M1019 – Once Upon A Time… [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[TheFlyingBoat]

My towncore is Damo, Doom, Death, and ghug. Sabi seems town enough but that may be because I am more willing to write weird things they do off given their play last game and their general newness.

That leaves the PoE as Durga, Bunnicula (my Bunny/Vecna combo), Jamie, and rdr.

If I had to rank I go Jamie, Durga, rdr, and Bunnicula

why do you feel this way about any of these people

Easy, your vote and Doom's vote on Kak that made it a tie and then put him in the lead with 15 mins to go seem incredibly unlikely to come from mafia. Damo is the lost sibling, ghug's active posting and mechanical analysis seemed incredibly townie.

[Durga]

Do you want me to post a paragraph worth of explanation for each that you won't read or do you just want me to quote reply it for you?

I'd like to see you interact and evolve your reads with the game and share those reads as they evolve actually

[damo666]

At the moment I'm gonna follow ghug's advice and ##vote Jamie

[DeathLlama8]

My towncore is Damo, Doom, Death, and ghug. Sabi seems town enough but that may be because I am more willing to write weird things they do off given their play last game and their general newness.

That leaves the PoE as Durga, Bunnicula (my Bunny/Vecna combo), Jamie, and rdr.

If I had to rank I go Jamie, Durga, rdr, and Bunnicula

why do you feel this way about any of these people

Easy, your vote and Doom's vote on Kak that made it a tie and then put him in the lead with 15 mins to go seem incredibly unlikely to come from mafia. Damo is the lost sibling, ghug's active posting and mechanical analysis seemed incredibly townie.

cool thanks
wb the PoE ranking?

[damo666]

oh probably durga too
eod1 + the NK choices so far make me feel like scum are lurking though

naw, i'm town. and we can't afford to kill me, sorry.

This is an odd post. Why are you so valuable?

[TheFlyingBoat]

the bot has been back up but he still hasnt done any hunting

I have a pretty good PoE set up imo.

you haven't done shit? do you think you're gonna copy ghug's POE list that conveniently removes you and coast to the end game w/o providing any independent thoughts or actions? are you gonna actually try to catch scum or is your idea of playing this game make random shots via your "PoE set up" and hope for the best?

No I now plan to do a reread of interactions of others with ghug to figure out why they killed him instead of damo. There was also one other line that I recall being suspicious that I will need to search for to identify who said it and see if it is NAI or scum indicative.

[Durga]

oh probably durga too
eod1 + the NK choices so far make me feel like scum are lurking though

naw, i'm town. and we can't afford to kill me, sorry.

This is an odd post. Why are you so valuable?

Because I'm good at this game duh

[damo666]

naw, i'm town. and we can't afford to kill me, sorry.

This is an odd post. Why are you so valuable?

Because I'm good at this game duh

Ok who's your scum pool then?

[Durga]

This is an odd post. Why are you so valuable?

Because I'm good at this game duh

Ok who's your scum pool then?

I'm just halfway through my rereread of d1 but so far I don't like Jamie and rdr and tfb. Hopefully your buddy is one of these three. Vecna looks a lot better than I remember. I have a yoga class now but will finish my read when I'm back

[Durga]

I would actually really like to know if tfb is the buddy so I can stop tunneling if so but yeah yeah hiding info from scum blah blah blah

[BesharamSabi]

Can someone explain why we can't reveal who the other lost sibling is?

[Doom427]

Can someone explain why we can't reveal who the other lost sibling is?

That way scum don't know they can shoot them is my guess?

[TheFlyingBoat]

why do you feel this way about any of these people

Easy, your vote and Doom's vote on Kak that made it a tie and then put him in the lead with 15 mins to go seem incredibly unlikely to come from mafia. Damo is the lost sibling, ghug's active posting and mechanical analysis seemed incredibly townie.

cool thanks
wb the PoE ranking?

Sure, the ranking is more a product of meta analysis and less of hard behavior, something I hope to supplement during my reread and in fact I already do feel somewhat less confident in it. I liked some of Bunny's earlier posts but points about him being a replacement and therefore easily able to play as town since that's how he basically thought about it before he replaced was convincing to me that I shouldn't take that as town indicative as one would initially think. Further some of his later posts were far less appealing and that was true even before ghug's death. Bunnicula is now pretty higher on my list.

Rdr is someone who's posting I generally like but do find to be hard to read for certain. He hasn't done anything I would consider obv town and is therefore in the PoE. He was on the back side of it earlier just in front of bunny because while he hadn't obv towned he had posted well but not that bunny is higher up on my list, rdr is now at the bottom of it. The fact he didn't really fight it at all and understood why he was on the list was nice.

Durga has seemed off this game and hasn't been asking the tough questions I saw her ask last time and has been shitposting interspersed with a little bit of righteous indignation for not being seen as obv town yet.


As for Jamie, he's been far too nice and unabrasive. Someone told me in the last game Jamie fakes being nice when he's scum where he feels more comfortable being an asshole when he's town.

[damo666]

Can someone explain why we can't reveal who the other lost sibling is?

I guess I reveal eventually. Then we have two clears for 2 days and we soak up the next 2 NKs. If I don't reveal you wont have a clear.

I suppose they could claim if under pressure and if there's a counter we have deffo one for one trade.

[damo666]

I would actually really like to know if tfb is the buddy so I can stop tunneling if so but yeah yeah hiding info from scum blah blah blah

Well I can reveal it is not you. You have done that yourself near enough!

[Durga]

Tfb you're so full of shit omg

[Durga]

Can someone explain why we can't reveal who the other lost sibling is?

I guess I reveal eventually. Then we have two clears for 2 days and we soak up the next 2 NKs. If I don't reveal you wont have a clear.

I suppose they could claim if under pressure and if there's a counter we have deffo one for one trade.

I assume you're the next NK

[Durga]

I would actually really like to know if tfb is the buddy so I can stop tunneling if so but yeah yeah hiding info from scum blah blah blah

Well I can reveal it is not you. You have done that yourself near enough!

[Durga]

Damo I was thinking about it while I was supposed to meditate and cleanse my mind of my daily struggles but doesn't it make more sense to reveal the other clear now because you'll have to do it anyway EoN and you'll die this night and they'll die the next night so we might as well have two town clears direct this kill that one?

[Durga]

Don't reveal if it's DL tho