Mini Mafia 1018 - Race with the Devil [hidden]

[BobMcBob]

kaks entrance feels fine
its a nice joke to start although it got a little more awkward as it went on
hi kak!
also the actual theorys fine for now i guess

[Maniac]

<snip> … i guess

Don’t guess. Did Einstein guess? Did Marie Curie guess? We have all the evidence in front of us to make informed decisions. We hold in our hands the power of life and death. We are executing a fellow human being and you’re leaving it to guesswork. Your coldness hurts my very core. I thought you were a reasonably moral person who when faced with a choice Sophie would struggle with would give it all the due care and consideration that it demands. You and I are no longer friends.

[Jamiet99uk]

Good day, fellow townspeople.

Why are there votes on me?

I am town.

[Jamiet99uk]

Bob McBob feels off this game.

##Vote Bob

I can’t remember when I was so triggered by so many posts D1. Considering this is a small field I could happily vote off 3 people today including Jamie.

What?

[Jamiet99uk]

Oh hi just saw this. I'm off to dinner.

In fact, both sentences in this post start with capital letters, and end in full stops.

Very unlike Bob, that is.

i've played with bob where he uses caps and no caps. this is a dumb argument

Of course it is. I'm not being serious.

The main question I have is, why did Foxcastle seem to take it so seriously?

[Jamiet99uk]

Reading Jamie In isolation it’s interesting that he provided the data about high/low posters being voted off D1 (admittedly at my instigation) but it seems that he is now using our group bias to get target a low poster with spurious reasons like ‘seems of’. Getting easy D1 kills is not pro-town. ##vote Jamie

I wouldn't describe Bob as a low poster at all. These things do not connect in the way you suggest.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ahoy, fellow townies.

This is my first post.

Allow me to declare my respect for Ghug at this point.

##vote Jamie

Very funny.

[Jamiet99uk]

Bob McBob feels off this game.

##Vote Bob

clearly omgusing right here
he also interacted with ghug
150% scum

Because only scum would OMGUS?

Please talk us through this line of thinking.

[Jamiet99uk]

In fact, both sentences in this post start with capital letters, and end in full stops.

Very unlike Bob, that is.

Huh, that does seem to be an oddity. Bob, do you have an explanation?

i legitimately just forgot because it wasnt at the front of my mind
hence my next message
also no i dont post like this anywhere else

Wait a second.

So, here Bob is telling us that he deliberately posts in a fake, crappy, poorly punctuated style when he is playing Mafia, whereas on other sites / for other purposes he writes normally and uses proper grammer and punctuation?

What is the point of that exactly?

Adopting a fake persona that you actively have to keep up, simply doesn't seem like a sensible thing to do. Y not just B normal?

[Jamiet99uk]

Bob is trying too hard.

This.

[Jamiet99uk]

i love this post so much
but seriously lfischl, you need to start having more opinions
chuck out some gut feelings at least

If one of ghug and jaime are scum then the other definitly is. If we were to vote one of them out and they were town then i think the other one would be town as well.

If I was GMing I’d be so tempted to put Ghug and Jamie in to Mafia roles with someone like Vecna. Just as an experiment to see if they could work together despite their own issues. Psychologists would write papers on it and the book and subsequent film would be the staple of marria guidance counsellors the world over.

Not that I’m casting aspersions on the wonderful GMs of course.

This would be a bad thing for the GM to do.

This is what Wjessop did.

Don't be like Wjessop.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok, time for a theory! Since the universe is always changing and everything will balance out, the player from last game will be drawn into the role of their opposite role.

Bob McBob - was town -> now maf
Bona - was town -> now maf
Vecna - was 3P -> now?
Ghug - was town -> now maf
JamieT - was maf -> now town
worcej - was maf -> now town
Maniac - was maf -> now town
Rdrivera2005 - was town -> now maf
Kakarroto - was maf -> now town
lfischl - was town -> now maf
celaph - was town -> now maf
Foxcastle - didn't participate -> now?

Though that would leave us with too many mafiosi, so I guess there are only 3 maf's in that pool, if my theory is correct. Also that would make Vecna and Fox more likely town.

So the pool would be: bob, bona, ghug, rd, lfischl, celaph. Oh, how peculiar, it's double of the 3. Yeah, it all comes together.

So then, I'll read what happened in these 11 pages and then will think about that theory more. But I think I'm close to solving this.

Is this sarcasm?

