M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[snowy801]

@Durga why do you townread kgray?

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I don't think you're being too much of a dick, but I do think you're slightly being a dick.

Like when I become absolutely sure someone's scum I treat them with a light touch because personally I see scum being as sacrifice to create an enjoyable mafia game for town and I wouldn't really want to compound that by smacking them around at every opportunity (see: me with Jamiet in M69)

it must be annoying having everything you do being called scummy as soon as you do it regardless of your alignment. And it invites both tunneling on your part and undesirable part on hers. I like to let my suspects breathe a little so they can show their true colors naturally

[President Eden]

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

I do feel pretty bad that she's upset but I also don't think her representation of how ghug and Eden (among others) treated her is accurate / faithful

And ghug is really bad at communications / asking questions I noticed from his and Jamiet's love tiffs

Yeah and I get that being ganged up on is frustating and terrible and PE is illogical and ghug is a bully who feels the need to comment on every single thing but she hasn't exactly been hella townie or advocating for the best moves so idkkkk

I think the various times I have pushed back on or sussed kgray have been among my more focused and logical posts this game, which is why I am interested in letting this one play out some

[Durga]

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I don't think you're being too much of a dick, but I do think you're slightly being a dick.

Like when I become absolutely sure someone's scum I treat them with a light touch because personally I see scum being as sacrifice to create an enjoyable mafia game for town and I wouldn't really want to compound that by smacking them around at every opportunity (see: me with Jamiet in M69)

it must be annoying having everything you do being called scummy as soon as you do it regardless of your alignment. And it invites both tunneling on your part and undesirable part on hers. I like to let my suspects breathe a little so they can show their true colors naturally

damn you're wise

[Durga]

I do feel pretty bad that she's upset but I also don't think her representation of how ghug and Eden (among others) treated her is accurate / faithful

And ghug is really bad at communications / asking questions I noticed from his and Jamiet's love tiffs

Yeah and I get that being ganged up on is frustating and terrible and PE is illogical and ghug is a bully who feels the need to comment on every single thing but she hasn't exactly been hella townie or advocating for the best moves so idkkkk

I think the various times I have pushed back on or sussed kgray have been among my more focused and logical posts this game, which is why I am interested in letting this one play out some

Couldn't tell you, I often don't read your posts if they're over 4 sentences long. I'm pretty sure you're town tho

[snowy801]

Yeah and I get that being ganged up on is frustating and terrible and PE is illogical and ghug is a bully who feels the need to comment on every single thing but she hasn't exactly been hella townie or advocating for the best moves so idkkkk

I think the various times I have pushed back on or sussed kgray have been among my more focused and logical posts this game, which is why I am interested in letting this one play out some

Couldn't tell you, I often don't read your posts if they're over 4 sentences long. I'm pretty sure you're town tho

Ain't that the tragedy

[BunnyGo]

Be nice he's trying his best

why is my fiance giving up is my question

I am not giving up, but it is obvious to me the only chance for town to win is for the JOAT or oracle to reveal my role, so it is best if I am DKed today before their scans are wasted on someone else.

Do you think the oracle will be used any time soon?

[kgray]

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

I do feel pretty bad that she's upset but I also don't think her representation of how ghug and Eden (among others) treated her is accurate / faithful

And ghug is really bad at communications / asking questions I noticed from his and Jamiet's love tiffs

Yeah and I get that being ganged up on is frustating and terrible and PE is illogical and ghug is a bully who feels the need to comment on every single thing but she hasn't exactly been hella townie or advocating for the best moves so idkkkk

I mean, I have been hella towny though. I don't think anybody here can honestly say they think I'd try to vote out an un-CC'd cop claimant as scum, or that I wouldn't be trying to do damage control or care more about acting the "right" way. Yeah, yeah, wifom and whatever. But this isn't how I play scum.

I have explained why I'm frustrated, and I'm sure you specifically know why I'm frustrated, but I'm not going to keep complaining about it because I do realize that it's town's job to question alignments so I can't expect everyone to just accept that I'm town. But at the same time, I'm struggling to care about it and there's only so much I can do.

[kgray]

@Durga why do you townread kgray?

