M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[BunnyGo]

Maybe they thought cop!Chaqa would scan the GF? Would need to look back at Chaqa's biggest question marks.

Otherwise, no idea.

Holy hell. I like this idea. I might town read you less for it though.

Snowy is Godfather, I bet.

Oooh. That is interesting

[President Eden]

I want Chaqa to find a girlfriend too, but I doubt we'd ever believe him if he did.

i'm doing better than chaqa, a girl wrote her phone number in my agenda book last week

Ugh, strong teenage ghug vibes...

I am shocked that both look/looked up to me so checks out

[BunnyGo]

Okay I'm sorry Chaqa if you're really the cop. I'm sure I'm one of the people pissing you off.

But it's so odd to me that you didn't seem more shocked and surprised to not only have not been RB'd but to also have gotten a guilty?? Like, you have no emotion? No excitement? You're not thrilled to rub it in all of our faces that you're actually doing a great job as a PR?

That said, it's not like Tom seems too excited about catching scum!Chaqa lying either.

this is exactly how i feel about both of these things which makes me want to kill both of them lol

I mean we all know I’m going to get wagoned today barring a cc I don’t see coming. I’m more confused than anything.

It’s hard to be excited when I didn’t “catch” scum Chaqa since I’ll be killed, I won’t flip and nothing will get resolved. It’s an easy 50/50 scum will win which is probably why they are doing it. Plus it tells them if a cop is still in the game as it essentially forces a cc if there is one.

Like I know I’m dead, and because I don’t flip Chaqa won’t be caught. What is there to be excited about lol

9/10 for scum!tom
4/10 for town!tom

[BunnyGo]

What if Flum was the oracle?

A) then chaqa isn’t cop and Flum would have known
B) we’d have gotten a result with the death.

[BunnyGo]

Maybe they thought cop!Chaqa would scan the GF? Would need to look back at Chaqa's biggest question marks.

Otherwise, no idea.

Holy hell. I like this idea. I might town read you less for it though.

Yes my favorite thing to do as scum is slip insider knowledge of our scummy motivations into the main thread just so I can come off as having good ideas

Yes…

[BunnyGo]

I didn't earlier say it, but Killing Flum is just the most obvious move in the world for Scum. Bunny or Flum are both good kills, but Bunny we do talk about possibly being Evil. Flum has no chance of getting daykilled, so he's a great NK. Which means sure, WorceJ could defend Flum, but then ... Just don't kill Flum? Don't kill Flum, and kill random person that doctor won't visit. I can't understand Mafia's head here.

Toms conspiracy theory about Jasnah!cop is ... Reaching. If no one counterclaims we kill Tom, Oracle can scan, but we assume Tom is scum, and Oracle gives themself up near endgame if Mafia doesn't shoot them by then.

Doom has finally gone off the rails lmao

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

[Doom427]

And I guess that's why I should never play Mafia in the Tub. I put my glasses back on, and now I'll be smart, calm, and collected.

People Scum will never Night Kill-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, TFB(?)
Town clears-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, Flum, Bunny, TFB
Mafia likes to kill town clears, so going for Flum isn't that surprising. We already know they want to keep the "Are PR is scum?!?!?(confirmed!!!!)" Controversy alive (And so do I, it's exciting!), And night killing any of them removes all that controversy and potential misKills. (Unless they night kill WorceJ to leave Bona as the lone Mafia, but... They wouldn't, right?).

Killing Flum has an obvious benefit, and if WorceJ has done the same Calculus, he might protect Flum, and Scum REALLY don't want WorceJ to get another scan off, and have a more solid alibi. So, there is a pretty easy explanation, assuming WorceJ and Chaqa are both townies. It does Make Mafia look like total chumps for losing SO badly on another play. Honesly, Mafia has to make a play. If someone claims Cop, I'll probably default to guessing they're Mafia fake-claiming, because if we have a Scum!Tom, Mafia has to go for it and have someone else claim they're cop.

Hmmm.... So... If no one counterclaims, and Tom is scum.... The only reason Mafia wouldn't counter... Is if They already claimed something else . . Are PR is Scum confirmed!!!!!

[President Eden]

And I guess that's why I should never play Mafia in the Tub. I put my glasses back on, and now I'll be smart, calm, and collected.

People Scum will never Night Kill-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, TFB(?)
Town clears-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, Flum, Bunny, TFB
Mafia likes to kill town clears, so going for Flum isn't that surprising. We already know they want to keep the "Are PR is scum?!?!?(confirmed!!!!)" Controversy alive (And so do I, it's exciting!), And night killing any of them removes all that controversy and potential misKills. (Unless they night kill WorceJ to leave Bona as the lone Mafia, but... They wouldn't, right?).

Killing Flum has an obvious benefit, and if WorceJ has done the same Calculus, he might protect Flum, and Scum REALLY don't want WorceJ to get another scan off, and have a more solid alibi. So, there is a pretty easy explanation, assuming WorceJ and Chaqa are both townies. It does Make Mafia look like total chumps for losing SO badly on another play. Honesly, Mafia has to make a play. If someone claims Cop, I'll probably default to guessing they're Mafia fake-claiming, because if we have a Scum!Tom, Mafia has to go for it and have someone else claim they're cop.

Hmmm.... So... If no one counterclaims, and Tom is scum.... The only reason Mafia wouldn't counter... Is if They already claimed something else . . Are PR is Scum confirmed!!!!!

Crushed it.

