M1019 – Once Upon A Time… [GAME THREAD] [HIDDEN]

[Kakarroto]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

Well we will get him tomorrow. Too bad we lose a full day this way but that's just my fault I guess.

How is it your fault?

If damo with his weird counter is more believable than me, then I made some mistakes as PR.

[BunnyGo]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

[BunnyGo]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

Well we will get him tomorrow. Too bad we lose a full day this way but that's just my fault I guess.

What do you mean lose a full day?

[Durga]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

[Kakarroto]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

Well we will get him tomorrow. Too bad we lose a full day this way but that's just my fault I guess.

What do you mean lose a full day?

Well D3 will be all voting damo without progress for town.

[Durga]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

Then again it just takes one sibling to say fake the next day after failing

[Kakarroto]

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

Then again it just takes one sibling to say fake the next day after failing

Wouldn't that reveal another PR? I think I wouldn't mind a 2 for 1 trade as mafia here.

[DeathLlama8]

two more votes to hammer according to the bot

[Durga]

Aghhhh I hate this!!

[BunnyGo]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

Indicating that scum never discussed this in the scumchat. There are many reasons that may be the case. But there are many players here I’d expect to figure it out in a N0.

[Doom427]

two more votes to hammer according to the bot

I'd like to wait until we hear from Sabi and TFB so we have everyone's reaction but...
Well...
I had enough of the big multi-page fights last game. I won't cry if others vote to end early so we have something else to discuss. Don't think Bunny and Ghug's chat is getting us any info at this point.

[Durga]

Why would Damo visit snowy any way didn't snowy scum read damo

[BunnyGo]

Why would Damo visit snowy any way didn't snowy scum read damo

I think only one sibling needs to find the other. They don’t both need to find each other.

[Doom427]

I was expecting a fake claim to be the sibling: doesn’t lead to immediate CC and prevents siblings from trying to find each other. Can even do the kill and if followed by tracker can claim you thought they were possible sib. It’s a fake claim that neutralizes all the PRs. It’s why I originally strongly believed kaka’s claim despite scum reading him.

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

Indicating that scum never discussed this in the scumchat. There are many reasons that may be the case. But there are many players here I’d expect to figure it out in a N0.

Bunny, we were told there would be a sucm chat N0. Eden would be fucking the game up if he didn't give that. There are plenty of options for chat on the internet. They were able to discuss.

[BesharamSabi]

Sorry for ruining your reveal Ghug, suspense was killing me.

Glad Bunny did the post, hope he can give us a read on Vecna though. He wasn't mentioned, and I'm very curious if Bunny knows anything about his alignment

Ah yes. I think I forgot to include rdr too. My reads in both were similar: somewhat null but towny for the posts they had.

This is different than Doom. Who has been VERY different this game than last one (and I really liked that Sabi pointed this out). But i never got the sense it came from a scummy place. I had two theories about it. Neither worth mentioning, but I bring it up because it wasn’t a “null with town lean” like Vecna, it was “different, but probably not scum”

Wow bunny approved of my gaming. Maybe she's a PR or scum but doom sure as heck isn't VT. It's still off for me.

[Durga]

@damo what made you pick snowy?

[BunnyGo]

Oh hey that's really smart - but Kaks might not have thought of it like that and just went for the most powerful one

Indicating that scum never discussed this in the scumchat. There are many reasons that may be the case. But there are many players here I’d expect to figure it out in a N0.

Bunny, we were told there would be a sucm chat N0. Eden would be fucking the game up if he didn't give that. There are plenty of options for chat on the internet. They were able to discuss.

Ah. Was this in the signup thread? I only saw that in people’s comments. But still, it means that several players who would discuss this (eg Damo, Vecna, Jamie, probably you (doom)) didn’t communicate their thoughts about what to fake claim if caught. The players who always consider mechs would have considered this in the chat.

[ghug]

If Kak was scum wouldn't he just claim he followed one of his scum members and saw nothing for the sake of not being contradicted? I mean maybe not but it seems like an easier result than this.

At the same time damo is adament so I don't knooooow

I mean, claiming no visit on a townie has the potential to out a PR without drawing attention to a teammate, right?

[BesharamSabi]

two more votes to hammer according to the bot

I'd like to wait until we hear from Sabi and TFB so we have everyone's reaction but...
Well...
I had enough of the big multi-page fights last game. I won't cry if others vote to end early so we have something else to discuss. Don't think Bunny and Ghug's chat is getting us any info at this point.

OK can someone give me the pros and cons of hammering kako rn?

[DeathLlama8]

two more votes to hammer according to the bot

I'd like to wait until we hear from Sabi and TFB so we have everyone's reaction but...
Well...
I had enough of the big multi-page fights last game. I won't cry if others vote to end early so we have something else to discuss. Don't think Bunny and Ghug's chat is getting us any info at this point.

OK can someone give me the pros and cons of hammering kako rn?

I can if you tell me what you think of kakarroto and damo’s respective claims