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I mean I have seen like zero levity, so

[BunnyGo]

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I don't think you're being too much of a dick, but I do think you're slightly being a dick.

Like when I become absolutely sure someone's scum I treat them with a light touch because personally I see scum being as sacrifice to create an enjoyable mafia game for town and I wouldn't really want to compound that by smacking them around at every opportunity (see: me with Jamiet in M69)

it must be annoying having everything you do being called scummy as soon as you do it regardless of your alignment. And it invites both tunneling on your part and undesirable part on hers. I like to let my suspects breathe a little so they can show their true colors naturally

Get out of my head. I was literally saying this the last game I was in a while ago.

[Chaqa]

My problem is I don't really know how to read kgray because I've only ever been scum when she's scum, I think. Hence why I wanted to scan her.

I don't really want to vote her out today, either.

[kgray]

My problem is I don't really know how to read kgray because I've only ever been scum when she's scum, I think. Hence why I wanted to scan her.

I don't really want to vote her out today, either.

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

[ghug]

I don't I just feel bad that she's upset, yknow?

In all seriousness I can't figure her out this game. She's different than normal but I heard her scum game is top tier but this isn't exactly that. She's frustrated and showing it and I'm not sure she would necessarily do that as scum. But then again I don't know why she's frustrated as town either. So really I'm confused.

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I mean I have seen like zero levity, so

Well, the intent has been to tease, not to bully, but I understand that's a fine line, so I'm sorry and I'll cool it.

That said, though, I feel like you've spent a lot of time dismissing me unfairly, and I still see very little to suggest you're town.

[Chaqa]

My problem is I don't really know how to read kgray because I've only ever been scum when she's scum, I think. Hence why I wanted to scan her.

I don't really want to vote her out today, either.

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

oh no i scumslipped again

[Durga]

My problem is I don't really know how to read kgray because I've only ever been scum when she's scum, I think. Hence why I wanted to scan her.

I don't really want to vote her out today, either.

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

oh no i scumslipped again

This...is your response?

[kgray]

Honest assessment: am I being too much of a dick? Like my scumread is serious but I didn't think doing it with a bit of levity would go poorly.

I mean I have seen like zero levity, so

Well, the intent has been to tease, not to bully, but I understand that's a fine line, so I'm sorry and I'll cool it.

That said, though, I feel like you've spent a lot of time dismissing me unfairly, and I still see very little to suggest you're town.

I don't really think I'm being unfair when so much of your explanations for your read have been that I'm not obvtown or something equally vague. It's fine if that's just what your read is, but to make that the focus of 80% of your actual game-related content is ridiculous.

What have you seen to suggest Tom is town? Eden? Snowy? Vecna? Literally anybody else who isn't a PR claimant? You can't just have me as your top scumread me and tunnel me constantly because of POE on D2 without having extreme reasons to townread other people.

[Chaqa]

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

oh no i scumslipped again

This...is your response?

I seriously cannot help myself from doing this shit lol

@Kgray: it was true at the time, but I'm having doubts. I think I learned last game with bona to trust my gut, so you probably are town, especially if my theories on Snowy and Jasnah prove true.

[kgray]

My problem is I don't really know how to read kgray because I've only ever been scum when she's scum, I think. Hence why I wanted to scan her.

I don't really want to vote her out today, either.

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

oh no i scumslipped again

ffs Chaqa that wasn't the point

[Chaqa]

You confidently townread me like halfway through D1, saying that you know exactly how to read me because we've played together as scum so much.

oh no i scumslipped again

ffs Chaqa that wasn't the point

I'm sorry I know you told me to lay off the theater this phase while Bona and worcej do their thing, but it seemed so fun.

[Durga]

oh no i scumslipped again

ffs Chaqa that wasn't the point

I'm sorry I know you told me to lay off the theater this phase while Bona and worcej do their thing, but it seemed so fun.

LOL

[BunnyGo]

oh no i scumslipped again

ffs Chaqa that wasn't the point

I'm sorry I know you told me to lay off the theater this phase while Bona and worcej do their thing, but it seemed so fun.

The last time I was scum with you two, you did nothing BUT bus each other.

But it wasn't like this. Kgray enjoyed that.