M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

Jeez ghug if nobody's on go the fuck to sleep

What's the context for this weird comment?

He probably started to catch up and found me stonedposting alone at midnight.

Please take care.

Drug abuse can lead to rapid moral and physical decline.

[snowy801]

With the idea that the mafia might not want to scum read too many town players, I counted the number of different players everyone have voted for up to this point:

BesharamSabi: 4
Bonatogether: 6
bozo: 5
BunnyGo: 7
Chaqa: 9
damo: 7
Doom: 4
Durga: 9
Fluminator: 6
ghug: 11
Jamie: 7
jasnah: 3
kgray: 9
lfischl: 3
PE: 11
rdrivera: 2
snowy: 8
TFB: 8
Tom: 3
Vecna: 5
worcej: 3

I am interested to see how well this statistic correlates to the mafia.

##VOTE rdr

I win

It is kinda weird you've been stuck on unvote for the longest time rdrivera.
Is this behavior typical of you, would you say? What's on your mind?

[Vecna]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Hows your thinking on snowy progressed?

[snowy801]

With the idea that the mafia might not want to scum read too many town players, I counted the number of different players everyone have voted for up to this point:

BesharamSabi: 4
Bonatogether: 6
bozo: 5
BunnyGo: 7
Chaqa: 9
damo: 7
Doom: 4
Durga: 9
Fluminator: 6
ghug: 11
Jamie: 7
jasnah: 3
kgray: 9
lfischl: 3
PE: 11
rdrivera: 2
snowy: 8
TFB: 8
Tom: 3
Vecna: 5
worcej: 3

I am interested to see how well this statistic correlates to the mafia.

Is there a good way to control for activity here? This is actually a potentially interesting analysis if we can do it in a proper way. Part of me doubts it because i feel like while mafia may be reticent to target too many town players, some town players may have a proclivity to stick to their guns when they think they have someone nailed which reduces the number of switches they may have.

Am I allowed to claim TFB as mini-Snowy? I love this guy

[lfischl]

Lfischl, any strong thoughts atm?

I still don't like bozo and am leading towards eden as scum. Worcej has brought up an interesting point about sabi only wanting to vote him, my guess is sabi is town, but it would be nice to hear more about other people from them.

@worcej

[Jamiet99uk]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Who is most guilty of "sitting back" today?

Even Lfischl is posting today.

[worcej]

I find worcejs reaction extremely suspicious if jasnah is scum considering how quick he was to immediately think she must be scum from a play that makes zero sense as either alignment.

Tom, why do you think it's more likely this was an impulsive bus than an impulsive scumread of the person in a CC who he believes to not be the role they're both claiming?

Because scum are quicker to jump to conclusions given their knowledge of what is the truth (again assuming jasnah was scum). I would expect town to take longer to try to figure out who is telling the truth versus immediately assuming one or the other is being truthful.

His follow up post to immediately ending jasnah was:

"D1 is jasnah/Bunny
D2 is Bunny/jasnah
D3 we resume the game.

Looks like we got our 'boring PR game' after all lawlz

Probably should've just no-killed like I proposed."

which seemed a little like covering his tracks to me.

How are scum quicker to jump to conclusions?

Also - you absolutely are ignoring all the stated reasons I made on why I believe Bunny well above jasnah.

Also, said post was said in a lot of annoyance at how people were so anti-no killing because the game would boil down to PR only playing and then a CC took the thunder of the phase.

[Jamiet99uk]

I remember when Tom Bombadil was good at this game.

[Vecna]

What's the context for this weird comment?

He probably started to catch up and found me stonedposting alone at midnight.

Please take care.

Drug abuse can lead to rapid moral and physical decline.

You really think Ghug's morals can decline from their current point?

[worcej]

Lfischl, any strong thoughts atm?

I still don't like bozo and am leading towards eden as scum. Worcej has brought up an interesting point about sabi only wanting to vote him, my guess is sabi is town, but it would be nice to hear more about other people from them.

@worcej

Okay, so how about I ask some more specific questions:

• What do you not like about bozo?
• What do you not like about eden?
• Can you expand on the Sabi thoughts I've presented?
• How do you feel about BunnyGo?
• What is your opinion on Chaqa?

[lfischl]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Who is most guilty of "sitting back" today?

Even Lfischl is posting today.

Where did bozo go?

[TheFlyingBoat]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Who is most guilty of "sitting back" today?

Even Lfischl is posting today.

lfischl has posted a whopping 200 words this day, a lot of which say nothing and tell us nothing

[Fluminator]

Vecna, how confident are you on your kgray town read? Do you have any particular posts that pinged you?

[snowy801]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Who is most guilty of "sitting back" today?

Even Lfischl is posting today.

Where did bozo go?

While I think it's really funny that fish of all people are saying this, it's a good point
Anyone know what time zone bozo resides in? His on and off did seem pretty irregular

[Doom427]

I feel as if most of the people engaging are likely town and scum is content to sit back and let us rip each other apart

Yeah, while it's more fun to analyze what people are doing with tons of information, this is probably right. Lurkers, post more or perish.

I've been kinda lurking too, but the only thing I want to talk about is theories about people who are posting a lot, so ummm, that's that.

[Chaqa]

For some context though, here's where I'm at:

Town
BesharamSabi
Bonatogether
BunnyGo
Chaqa
Durga
Fluminator
Vecna
worcej

Contingent Town (town if an assumption I have in my head is true)
ghug
lfischl

Slight Town Lean
Doom427 (more likely scum if Eden is)
Jamiet99uk
kgray
President Eden

Null or Scum
bozotheclown
rdrivera2005
snowy801
TheFlyingBoat
Tom Bombadil

I still think you're probably town, but posting your reads in alphabetical order is very scummy.

How so?

[Chaqa]

Mostly a gut feeling for me. I just don't think he's town.

What. You can't have two reads and default to gut feeling. You need to explain them.

I don't like how eden is pushing a chaqa fake claim so hard, it makes me think that he's scum and wants all the possible PR's gone.

Wisdom oft comes from the mouth of babes...

Haven't all of the "new" players (Lfischl, Doom, Sabi, jasnah) been sus of Eden?

[Fluminator]

I remember when Tom Bombadil was good at this game.

Is your partner not performing well enough for you

[worcej]

[snip]
I'm just not seeing any world in which worcej and jasnah are scumbuddies and it concerns me that this is (I think) your strongest read in the game.

Jamie recently trolled it, but it is kinda weird how not participating Tom has been so far and how he has no real reads outside of this one at me.

[worcej]

For some context though, here's where I'm at:

Town
BesharamSabi
Bonatogether
BunnyGo
Chaqa
Durga
Fluminator
Vecna
worcej

Contingent Town (town if an assumption I have in my head is true)
ghug
lfischl

Slight Town Lean
Doom427 (more likely scum if Eden is)
Jamiet99uk
kgray
President Eden

Null or Scum
bozotheclown
rdrivera2005
snowy801
TheFlyingBoat
Tom Bombadil

I still think you're probably town, but posting your reads in alphabetical order is very scummy.

How so?

My opinion, FWIW, is it strikes me as too planned and methodical, which I think is an inherent indicator of scum fake-listing.