M70 - THE BASKIN-ROBBINS CONSPIRACY [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

@Snowy- crosspost, nvm

[Bonatogether]

@worcej stop being a dick

@ghug, on Durga

So what I think is strange isn't that someone might've thought jasnah was fake claiming. That was my immediate instinct after Bunny's claim

What is strange is her insistence that the original claim inherently showed signs of being fake, which... I don't see at all

!!!! did I imagine the part where she talked about how she'll lead town to total victory and how to follow her etc etc

yeah, that was her whole thing in her first game. she didn't do much else iirc

[Durga]

Yeah, I feel like scum deflecting would look more like Durga's reaction than Eden's.

bro I would use really strong words against you here but I'm a changed person now

What if ND was in this game?

i would not be here

[Bonatogether]

I scumlean kgruy for making comments about me pocketing her, which I recall her doing another time when she was scum recently.

[Vecna]

Maybe he's not scum, but she def isn't (or at least not for this specific play)

I'm not sure why you'd be so confident in this.

Nothing about this play makes any sense as scum

Its obviously a gambit, but that doesnt mean its not a 3d-chess openwolf gambit (yes, suck it ghug).

[Fluminator]

Is there context to the word "wolfing" I'm unaware of?

[rdrivera2005]

@worcej stop being a dick

@ghug, on Durga

So what I think is strange isn't that someone might've thought jasnah was fake claiming. That was my immediate instinct after Bunny's claim

What is strange is her insistence that the original claim inherently showed signs of being fake, which... I don't see at all

Yeah, that's my confusion too. I'm coming around to the jasnah VT, Bunny Miller idea now, but it's mostly because of how jasnah acted when she came back. I also don't see how Durga's immediate reaction wasn't to assume Bunny was the real Miller if she thought jasnah was town fucking around to begin with.

If Jasnah is town and bunny is miller there'd be a 3rd cc
I don't think we need to worry about it too much until such a claim emerges

I am having a really hard time reading this game so why you think we will have another claim if Jasnah and Bunny are both town?

[Jamiet99uk]

I stand by my view that we must kill either Jasnah or Bunny because fake-claiming Miller, as town, would be a really stupid thing to do. Jasnah has not retracted the claim as far as I can see, so we have two adamant Miller claimants. One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot.

Furthermore, I explained my thinking on all of this *before* either of them claimed, and I am sticking to my position.

[Jamiet99uk]

Yeah, that's my confusion too. I'm coming around to the jasnah VT, Bunny Miller idea now, but it's mostly because of how jasnah acted when she came back. I also don't see how Durga's immediate reaction wasn't to assume Bunny was the real Miller if she thought jasnah was town fucking around to begin with.

If Jasnah is town and bunny is miller there'd be a 3rd cc
I don't think we need to worry about it too much until such a claim emerges

I am having a really hard time reading this game so why you think we will have another claim if Jasnah and Bunny are both town?

This has already been clarified.

[Vecna]

I don't think jasnah fake claimed Miller. The fact some of yall are quick to think it's fake is awfully sus.

So you think Bunny is lying?

Are people even reading the same game?

When Jasnah says "You should believe im a townclear, whether DemonRHK (the mod of this game) knows it or not" - it clearly means she's just going full on troll-parade.

Which, in itself is all sorts of odd, because she doesnt seem the type to go on such a tangent, but it sure is interesting.

[snowy801]

Yeah, that's my confusion too. I'm coming around to the jasnah VT, Bunny Miller idea now, but it's mostly because of how jasnah acted when she came back. I also don't see how Durga's immediate reaction wasn't to assume Bunny was the real Miller if she thought jasnah was town fucking around to begin with.

If Jasnah is town and bunny is miller there'd be a 3rd cc
I don't think we need to worry about it too much until such a claim emerges

I am having a really hard time reading this game so why you think we will have another claim if Jasnah and Bunny are both town?