[BobMcBob]

<snip> … i guess

Don’t guess. Did Einstein guess? Did Marie Curie guess? We have all the evidence in front of us to make informed decisions. We hold in our hands the power of life and death. We are executing a fellow human being and you’re leaving it to guesswork. Your coldness hurts my very core. I thought you were a reasonably moral person who when faced with a choice Sophie would struggle with would give it all the due care and consideration that it demands. You and I are no longer friends.

this reminds me of someone from when i was a noob telling me to be less hedgy
cant quite remember who
probably because it was half the site

[BobMcBob]

Bob McBob feels off this game.

##Vote Bob

clearly omgusing right here
he also interacted with ghug
150% scum

Because only scum would OMGUS?

Please talk us through this line of thinking.

exactly, thats my foolproof line of reasoning

[BobMcBob]

Huh, that does seem to be an oddity. Bob, do you have an explanation?

i legitimately just forgot because it wasnt at the front of my mind
hence my next message
also no i dont post like this anywhere else

Wait a second.

So, here Bob is telling us that he deliberately posts in a fake, crappy, poorly punctuated style when he is playing Mafia, whereas on other sites / for other purposes he writes normally and uses proper grammer and punctuation?

What is the point of that exactly?

Adopting a fake persona that you actively have to keep up, simply doesn't seem like a sensible thing to do. Y not just B normal?

you played with me before that alien game when i started doing this
i felt like shifting my meta that game and to make it more clear i eventually started doing this
and then i didnt stop doing it

[Jamiet99uk]

clearly omgusing right here
he also interacted with ghug
150% scum

Because only scum would OMGUS?

Please talk us through this line of thinking.

exactly, thats my foolproof line of reasoning

The word "fool" probably fits in there somewhere.

[Jamiet99uk]

i legitimately just forgot because it wasnt at the front of my mind
hence my next message
also no i dont post like this anywhere else

Wait a second.

So, here Bob is telling us that he deliberately posts in a fake, crappy, poorly punctuated style when he is playing Mafia, whereas on other sites / for other purposes he writes normally and uses proper grammer and punctuation?

What is the point of that exactly?

Adopting a fake persona that you actively have to keep up, simply doesn't seem like a sensible thing to do. Y not just B normal?

you played with me before that alien game when i started doing this
i felt like shifting my meta that game and to make it more clear i eventually started doing this
and then i didnt stop doing it

well i think its wierd
you should just behave like a normal person

[BobMcBob]

Ok, time for a theory! Since the universe is always changing and everything will balance out, the player from last game will be drawn into the role of their opposite role.

Bob McBob - was town -> now maf
Bona - was town -> now maf
Vecna - was 3P -> now?
Ghug - was town -> now maf
JamieT - was maf -> now town
worcej - was maf -> now town
Maniac - was maf -> now town
Rdrivera2005 - was town -> now maf
Kakarroto - was maf -> now town
lfischl - was town -> now maf
celaph - was town -> now maf
Foxcastle - didn't participate -> now?

Though that would leave us with too many mafiosi, so I guess there are only 3 maf's in that pool, if my theory is correct. Also that would make Vecna and Fox more likely town.

So the pool would be: bob, bona, ghug, rd, lfischl, celaph. Oh, how peculiar, it's double of the 3. Yeah, it all comes together.

So then, I'll read what happened in these 11 pages and then will think about that theory more. But I think I'm close to solving this.

Is this sarcasm?

i mean its either that or kak has a serious case of gamblers fallacy

[BobMcBob]

Wait a second.

So, here Bob is telling us that he deliberately posts in a fake, crappy, poorly punctuated style when he is playing Mafia, whereas on other sites / for other purposes he writes normally and uses proper grammer and punctuation?

What is the point of that exactly?

Adopting a fake persona that you actively have to keep up, simply doesn't seem like a sensible thing to do. Y not just B normal?

you played with me before that alien game when i started doing this
i felt like shifting my meta that game and to make it more clear i eventually started doing this
and then i didnt stop doing it

well i think its wierd
you should just behave like a normal person

maybe i should
maybe ill change back next game
maybe ill hold a vote

[BobMcBob]

Because only scum would OMGUS?

Please talk us through this line of thinking.

exactly, thats my foolproof line of reasoning

The word "fool" probably fits in there somewhere.

yeah, right before proof
would you prefer me to vote somewhere else?
who do you scumread?