[BunnyGo]

Maybe they thought cop!Chaqa would scan the GF? Would need to look back at Chaqa's biggest question marks.

Otherwise, no idea.

Holy hell. I like this idea. I might town read you less for it though.

Are we absolutely sure Bunny is the Miller?

No. I’m the cop*. And it’s too late for tom to CC me at this point. I was looking forward to that.















*ITS A JOKE!!!

[BunnyGo]

Holy hell. I like this idea. I might town read you less for it though.

Are we absolutely sure Bunny is the Miller?

It’s been in the back of my mind that he might not be, but I don’t see any serious reason to believe it.

That said, jasnah might be a better Oracle target than Tom, if we think lfischl isn’t the Cop. Clears up two potential controversies at once.

But mostly I just think he’s the Miller.

This is true. I don’t see lfischl staying quiet day 2. Let alone day 3.

[kgray]

Doom has finally gone off the rails lmao

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

No they don’t. In what world does scum have this level of unfiltered stream-of-consciousness posting style?

[Doom427]

Doom has finally gone off the rails lmao

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

Town!Doom plays it safe, triple checks her phasing, and never says anything off that would make others think she is anything else. Scum!Doom talks crazy and doesn't edit posts. Got it.

I get from a meta perspective why we don't want to encourage poorly worded posts, but that's such a silly scum tell. This forum won't have anything post wise for a little bit, because the only thing we're waiting on is a possible CC (scum team kicking themselves for not having one planned out), so what about this is scummy? Need to have a solid scum game if I roll them in my next game, after all.

[rdrivera2005]

Well, I can't find any sense on this game in any way.

Scum allowing a cop scan is such a bad play it's unbelievable.

Scum Chaqa claiming a guilty scum on Tom with Oracle still alive (probably) is such a bad play is unbelievable.

I already thought Tom was scum so ##vote Tom, but Oracle should probably target Tom.

[BunnyGo]

Also I’m pretty sure I know who the Oracle is but they aren’t likely to reveal ever because they don’t roll like that

why would you say this

Oooh. I figured out who the Oracle is now too…

[Bonatogether]

And I guess that's why I should never play Mafia in the Tub. I put my glasses back on, and now I'll be smart, calm, and collected.

People Scum will never Night Kill-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, TFB(?)
Town clears-WorceJ, Bona, Chaqa, Flum, Bunny, TFB
Mafia likes to kill town clears, so going for Flum isn't that surprising. We already know they want to keep the "Are PR is scum?!?!?(confirmed!!!!)" Controversy alive (And so do I, it's exciting!), And night killing any of them removes all that controversy and potential misKills. (Unless they night kill WorceJ to leave Bona as the lone Mafia, but... They wouldn't, right?).

Killing Flum has an obvious benefit, and if WorceJ has done the same Calculus, he might protect Flum, and Scum REALLY don't want WorceJ to get another scan off, and have a more solid alibi. So, there is a pretty easy explanation, assuming WorceJ and Chaqa are both townies. It does Make Mafia look like total chumps for losing SO badly on another play. Honesly, Mafia has to make a play. If someone claims Cop, I'll probably default to guessing they're Mafia fake-claiming, because if we have a Scum!Tom, Mafia has to go for it and have someone else claim they're cop.

Hmmm.... So... If no one counterclaims, and Tom is scum.... The only reason Mafia wouldn't counter... Is if They already claimed something else . . Are PR is Scum confirmed!!!!!

What the hell is this 'people will never night kill'? If all these people are in town clear, doesn't that mean they will be nked at some point?

[BunnyGo]

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

No they don’t. In what world does scum have this level of unfiltered stream-of-consciousness posting style?

Hmm. You may be right.

[Bonatogether]

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

No they don’t. In what world does scum have this level of unfiltered stream-of-consciousness posting style?

I did that as my first game as scum

[BunnyGo]

??? Nothing I'm saying is even that different from anyone else???

Am I like... In a coma, and this is my brains attempt to wake me up? What am I saying that's odd. Killing Flum makes sense, blocking WorceJ to let off a Chaqa scan is dumb. That's my analysis of end of night results.

Then I say what I think we should do. Kill Tom. Oracle scans tom. Oracle dies, and tells us if Tom is scum or a VT. If VT, we kill Chaqa? What's weird?!?!?

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

Town!Doom plays it safe, triple checks her phasing, and never says anything off that would make others think she is anything else. Scum!Doom talks crazy and doesn't edit posts. Got it.

I get from a meta perspective why we don't want to encourage poorly worded posts, but that's such a silly scum tell. This forum won't have anything post wise for a little bit, because the only thing we're waiting on is a possible CC (scum team kicking themselves for not having one planned out), so what about this is scummy? Need to have a solid scum game if I roll them in my next game, after all.

Mostly I wanted to see how you responded when I piled on.

[BunnyGo]

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

No they don’t. In what world does scum have this level of unfiltered stream-of-consciousness posting style?

I did that as my first game as scum

I do it most games regardless of alignment. But most people don’t.

[kgray]

Doom. I’m loving the first game play from you. But these posts have been screaming that you’re not town.

No they don’t. In what world does scum have this level of unfiltered stream-of-consciousness posting style?

I did that as my first game as scum

Nah not like this. You just kept brazenly pushing scummy ideas, not wildly rambling about mafia motivations and theories. What Doom's doing has a very high chance of backfiring if she gives up that she knows too much (unless it's not actually impulsive and is just acting, in which case, wow).