Like Jamiet said that was just me being an idiot. I shouldn't even be playing right now but eh, you know me

Also good, you're finally here. I need you to thread your killer instincts here because I'm not really feeling it right now

[TheFlyingBoat]

I stand by my view that we must kill either Jasnah or Bunny because fake-claiming Miller, as town, would be a really stupid thing to do. Jasnah has not retracted the claim as far as I can see, so we have two adamant Miller claimants. One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot.

Furthermore, I explained my thinking on all of this *before* either of them claimed, and I am sticking to my position.

Eh, not the dumbest thing in the world if you want to force someone who has their own timeline for a claim to a timeline you think is better. "One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot." is a ridiculous false dichotomy. Do better, Jamie.

[Vecna]

boat/vecna/bona board?

Youre only signed up for round 3. I doubt ill play round 3 (11pm starting time).

Play round 2 with me instead

yeah 1 and 2 if I can drag my carcass out of bed early enough.

Maybe if I die early in either or both games I can do round 3

[President Eden]

I stand by my view that we must kill either Jasnah or Bunny because fake-claiming Miller, as town, would be a really stupid thing to do. Jasnah has not retracted the claim as far as I can see, so we have two adamant Miller claimants. One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot.

Furthermore, I explained my thinking on all of this *before* either of them claimed, and I am sticking to my position.

jasnah hasn't formally retracted, but I think she implied that she was fakeclaiming to get PR credit here:

TBH it would have been useful to town that I become clear, subsequently everyone can vote the mafia I'm on and we easily win.

If Bunnygo is a town, he played really bad here, because town is guaranteed to win once it's accepted that I'm conf PR, doesn't matter what role DemonRHK wants to think I am

The idea being, I suppose, that the actual Miller would not counterclaim her, so she would have the added credibility of being a PR with no counterclaim.

Silly, of course, as befits her. But you can see where the appeal to such a play might be for, as Bunny put it, a "young and very clever person" (both of which I also know her to be from gunboat).

[ghug]

Is there context to the word "wolfing" I'm unaware of?

It's what people who come in from other mafia sites with dumb ideas about how the game should be played say.

[Durga]

Is there context to the word "wolfing" I'm unaware of?

It's what people who come in from other mafia sites with dumb ideas about how the game should be played say.

ghug is a known xenophobe

[Vecna]

I think the best play is still to kill Bunny because if he is town, he will drive the town into the ground, and if he's mafia, then killing him helps town

##vote bunnygo

lol, I thought u were just kidding, but did it just turn into openwolfing season?

First, don't call it wolfing. You're better than that.

Second, you need to lay off with these accusations of people openly claiming their scumminess when they do things you think are scummy. There's a difference.

Boy, youre such a sourpuss when you roll wolf. Do you camp playgrounds in your free time to steal kids soccerballs and candy canes as well?

[ghug]

Is there context to the word "wolfing" I'm unaware of?

It's what people who come in from other mafia sites with dumb ideas about how the game should be played say.

ghug is a known xenophobe

You'll recall that I once organized a wildly successful cross-site Diplomacy tournament back in the day.

I'm just disinclined to like the sort of people who are brainbomb's friends.

[ghug]

lol, I thought u were just kidding, but did it just turn into openwolfing season?

First, don't call it wolfing. You're better than that.

Second, you need to lay off with these accusations of people openly claiming their scumminess when they do things you think are scummy. There's a difference.

Boy, youre such a sourpuss when you roll wolf. Do you camp playgrounds in your free time to steal kids soccerballs and candy canes as well?

I love that you went back to respond to this after having already acknowledged it.

[Jamiet99uk]

I stand by my view that we must kill either Jasnah or Bunny because fake-claiming Miller, as town, would be a really stupid thing to do. Jasnah has not retracted the claim as far as I can see, so we have two adamant Miller claimants. One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot.

Furthermore, I explained my thinking on all of this *before* either of them claimed, and I am sticking to my position.

Eh, not the dumbest thing in the world if you want to force someone who has their own timeline for a claim to a timeline you think is better. "One of them must be scum unless we are convinced that one of them is a complete idiot." is a ridiculous false dichotomy. Do better, Jamie.

Explain this thing about timelines to me. I don't understand your point. Why would town fakeclaim Miller today?