Sad.

##Vote Doom instead then

Do you understand the "mechish" reason why not?

I can't say that I do. Could you explain it to me?

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

[BunnyGo]

I did not scum read rdr

Then don't vote for him, agggggggg. W/e, you're not voting on him now at least. It's just such a suspicious reaction to getting pressure on you, but we're past that point in this game.

I went and did a quick double check, and Jamie also jumped on a larger wagon, but he scum read me plenty, especially before the vote, a lot more than he scum read rdr, which is why I can kinda buy it.

Assuming this discovery I'm in ends at a reasonable time, which it should, I will be around

For the record, my response to this was saying "I wish I was a cool lady lawyer" before quickly realizing that no, I do not want that. I like dipping out of the office early to go home and play video games. Law people work long hours.

I just want to wear cool lady lawyer clothes

Annnnd just as I said that we had to adjourn because the plaintiff's translator wasn't accurate. Looks like the world is so that I'm meant to just play mafia

I’m curious: who identified the inaccuracies?

[Jamiet99uk]

Do you understand the "mechish" reason why not?

I can't say that I do. Could you explain it to me?

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

And this proves what?

[Durga]

Then don't vote for him, agggggggg. W/e, you're not voting on him now at least. It's just such a suspicious reaction to getting pressure on you, but we're past that point in this game.

I went and did a quick double check, and Jamie also jumped on a larger wagon, but he scum read me plenty, especially before the vote, a lot more than he scum read rdr, which is why I can kinda buy it.



For the record, my response to this was saying "I wish I was a cool lady lawyer" before quickly realizing that no, I do not want that. I like dipping out of the office early to go home and play video games. Law people work long hours.

I just want to wear cool lady lawyer clothes

Annnnd just as I said that we had to adjourn because the plaintiff's translator wasn't accurate. Looks like the world is so that I'm meant to just play mafia

I’m curious: who identified the inaccuracies?

The plaintiff, who speaks a fair amount of English but wasn't comfortable enough to testify in it

[damo666]

I can't say that I do. Could you explain it to me?

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

[Durga]

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Is there actual proof of this

[Jamiet99uk]

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Ghug may also have simply seen him not visiting.

If TFB is the other sibling, you would apparently know this, yes?

[Doom427]

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Is there actual proof of this

Eh, enough to not kill TFB today at least?

If he is town, make Mafia wonder who is lost sibling. We can kill TFB later, I don't think it's a great clear, but it's enough

[Doom427]

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Ghug may also have simply seen him not visiting.

If TFB is the other sibling, you would apparently know this, yes?

But we're trying to keep it secret hush hush, aren't we?

Even if TFB isn't lost sibling, he could be sleepwalker.

Also, Ghug knew that no one except Kak would do the murder, so not visiting doesn't mean anything

[damo666]

I think Jamie voters are all town.

Now if Jamie is town this implies both scum are off Jamie. Now this doesn't make a lot of sense (unless perhaps they think it's too early).

So I think Jamie must be scum.

Just what

I concur with Durga's comments.

At the time of posting there were 3 people on Jamie; me, TFB and DL.

If scumpair was {rdr and Bunny} or {rdr or Bunny + someone not on Jamie wagon} I would have expected them to vote Jamie hence I conclude Jamie is scum.

Unless of course scum are something weird like Durga/Sabi.

[damo666]

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Is there actual proof of this

No. It is supposition.

[damo666]

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Ghug may also have simply seen him not visiting.

If TFB is the other sibling, you would apparently know this, yes?

i) Then imo ghug wouldn't as strongly advocating not voting him
ii) Ofc. And if he's sleepwalker I wouldn't.

[Doom427]

Just what

I concur with Durga's comments.

At the time of posting there were 3 people on Jamie; me, TFB and DL.

If scumpair was {rdr and Bunny} or {rdr or Bunny + someone not on Jamie wagon} I would have expected them to vote Jamie hence I conclude Jamie is scum.

Unless of course scum are something weird like Durga/Sabi.

Just agreeing with others this argument isn't great, but Damo is townclear, and the argument isn't great why are y'all bringing it back up? No one else was using it to prove Jamie was scum, I don't think.

[BunnyGo]

I can't say that I do. Could you explain it to me?

Ghug repeatedly asked people to never vote form himself or TFB starting day 2.

And this proves what?

You’re not this obtuse. It’s a data point that ghug may have followed TFB on N1 and he’s the sleepwalker or mason.

[BunnyGo]

And this proves what?

The theory is ghug tracked TFB to non-snowy indicating TFB is town.

Is there actual proof of this

No. I suggested that from damo’s POV, it’s less likely TFB is the sleepwalker than the other mason (whom damo knows). But I’m reread it felt like ghug was leaving hints. Most of his posts seem to be mocking kaka’s claim or asking people not to vote TFB.

[DeathLlama8]

@jamiet

no comment on behavior - I agree that it's unfair to disincentivize him being nice- - but he had 45 posts yesterday, mostly before damo's reveal, without really actively scumhunting, and I don't have anything to townread him off of. The kakarroto townread is weird but probably something kaka would've felt more comfortable doing with a N0 chat, and also something that was expressed before the game.

here's my vote fwiw. not that strong of a read though

[DeathLlama8]

i will not be super active at EOD but I'll check to make sure nothing's on fire

[Durga]

I will give ghug the benefit of the doubt and state he wouldn't have been so reckless about his read knowing he might flip before revealing